Mr X takes an oath out to satisfy his father lust for another woman.
"lust" is a christian word. Hindus do not have any such word. We call it Kama or Love/desire.
So In Hindu sub text Mr. X takes an oath to reassure that the object of his fathers love/desire will get what she wants if his father gets what he wants.
And what he gives in exchange was what was always his to give.
Mr X follows the oath even if that means killing innocents for sake of it.
There are no word called "innocent" in Hinduism/sanskrit. There is only a word for blameless i.e. Anagas. If anybody participates in a war, then they are not blameless.
This is not a terrorist attack, this is a declared way where the opponents are there to kill each other.
Mr X follows the oath even if that means supporting the evils.
There is no word called "evil" in Hinduism or sanskrit. We have Dush-Karma or "wrong deed", we have "paapa" which comes from the word "Aap" which means identity(self/ego) in sanskrit. So even a Paap is action done in self interest or in other words a "Selfish" deed.
Mr. X oath is a promise of Karma, IRRESPECTIVE of the end result. In english the saying is "Means is more important than the end".
Mr X do not support Dharma but Adharma by violating teachings of Gita as he was bind by his oath. He values his oath more than innocent lives and dharma.
Be like Mr X.
You have ZERO understanding of the teaching of Gita or even what "Dharma" means. Those are just meaningless words to you.
As my post demonstrates, you entire understanding of Hinduism is actually a feeble understanding of christianity disguised as Hinduism. The same way your "proofs" are opinions disguised as facts.
Following's one's oath IS dharma. Not the end result, but the Journey itself. Dharma IS the journey, the end always leads to god.
Keep living in a cocoon where use of your own mind is prohibited.
Now is the prefect time to take your own advice and take a good long hard look in the mirror. I invite you to step outside your cocoon and educate yourself by breaking free of years of social brainwashing.
Fools paradise where everyone is master in their own minds. Inhabited by most religious ones.
Nope. A fools paradise is based on Ignorance. Unaware or denying the existence of potential trouble. You are ignorant about your own mind, what to say about Facts that lies outside your own ego.