Book Review : The Indian Doctrine

[con]

This is unmistakably a death threat. The first and last sentence when taken together imply some physical harm to me by RAW. Although you may have no power over RAW the fact that you implied such a thing cannot be taken lightly. All the Indian writers on this forum realizing the implications of this have suddenly backtracked or deflected the issue. It is unfortunate that you have resorted to such intimidatory tactics.

Christ!
I have no words!

I never knew that RAW would scare people so much,that too on a forum!

 

[Adux]

Con,

Dont you just love it when he says, Combining the First and the last sentences, he sees a death threat...classic conspiracy theory junkie.

heck we should all take a page of a newspaper. Eliminate sentences we dont like, and cut it here and there. And see what it means in the end. Maybe there is a hidden message to the people of Zion from Neo, or maybe the Free Masons have secret messages for their Secret Allies.

 

[con]

Con,

Dont you just love it when he says, Combining the First and the last sentences, he sees a death threat...classic conspiracy theory junkie.

heck we should all take a page of a newspaper. Eliminate sentences we dont like, and cut it here and there. And see what it means in the end. Maybe there is a hidden message to the people of Zion from Neo, or maybe the Free Masons have secret messages for their Secret Allies.

I have concluded that Mr.Munshi REALLY does believe RAW can do anything!

 

[Keysersoze]

This is unmistakably a death threat. The first and last sentence when taken together imply some physical harm to me by RAW. Although you may have no power over RAW the fact that you implied such a thing cannot be taken lightly. All the Indian writers on this forum realizing the implications of this have suddenly backtracked or deflected the issue. It is unfortunate that you have resorted to such intimidatory tactics.

If RAW is assassinating people for posting on the interent then they must have a loooooooooooooong list of people to get through

Keep chatting away dude this is the funniest thread I have seen in while!

 

[Contrarian]

I have one question...

Does Munshi actually BELIEVE these things with all heart and soul that he fails to see any and all logic to the contrary?

Or

He is trying to pull one over us

Or

He is completely delusional?

 

[Adux]

If RAW is assassinating people for posting on the interent then they must have a loooooooooooooong list of people to get through

Keep chatting away dude this is the funniest thread I have seen in while!

Amen to that!!!!!!

 

[con]

If RAW is assassinating people for posting on the interent then they must have a loooooooooooooong list of people to get through

Keep chatting away dude this is the funniest thread I have seen in while!

Fear the all knowing, whose sight no human can hide.... the evil RAW

 

[BanglaBhoot]

Of course I do not believe that RAW would actually try to assassinate me but the proposition of the threat by Con shows that the Indian writers on this forum have no honour or integrity and are actually a bunch of cowards who will resort to intimidation to win an argument that they have no chance of winning. I would like my Indian opponents and other subscribers to this forum to look at the following qoutation taken provide some opinions upon RAW's assassination policy -

Zainul Abedin in his book ‘Raw and Bangladesh’ makes the following statement in Chapter 30, “A noted Indian parliamentarian Mr. Subramanium Swamy, provided important insight about RAW’s plan to assassinate Ziaur Rahman. He stated in an interview given to the weekly magazine ‘Sunday’, ‘RAW had plotted the assassination of President Ziaur Rahman with ‘approval from Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Mr. R.N. Kao, the RAW Chief and Shankaran Nair, a senior official of RAW had plotted to kill General Ziaur Rahman. The scheme was already at an advanced stage with Mrs. Gandhi’s approval. But the Congress government fell and Mr. Morarji Desai became Prime Minister. Mr. Desai was appalled to learn about assassination plan. He called halt to the murder plot. The RAW warned the Prime Minister that it was too late to back out now and that many RAW assets would be endangered if the plan was aborted at this stage. However, Desai remained adamant and finally RAW abandoned the assassination.’ Mr. Subramanium Swami commented, ‘Zia was assassinated after Indira Gandhi returned to power but India said that she was not involved.” See also Abu Rushd – RAW in Bangladesh (2005) Chapter 7 pp. 68-71

See also -

http://www.moneyandpolitics.net/news/pdf/newsBangladesh-08-02-06-TheNewNation.pdf

http://209.85.165.104/search?q=cach....html+RAW+and+Ziaur+Rahman&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=2

 

[kidwaibhai]

with all due respect sir i think every intelligence agency is involved in asasination attempts all though our stupid ISI has not yet done so with so many WACOS running around in pakistan and the greatest country ever the "ISLAMIC REPUBLIC OF AFGHANISTAN". i really do think sir that you are being highly sensitve. gog knows i have said stuff much worse than that to many indians here but they all take it as a joke i sincierly hope Sir that you do the same.
P.S dont really like afghans since the americans came they blame us for everything.

 

[EagleEyes]

Before we proceed any further in this debate I suggest that all the Indian writers who have taken part in this thread to take a course in English. I feel there is a serious lack of comprehension on their part or it might simply be deliberate. There is a tendency for them to pick up on certain things and completely ignore the vital issues. I have heard this is also the method of diplomacy adopted by the Indian government hence the persistent misunderstandings with its neighbours. When the Indian writers are incapable of answering in a coherent manner the questions raised by me or others they resort to insults and even death threats. Under these circumstances how will we in South Asia ever be able to achieve common understanding with India when they clearly have no intention of engaging in discussion or debate in a civilized and rational manner.

I now have to contend with Bull on exactly the same areas that I have covered with Con but I am really not inclined to do so until the Indian writers on this forum show some integrity and intellectual honesty.

