What's new

Budget deficit to climb over Rs1 trn

indian dream

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Apr 8, 2011
Messages
203
Reaction score
0
ISLAMABAD: For the first time in the history of the Islamic Republic the difference between what the government spent over the past twelve months and what the government managed to collect will cross Rs1,000,000,000,000.

Prime Minister Syed Yusuf Raza Gilani in his first speech as prime minister had introduced a number of austerity measures: PM Secretariat’s budget will be cut by a wholesome 40 percent; all ministers will travel economy class; no minister will travel in a car of more than 1600 cc.

On 26 December 2009, PM Gilani had constituted a Special Committee to “prioritize and oversee the implementation process of the austerity measures.” On 21 December 2010, a meeting of the cabinet, presided by PM Gilani, approved “major austerity measures.”

Twelve months ago, our budget drafters had expected net revenue receipts of Rs1.37 trillion and current expenditures of Rs1.99 trillion-the budgetary deficit was set at Rs685 billion. Over the past twelve months, two things have happened: First, current expenditures at the Cabinet Division, the Prime Minister’s Secretariat and the Household Allowances of the President have all gone through the roof. Second, there has been a massive shortfall in revenue receipts.

Twelve months ago, the Government of Pakistan (GOP) and the International Monetary Fund (IMF) had agreed on a budget deficit target of around 4 percent of GDP. Over the past twelve months, the GOP has ended up spending in excess of Rs1 trillion over and above its receipts and, as a consequence, the budget deficit may have crossed 7 percent of GDP.

Figure fudging at Block Q of Pak Secretariat, according to some insiders, is now in full swing. If the wizards at the Ministry of Finance can somehow inflate the GDP the budget deficit as a percentage of the GDP will look much, much smaller than it really is. That will be the best of both worlds-we will have a swollen GDP, pumped-up per capita income and a half bearable budgetary deficit. Only if wishes were horses, beggars would ride.

At Block Q midnight oil is once again being burnt. Budget 2011-2012 is scheduled to be announced in a week’s time. Once again we will have inflated revenue receipts, a healthy developmental allocation, a constrained steam of expenses and an awfully alluring budgetary deficit. At Block Q the motto is: A life spent making mistakes is not only more honorable but more useful than a life spent making real budgets.

Budget deficit to climb over Rs1 trn
 
$11 Billion deficit is not the end of the world but it is a concern for sure.
 
a good leadership + pakistani nation can solve this problem .. as pakistanis are the highest charity payer according to per capita income .

Highest charity but lowest tax payers. Budget deficit cannot be solved by charity as tax collected is what goes towards the country and not the charity.
 
It was a very short written finance article about countrys budget, its spending and the deficit. But this paragraph overly simplified the problem,

Twelve months ago, our budget drafters had expected net revenue receipts of Rs1.37 trillion and current expenditures of Rs1.99 trillion-the budgetary deficit was set at Rs685 billion. Over the past twelve months, two things have happened: First, current expenditures at the Cabinet Division, the Prime Minister’s Secretariat and the Household Allowances of the President have all gone through the roof. Second, there has been a massive shortfall in revenue receipts.

I'm not disputing the amount mentioned as deficit but rather how in one short paragraph the written summed up the reason behind it. It's a lot more complicated process than just blaming PM' s cabinet spending. In the past 12 months we saw some of the worst floods in the country, then your "regular" terrorism problem and spendings on initiating of many energy related projects that won't see any returns for years. Once again I'm not disputing the deficit number but they should do some more research before writing such intricate articles.
 
1 trillion rupees is $11 billion. If you compare it to the past 15-20 years, I believe Pakistan had a budget deficit much higher before than it is now. But it has gotten worse since Musharraf left. However, Ramu is right when he says $11 billion is not the end of the world. More reasons to get out of the WOT asap.
 
thats fine we are still less then USA. Can someone ask Mr.10% to release some funds!!
 
India isn't doing too great either on the Budget Deficit department for 2011. The budget deficit is expressed as a % of the GDP in the "Value" column in the lists below:

http://www.photius.com/rankings/economy/budget_deficit_pct_of_gdp_2011_0.html

Budget Deficit % of GDP 2011 Country Ranks, By Rank

Rank Country Value Date of Info
1 Marshall Islands 673.90 2008
2 Ireland 37.96 2009 est.
3 Maldives 26.94 2009 est.
4 Iraq 23.29 2010 est.
5 Bhutan 20.47 FY09/10
6 Eritrea 20.26 2009 est.
7 West Bank 18.52 2009
8 Azerbaijan 15.91 2009 est.
9 Afghanistan 13.83 FY09/10 est.
10 Botswana 13.78 2009 est.
11 Sierra Leone 13.41 2000 est.
12 Swaziland 13.18 2009 est.
13 Niue 12.59 NA
14 Lesotho 12.48 2009 est.
15 Algeria 12.01 2009 est.
16 Chad 11.68 2009 est.
17 Kyrgyzstan 10.80 2009 est.
18 Nepal 10.59 FY10
19 Congo, Democratic Republic of the 10.32 2006 est.
20 Cape Verde 10.18 2009 est.
21 Tuvalu 10.11 2006
22 United Kingdom 10.06 2009 est.
23 Tonga 9.74 FY07/08 est.
24 Spain 9.66 2009 est.
25 Greece 9.40 2009 est.
26 Jordan 8.96 2009 est.
27 United States 8.93 2009 est.
28 Ghana 8.34 2009 est.
29 Lithuania 8.34 2009 est.
30 Egypt 8.01 2009 est.
31 Poland 7.90 2009 est.
32 Latvia 7.85 2009 est.
33 France 7.83 2009 est.
34 Sri Lanka 7.80 2009 est.
35 Madagascar 7.80 2009 est.
36 Japan 7.66 2009 est.
37 Slovakia 7.60 2009 est.
38 Jamaica 7.52 2009 est.
39 Portugal 7.42 2009 est.
40 Namibia 7.34 2009 est.
41 Saint Lucia 7.24 2000 est.
42 Romania 7.01 2009 est.
43 Guinea 6.94 2009 est.
44 Iceland 6.76 2009 est.
45 Vietnam 6.74 2009 est.
46 Georgia 6.62 2009 est.
47 South Africa 6.52 2009 est.
48 Slovenia 6.40 2009 est.
49 Ukraine 6.30 2009 est.
50 Grenada 6.29 1997
51 Kenya 6.26 2009 est.
52 Pakistan 6.24 2009 est.
53 Armenia 6.16 2009 est.
54 Tanzania 6.16 2009 est.
55 Burundi 6.12 2009 est.
56 American Samoa 6.10 FY07
57 Cambodia 6.07 2009 est.
58 India 6.06 2009 est.
59 Malaysia 6.04 2009 est.
60 Benin 5.90 2009 est.

