BSP MP Insults Vande Mataram in Lok Sabha

[Abu Zolfiqar]

The contents of the "song" or whatever goes in contrast to teachings of Islam so inevitably many more observant Muslims would take offense to it. Many school children refuse to sing it also.

Not just Muslims but even some Christians in the country

 

[livingdead]

The contents of the "anthem" or whatever goes in contrast to teachings of Islam so inevitably many more observant Muslims would take offense to it. Many school children refuse to sing it also.

Not just Muslims but even some Christians in the country

Never heard about christians opposing, where did you get that info?

 

[ExtraOdinary]

If it is his religion not to bow he should not be forced but he should have shown some respect.
The disturbing thing about Vande Mataram is, it is part of a novel Anand Math which is quite offensive to muslims.
If you guys have time, please read it. It describes british as saviour from the cluches of barbaric muslims.

I find it weird that it was chosen for freedom struggle.

If that was the case why the heck would the British ban it

 

[livingdead]

If that was the case why the heck would the British ban it

I have no idea. Why dont you read yourself if you dont believe me. Its not that big book, can be finished in one sitting.

 

[ExtraOdinary]

I have no idea. Why dont you read yourself if you dont believe me. Its not that big book, can be finished in one sitting.

Have you read it?

 

[IndoUS]

The contents of the "song" or whatever goes in contrast to teachings of Islam so inevitably many more observant Muslims would take offense to it. Many school children refuse to sing it also.

Not just Muslims but even some Christians in the country

Christians have no problem with the song , we use to sing every year during independence day.

 

[livingdead]

Have you read it?

yes................................

 

[Glitcher]

can you tell exact meaning of that word plz ?

 

[ExtraOdinary]

can you tell exact meaning of that word plz ?

Vande Mataram means "mother I bow to thee". I think it's in Bengali language

 

[Glitcher]

Vande Mataram means "mother I bow to thee". I think it's in Bengali language

oh it is offensive Muslims bow to Only Allmighty Allah not even Prophet Muhammad

 

[ExtraOdinary]

oh it is offensive Muslims bow to Only Allmighty Allah not even Prophet Muhammad

Nobody is asking him to sing the song. But he shud'nt have walked out in the middle, you should give respect to earn respect.

 

[Rajaraja Chola]

And another Patriotic Muslim remixed and re-released this song, which was one of the best national songs ever, by none other than AR Rehman.
He should have given respect atleast.

 

[Glitcher]

Nobody is asking him to sing the song. But he shud'nt have walked out in the middle, you should give respect to earn respect.

Agreed on that as long as it dosent abuse Islam or Muslim he should show respect after all it is national song Just like all the religeon has to be respected even if you dont agree with them

 

[Ayush]

the fool shouldnt have walked out..

 

[Mitro]

Actually he is hiding the truth that "He was about to Sh$$ in his pants"

Wondering which other song they play in Parliament i mean Item song Like Chuli ke niche kyahai,Fevicol se,Chatav ki chammaz se chat, wagara wagara

And why to play the Vande matram song thats offend member of other religion like Muslim and sikh.Constitution is more supreme then this national song which gives freedom to every indian to practice its religion.If you get offended with his behavior then you don't have any right to offend him in first place by playing this song written in 1882 .

Did they ever play Song from Iqbal Sare Jaha se acha hindustan hamara in our parliament. and does it qualify in National song .