Agreed. Whole heartedly!

 

[Keysersoze]

Before we proceed any further in this debate I suggest that all the Indian writers who have taken part in this thread to take a course in English. I feel there is a serious lack of comprehension on their part or it might simply be deliberate. There is a tendency for them to pick up on certain things and completely ignore the vital issues. I have heard this is also the method of diplomacy adopted by the Indian government hence the persistent misunderstandings with its neighbours. When the Indian writers are incapable of answering in a coherent manner the questions raised by me or others they resort to insults and even death threats. Under these circumstances how will we in South Asia ever be able to achieve common understanding with India when they clearly have no intention of engaging in discussion or debate in a civilized and rational manner.

I now have to contend with Bull on exactly the same areas that I have covered with Con but I am really not inclined to do so until the Indian writers on this forum show some integrity and intellectual honesty.

Your English writing skills are impeccable, However I do feel that you seem to have the ability to see things that are not there.

You talk of death threats to you and intimidation. I have been posting upon here and I can assure you despite many heated arguments with the Indian's that any comments of that nature, are merely humorous in nature.
On another thread you accused (A Pakistani member) of being a liar simply because his view differed from yours.
I have noticed a pattern where you dismiss anything that is contrary to your opinion rather than look at the information and use counterpoints.

I suggest a more level headed approach rather than the one you are taking.

 

[indiapakistanfriendship]

Dude, you're new to this forum so I'll spare you the lecture but please refrain from personal attacks or insults towards other members or their nationality.
Kill the message not the messenger!

Thanks!
Neo

Dear brother neo.. I highly appologise for playing part in lowering the standard of the discussion....But I was simply overwhelmed by the way he talks and makes comments...

Just for the sake of logic: here is an argument.. If some looney comes and says that september 9/11 was an conspiracy by ISI and repeats this for umpteen number of times.. how would you react....wont you be angered or frustrated?

I had also attached along with the posting a note with apologies to bangla brothers.

What another Indian moron sent to attack me. It seems these fools grow on trees in India. Is it the climate or your inferiority complex. I just don't get it. They send 4 Indians to slander and defame me but they simply can't defeat me in a straight discussion. Two of them even conceded defeat and another has become so inane that it appears pointless to reply to him. Con stopped making sense a long time ago. Now we have this lunatic 'indiapakistanfriendship' making uncivilized comments that shows his inbreeding and tendency to talk through his rear end.

Inferiority complex? wo wo wo... look at this he is sayin that we are having inferiority complex against this guy and his country.....It is you who is having an inferiority complex....The way your BDR rifles mutilated the bodiesof our soldiers and sent them afloat a river.. you should know how civilized your soldiers must be

I dont know any academic who writes books talk in such a manner... he is callin me a lunatic and uncivilised person.. just look at the words he uses.."Talkin thorugh his ***" "inbreeding" are these the kind of words they teach u during your universities studies. Well our Sussex or MIT educated Prof's dont certainly teach us such things.. Cant even imagine the standard of your education. And about my upbringing... The word you have used clearly indicates your's and you dont certainly have any right to talk about it...

And about two of our buddies considering defeat to ya... that shows you are disillusioned... the pinnacle of which was when you said your army can catch us at chicken neck.....


Note: This is the last time I will be engaged in such talk.. I am here for civilized debate. Mr. Munshi you have simply pushed me to say the above said things....

 

[Contrarian]

Lol, Key,

Why take such a diplomatic approach with this guy. He is a Grade A, consipracy theory buff, who cannot take any other view than his. And his LOGIC for his views is equally ridiculous....the chanakya doctrine i ask you!!

And i will never forget his biggest gem!!
Those who disagree with his view or are pro India in BD are financed by RAW, and all the true patriots agree with him.

So in all honesty, this 'analyst' is going crazy.

 

[con]

Your English writing skills are impeccable, However I do feel that you seem to have the ability to see things that are not there.

You talk of death threats to you and intimidation. I have been posting upon here and I can assure you despite many heated arguments with the Indian's that any comments of that nature, are merely humorous in nature.
On another thread you accused (A Pakistani member) of being a liar simply because his view differed from yours.
I have noticed a pattern where you dismiss anything that is contrary to your opinion rather than look at the information and use counterpoints.

I suggest a more level headed approach rather than the one you are taking.

Well you just summarized what the Indian members have been trying to point out to Mr.Munshi.

A point to note is that Mr.Munshi indicates that he is born and educated in UK.This would mean he would have never been exposed to the actual dynamics of the sub-continent for most of his. He does not seem to have a history of being physically present in the sub-continent consistently nor can claim to have the authority that comes by being part of the Bangladesh establishment, where he would be having interacting with the Indian gov teams.
This is proved by his statement that "he has heard" that Indian delegation behaves irrationality. People "sitting" in UK have a different view of the countries in sub-continent. Hence I am not surprised about all these theories proposed by Mr.Munshi,

And yes Mr.Munshi might been having the language expertise due to "British English education",however what matters more is the application of knowledge that was gained. Unfortunately Mr.Munshi's displayed level of knowledge and logic seems to be contrary to the statement above.

As Mark Twain's once said, ''Don't let school interfere with your education.''

 

[PakSniper]

As Mark Twain's once said, ''Don't let school interfere with your education.''

Off topic, that is the stupidest quote I have ever read. And alot of arguments can me made as to why it is.

Now you guyies can go back to topic.