USA:
http://www.mapsofworld.com/usa/usa-maps/maps_of_world_usa_states_city.gif
Now apart from a few Islands the rest of the mandlass of the USA is across one large area.
China:
http://www.mapsofworld.com/china/maps/china.jpg
India:
http://www.mapsofworld.com/india/maps/india-political-map.jpg
The same applies for both China and India, although in all these countries the territory is vast it is continuous. There are no massive gaps, now look at Pakistan and then look at Bangladesh. Whats in the way? Yes thats India m8.
Totally different situation, your the one who aint got a clue.
Producing maps is not the answer. What has the Andamanese common with, let us say, the Punjabis of India? Yet they are Indians! And there are huge distances separating them!
Gaps are also no answer.
It is not I who has no clue, it is you who is clueless since you are looking at the spatial difference alone. National feeling is not only based on distances. It is based on congruity in religious, cultural, social and other affinities.
The unfortunate part is that you are superficial in vision and that is what makes it difficult.
Culture ,values etc change and are different in every country. I have tried to explain this to you but I don't see why you can't grasp this simple concept.
And yet the are subjugated for national feeling, abstract as it may appear!
Pakistan is seperated by thousands of miles land from Bangladesh, the culture is very different, so are the people. As such there is no way Bangladesh should ever be part of Pakistan.
How is the Punjabi culture same as the Balochi. Sindhi or Pashtun?
Pakistan's internal problems have nothing to do with whether Bangladesh should be part of Pakistan.
And why not?
On the one hand you say distance is what made Bengalis alien and yet on the other hand you dismiss the current ethnic/ subnational problems of Pakistan, even though distance is not an issue! Make up your mind.
For the reasons I have said above, Jinnah was wrong. He is a man, we all make mistakes. Don't worship men or think they are perfect just because they have achieved outstanding things, at the end of the day they are still human with all there weaknesses and fragile nature.
I am glad you admit that Jinnah was wrong and he did not understand the issues involved as you have so clearly understood! I am sure the majority of Pakistanis would not agree with you since it is an insulting thought!
Yes, he was human and you are not!
May I request you not to demean Jinnah even if he is wrong!
ahh now I understand your reasoning. You want a wider ummah..
Well to hell with that idea, never gonna hapen m8. Not in this world, only in the dreams of religious men.
Pakistan wasn't formed to be a Caliphate or to be governed under Shariah law.
I don't. The Quaran says so!
I reckon that you should accept it as the word of Allah!
Or you wish to be the rationale man?