Pakistan did A LOT LOT better than India in 2010:

Budget Deficit % of GDP 2010 Country Ranks, By Rank

1 Marshall Islands 673.90 2008
2 West Bank 21.83 2006
2 Gaza Strip 21.83 2006
3 Eritrea 20.27 2009 est.
4 Bhutan 19.16 2005
5 Iraq 18.54 2009 est.
6 Afghanistan 16.52 2007 est.
7 Maldives 15.11 2008 est.
8 United Kingdom 14.20 2009 est.
9 Iceland 13.66 2009 est.
10 Ireland 13.13 2009 est.
11 Sierra Leone 12.35 2000 est.
12 Jamaica 12.03 2009 est.
13 Yemen 12.02 2009 est.
14 United States 11.92 2009 est.
15 Jordan 11.87 2009 est.
16 Congo, Democratic Republic of the 11.71 2006 est.
17 Tonga 11.32 FY07/08
18 Nepal 11.23 FY08
19 Botswana 11.04 2009 est.
20 Latvia 10.95 2009 est.
21 Greece 10.79 2009 est.
22 Azerbaijan 10.75 2009 est.
23 Ghana 10.68 2009 est.
24 Lebanon 10.58 2009 est.
25 Spain 10.51 2009 est.
26 Tuvalu 10.11 2006
27 Lithuania 9.82 2009 est.
28 Vietnam 9.30 2009 est.
29 Georgia 8.83 2009 est.
30 Sri Lanka 8.66 2009 est.
31 Guyana 8.63 2009 est.
32 Chad 8.34 2009 est.
33 France 8.20 2009 est.
34 Russia 8.07 2009 est.
35 India 8.07 2009 est.
36 Malaysia 7.77 2009 est.
37 Mozambique 7.63 2009 est.
38 Venezuela 7.61 2009 est.
39 Japan 7.59 2009 est.
40 Syria 7.58 2009 est.
41 Saint Kitts and Nevis 7.04 2003 est.
42 Burkina Faso 7.02 2009 est.
43 Madagascar 7.01 2009 est.
44 Ukraine 6.93 2009 est.
45 Lesotho 6.90 2009 est.
46 Portugal 6.78 2009 est.
47 Egypt 6.78 2009 est.
48 Moldova 6.78 2009 est.
49 Romania 6.68 2009 est.
50 Turkey 6.60 2009 est.
51 Cape Verde 6.60 2009 est.
52 New Zealand 6.41 2009 est.
53 Kenya 6.29 2009 est.
54 Tunisia 6.26 2009 est.
55 Cuba 6.26 2009 est.
56 American Samoa 6.10 FY07
57 Benin 6.09 2009 est.
58 Slovenia 5.97 2009 est.
59 Armenia 5.87 2009 est.
60 Namibia 5.83 2009 est.
61 Austria 5.77 2009 est.
62 Malta 5.74 2009 est.
63 Mongolia 5.70 2008
64 Belgium 5.63 2009 est.
65 Albania 5.45 2009 est.
66 Thailand 5.42 2009 est.
67 Trinidad and Tobago 5.39 2009 est.
68 Bangladesh 5.32 2009 est.
69 Slovakia 5.24 2009 est.
70 Italy 5.16 2009 est.
71 Cambodia 5.16 2009 est.
72 Taiwan 4.98 2009 est.
73 Northern Mariana Islands 4.74 FY01/02 est.
74 Czech Republic 4.71 2009 est.
75 Israel 4.70 2009 est.
76 Netherlands 4.70 2009 est.
77 Nigeria 4.59 2009 est.
78 Burma 4.57 2009 est.
79 El Salvador 4.53 2009 est.
80 Senegal 4.51 2009 est.
81 Bosnia and Herzegovina 4.46 2009 est.
82 Korea, South 4.46 2009 est.
83 Cyprus 4.44 2009 est.
84 Nicaragua 4.40 2009 est.
85 Germany 4.39 2009 est.
86 Chile 4.36 2009 est.
87 Djibouti 4.32 1999 est.
88 Luxembourg 4.15 2009 est.
89 Estonia 4.15 2009 est.
90 Tanzania 4.12 2009 est.
91 Pakistan 4.11 2009 est.
92 Guatemala 4.09 2009 est.
93 South Africa 4.09 2009 est.
 
Highest charity but lowest tax payers. Budget deficit cannot be solved by charity as tax collected is what goes towards the country and not the charity.

i just want to show you the fact that this nation can solve there problem on their own as we get the good leadership like imran khan people will agree to give more taxes and will help this country to come out from this economic mess credited by corrupt leaders .. remember billions of dollars are being payed by pakistanis in zakat and in other charity funds . all we need is good leadership.
 
Back
Top Bottom