Book Review : The Indian Doctrine

[Adux]

Off topic,

He is talking about the difference between Knowledge and Wisdom

 

[PakSniper]

Off topic,

He is talking about the difference between Knowledge and Wisdom

Ahcha aduxji, sometimes its difficult understanding how Indian's put things down. Cause from his post he was talking about UK education, etc.

 

[Adux]

Sniperji,

I was talking about Mark Twain...lol,

About this Thread, the less said the better...lol

 

[con]

Off topic, that is the stupidest quote I have ever read. And alot of arguments can me made as to why it is.

Mate, those quotes from Mark Twain are the gems which men of wisdom has given to this world.
Sadly schooling provides knowledge,not wisdom! Be it UK or India or Pakistan.

sorry for going off topic.

 

[BanglaBhoot]

On another thread you accused (A Pakistani member) of being a liar simply because his view differed from yours.

This is a blatant lie. I have not made any comment in any other thread.

A point to note is that Mr. Munshi indicates that he is born and educated in UK. This would mean he would have never been exposed to the actual dynamics of the sub-continent for most of his. He does not seem to have a history of being physically present in the sub-continent consistently nor can claim to have the authority that comes by being part of the Bangladesh establishment, where he would be having interacting with the Indian gov teams. This is proved by his statement that "he has heard" that Indian delegation behaves irrationality. People "sitting" in UK have a different view of the countries in sub-continent. Hence I am not surprised about all these theories proposed by Mr. Munshi

Wrong on all counts. I was actually born in Bangladesh in 1972 but my parents took me to the UK when I was 9 months old in May of 1973 as my father when to pursue further education leading to an FRCS degree. I remained there for another 24 years and graduated with an LLM from the London School of Economics and qualified as a barrister in 1994. I returned to Bangladesh in 1997 and remained here ever since. In other words I am highly conversant with the dynamics of South Asia.

I believe that the Indian writers on this forum are out to sabotage discussion. I am amazed that they can spend the whole day writing on Pakistan Defence and sometimes they appear in rotation. Do none of these guys actually have employment or are they paid to write on this forum by some agency. I think these issues should be explored.

While I agree some of my comments can be off colour this is in direct response to some of the despicable comments aimed at me. I am prepared to give as I get but my method of retort will of course be of a higher quality and standard and be witty at the same time. It is unfortunate that the Indian writers on this forum are doing a serious discredit to their nation by the manner of their behaviour. Someone not from South Asia would presume from their comments that these Indians must be semi-literate or exceptionally dull. Is that the impression Indian writers wish to give to the outside world. If that is the case, I guess who are we to complain?

I hope that Bull will not miss the irony and sarcasm in that last statement. I am sure the other Indian writers will.

 

[kidwaibhai]

this might be off topic but you graduated from LSE that is awsome.

 

[Keysersoze]

This is a blatant lie. I have not made any comment in any other thread.

Heres a few examples of what you have written.

"Personal experience is nothing more then bullshit and a straight lie..........

When you enter discussion and start accusing religious organistaions, you must have a proof. I leave your matter to MODS."

Please support your statement by a link.............

Utter lie and false statement, yes MP's in Pakistan help guys to get visas, but it never happened that some one was sent with tablighi jamat, your statement is false and baseless.

If you can not support your allegations about Tablighi Jamat, I would request MODS to give you a break to come in to senses.

When ever the pathatic behaviour of your home land comes in, you guys take shelter behind Pakistan, what a rubbish and moronic attitude.

And of course now you have just accused me of being a liar......



https://defence.pk/forums/showthread.php?t=4737&page=2

 

[Keysersoze]

this might be off topic but you graduated from LSE that is awsome.

Dude wait until you meet some people from LSE I have and was NOT impressed.

 

[Contrarian]

Dude, Key, you have quoted from posts made by MirBadshah...

 

[Keysersoze]

Dude, Key, you have quoted from posts made by MirBadshah...

lol so I have.......oops

Ah well..........

 

[indiapakistanfriendship]

Dear Mr. Munshi Try what you may.. but one's gonna listen to what you spell out.....Educated in LSE huh???? I severly doubt it.....LLM huh???? you must have learnt that you need to put facts before your argument rather than plain jane conspiracy theory......

By the way .. who's reading your article or your book or your work

You and those who have colluded with you seem to be burnt out academics trying to attract attention atleast with lay people and conspiracy looneys.. because no good minded well established academic will ever waste his time listening to you

 

[BanglaBhoot]

So in the end Key has been found out to be making completely false accusations against me when he was actually quoting from MirBadshah. Con was also completely wrong about me on all counts.

Since I have disclosed my background may we know the biographical data of the Indian writers on this thread. Beware if you make something up someone will know so don't be caught out again.

 

[EagleEyes]

Ok since the discussions going on is related to who posted what, and how he posted, and why he posted and NOT related to the topic. The thread is getting closed.

Please create a new one if you wish to.

Regards.