Border Killings by BSF Frustrates Dhaka

[bd_4_ever]

what price?
Care to elaborate?

I dont have to elaborate...am sure you are intelligent enough to comprehend the meaning...


Cheers!!!

 

[deckingraj]

Reducing Illegal immigrants does not mean you should start killing them.

Very true...

Your bharati govt failed to act.

Very true

onus is on you to deport them if you cant then be sure your killer BSF is just getting bribes and letting them in. those who dont pay they are shot dead by BSF killers

Even if BSF is taking bribes and letting people in, how does this justify rest of the people who are coming in without bribing BSF???? Secondly do you know the amount of Illegal trade b/w India and Pakistan??? I hope you can see holy Rangers are not that holy either....

In short criticism is welcome but blind criticism is not good. Illegal immigration is a serious threat especially for developing nations because these nations are not able to take care of millions of their own...Jumping barbed wire is no circus acrobat where audience will clap once your show is over....I would request members to keep that in mind as well....

 

[Punjabbi Munda]

I dont have to elaborate...am sure you are intelligent enough to comprehend the meaning...


Cheers!!!

maybe BD will conquer India?!

 

[fallstuff]

These same Indian posters were whining after Sri Lankan Navy shot dead so called Indian fishermen in SL water.

Sri Lanka has more bal*s than BD border guards.

 

[saleen_s7]

maybe BD will conquer India?!

By killing innocent civilians and intruding our lands illegally, you are instigating the nationalist side of our country. When BNP or Jamaat comes to power, few people will start torturing the hindus or kill a few of your bsf and soo on. When that does happen, don't blame it on us for it as your the one to instigate it.

 

[Paan Singh]

These same Indian posters were whining after Sri Lankan Navy shot dead so called Indian fishermen in SL water.

Sri Lanka has more bal*s than BD border guards.

every body have same number of b****

 

[Punjabbi Munda]

By killing innocent civilians and intruding our lands illegally, you are instigating the nationalist side of our country. When BNP or Jamaat comes to power, few people will start torturing the hindus or kill a few of your bsf and soo on. When that does happen, don't blame it on us for it as your the one to instigate it.

For you islam is everything.
ARen't those hindus bangladeshi's?

That's why i sometimes start hating islam.

 

[Ganga]

Repeated attempts made by Bangladeshi nationals to enter India illegally is frustrating too.Frustration is there on both sides.We already have a population crisis and we don't want more burden.

 

[bd_4_ever]

In short criticism is welcome but blind criticism is not good. Illegal immigration is a serious threat especially for developing nations because these nations are not able to take care of millions of their own...Jumping barbed wire is no circus acrobat where audience will clap once your show is over....I would request members to keep that in mind as well....

Ok, even if i buy your point...our logic still stands. In simple words, BSF is not that naive to recognize the fact that she is not harmful...they could have kept her in jail and later released her on a flag meeting or even demand ransom for that matter...but i do not understand why you have to go above your limits and kill her for no reason...

Many of the Indians portray the 'illegal migration' as the reason...well for one, you dont have to kill a 15 year old girl for that purpose because she aint stealing away your treasures...BSF could have simply followed regular norms and just detained her...but why kill....?


Cheers!!!

 

[majesticpankaj]

Ok, even if i buy your point...our logic still stands. In simple words, BSF is not that naive to recognize the fact that she is not harmful...they could have kept her in jail and later released her on a flag meeting or even demand ransom for that matter...but i do not understand why you have to go above your limits ans kill her for no reason...

Many of the Indians portray the 'illegal migration' as reason...well for one, you dont have to kill a 15 year old girl for that purpose because she aint stealing away your treasures...BSF could have simply followed regular norms and just detained her...but why kill....?


Cheers!!!

I am with BD on these... BSF should take extreme precaution before killing any unarmed person. after all it is a loss to humanity

 

[LaBong]

They shouldn't have killed her. Indians stop justifying the incident, it was a gruesome event. She was just a kid and wasn't a threat by any means.

 

[Bang Galore]

Ok, even if i buy your point...our logic still stands. In simple words, BSF is not that naive to recognize the fact that she is not harmful...they could have kept her in jail and later released her on a flag meeting or even demand ransom for that matter...but i do not understand why you have to go above your limits ans kill her for no reason...

Many of the Indians portray the 'illegal migration' as reason...well for one, you dont have to kill a 15 year old girl for that purpose because she aint stealing away your treasures...BSF could have simply followed regular norms and just detained her...but why kill....?


Cheers!!!

You make a fair point. The death of this young girl is something that most of us regret. However you must understand & appreciate a few things. The fence that has been constructed about 140m within India's international border using Indian taxpayer money is there for a reason. To keep out illegal immigrants & smugglers! It serves the BSF if the people in question saw them as a violent trigger happy force. Fear is the primary reason to not risk crossing the fence. If the BSF only caught & released as you have suggested, there would be many more attempts to cross over because the risk of doing so & getting caught would be perceived as less. The BSF simply cannot man the entire border & prevent such attempts without necessarily using force. I understand that from your viewpoint & others(including the American right group that was mentioned) this looks like excessive force & the BSF might look heartless & callous but that probably is the image that the BSF wants & needs to man the border effectively. I wish it were not so but unfortunately we do not live in an ideal world & therefore whatever the opinions of Bangladeshis on this matter, the BSF would most likely continue this policy for quite some time.

 

[bd_4_ever]

You make a fair point. The death of this young girl is something that most of us regret. However you must understand & appreciate a few things. The fence that has been constructed about 140m within India's international border using Indian taxpayer money is there for a reason. To keep out illegal immigrants & smugglers! It serves the BSF if the people in question saw them as a violent trigger happy force. Fear is the primary reason to not risk crossing the fence. If the BSF only caught & released as you have suggested, there would be many more attempts to cross over because the risk of doing so & getting caught would be perceived as less. The BSF simply cannot man the entire border & prevent such attempts without necessarily using force. I understand that from your viewpoint & others(including the American right group that was mentioned) this looks like excessive force & the BSF might look heartless & callous but that probably is the image that the BSF wants & needs to man the border effectively. I wish it were not so but unfortunately we do not live in an ideal world & therefore whatever the opinions of Bangladeshis on this matter, the BSF would most likely continue this policy for quite some time.

Well, if what you mentioned has weight and is authentic...then its a sad scenario. I personally do not think killing should be an option. Serving in the national security or armed forces should not only mean to protect the country, but also to have respect for humanity...the one you kill is also someone's father, mother, son, daughter etc...and they will be weeping over the fact that someone on the other side of the border has sworn to protect his nation and create fear by killing their dear ones...however, i am sorry i cannot agree with the fact that killing should mean to spread fear and stop such incidents...you can see, i can see that its not working out...there should be a moderate way to solve things...

Our govt. has frankly failed to reach a conclusion regarding this and i fear more lives will be taken due to the leaders' irresponsibility...


Cheers!!!

 

[JanjaWeed]

This incident is real unfortunate & tragic.
However!! don't BD have a force guarding their side of the border?? If yes.. why did they let the girl sneek through in the first place??

 

[Bang Galore]

...you can see, i can see that its not working out...there should be a moderate way to solve things...

Our govt. has frankly failed to reach a conclusion regarding this and i fear more lives will be taken due to the leaders' irresponsibility...

There can be a solution. Why do so many Bangladeshis risk so much & come to India? They do so to make a better life for themselves & their families. Some sort of work permit in limited numbers seems to be the best option. For that to happen fanboy fantasies of conquering Assam & W.Bengal by demographic changes have to be quietly buried because these states would be the most reluctant to accept any Bangladeshis. The Bangladeshi government routinely refuses to accept Bangladeshi citizens caught by the BSF as their own resulting in the BSF using deadly force to police the border. Do you think that the father of the girl is the only Bangladeshi to be working in Delhi or elsewhere in India? The refusal to accept the truth of illegal immigration, including by many here renders any solution impossible. If you do not accept that there is a problem, how on earth are you going to solve it? The Bangladesh government needs to sit across with their Indian counterparts & sort out this issue. For that to happen friendship & trust between the two is a prerequisite, something that most posters here from BD are allergic to. The girl died because many in your country refuse to face up to the facts & instead take refuge in rhetoric.