Bengali economic migrants in Pakistan

[BDforever]

U are always welcome bro it is the Jamati lungi types that I hate, btw have u really visited India in the past?

yes, 3 times lol

 

[haviZsultan]

Bangladeshi not Bengali

That is incorrect. A Bengali can be both Indian or Pakistani and it is incorrect to call a Pakistani or Indian Bengali a Bangladeshi which is a national name not an ethnic name. This is like the Afghans calling all pashtuns Afghan. An idiotic stand to say the least-no offense intended

 

[FULL_METAL]

That is incorrect. A Bengali can be both Indian and Pakistani and it is incorrect to call a Pakistani or Indian Bengali a Bangladeshi which is a national name not an ethnic name. This is like the Afghans calling all pashtuns Afghan. An idiotic stand to say the least-no offense intended

what BS u are spewing man? how can a benagli be both Indian and Pakistani? what lala land u are living man? Bengali is an ethnicity, like I am a Bengali from India, am I a Bangladeshi? heck no, Bengalis living in Pakistan migrated from Bangladesh and living there illegally for economic opportunities, so they are still very much Bangladeshi. Hope u understand.

yes, 3 times lol

I am quoting u in whatever thread

 

[haviZsultan]

what BS u are spewing man? how can a benagli be both Indian and Pakistani? what lala land u are living man? Bengali is an ethnicity, like I am a Bengali from India, am I a Bangladeshi? heck no, Bengalis living in Pakistan migrated from Bangladesh and living there illegally for economic opportunities, so they are still very much Bangladeshi. Hope u understand.


I am quoting u in whatever thread

Rubbish-sorry to say. There are around 200,000 possibly a million Bengalis who are Pakistani by citizenship. The same way as there are Bengalis who are Indian by citizenship. Bangladeshi is a national identity. Bengali is an ethnic identity. Bengalis can be Bangladeshis Pakistanis Indians or other nationals. But a Bangladeshi can only be a resident of Bangladesh.

An example of Pakistani Bengalis are Khwaja Nazimuddin, MM Alam and Nurul Amin. Many Bengalis supported Pakistan and stayed on in west Pakistan.

 

[FULL_METAL]

Rubbish-sorry to say. There are around 200,000 possibly a million Bengalis who are Pakistani by citizenship. The same way as there are Bengalis who are Indian by citizenship. Bangladeshi is a national identity. Bengali is an ethnic identity. Bengalis can be Bangladeshis Pakistanis Indians or other nationals. But a Bangladeshi can only be a resident of Bangladesh.

An example of Pakistani Bengalis are Khwaja Nazimuddin, MM Alam and Nurul Amin. Many Bengalis supported Pakistan and stayed on in west Pakistan.

Agreed . Indian Bengalis has nothing to do with Bangladeshis it is just that we happen to share the same language which will be over within a few decades hopefully when Arabic will be the most spoken language in bangladesh

 

[xyxmt]

The fact is these Bengalis are those who were living in West Pak and stayed back after 1971 along with those who used to work for Muslim League and other Pro-Pakistan political parties in East Pak and moved to Pakistan after 1971. Technically, they are Pakistanis since that's what their nationality was before 1971. After 1971, only those Bengalis serving with the military and civil services got accepted as Pakistani nationals while the rest were labeled illegals. Even if they show proper documents, the authorities claim they are either fake or acquired through bribery.

These are the same people who fought for Pakistan's cause and even left their birth-land for their love for Pakistan. It's quite unfortunate even after decades these people are still treated as illegals. Even the stranded Pakistanis in Bangladesh have been granted Bangladeshi citizenship but the Bengalis in Pakistan aren't. Looking at these things, one would wonder whatever bad is happening in Pakistan, Pakistanis themselves are to blame for it...

I had a Bihari friend in Karachi whose family moved after 71, his father still has some business in BD and there was no proper way to send money between two countries. So he would take money from Bangalis working in Karachi and pay that money to their relatives in BD. I onces asked one of the Bangali guys why didnt you go back after 71, he said I just came from BD last year, I asked him how did you get here and he said thru India..chuptey chupatey, somewhere we took a bus, somewhere we walked...I asked him how much time it took you and he said 2 months. Then he told me some horror stories when BSF catches them and what they do, I asked what about Pakistan borders he said they dont bother us so much they rather sympathize with us because we went thru so much trouble to get here (Muslim brotherhood again i guess).

We should not worry about Bangalis, they are nice hard working people mostly do jobs that locals wont do and never creates any kind of problems.

 

[haviZsultan]

Agreed . Indian Bengalis has nothing to do with Bangladeshis it is just that we happen to share the same language which will be over within a few decades hopefully when Arabic will be most spoken language in bangladesh

Mocking the bengalis is the only pass time you have and it is sad that a hard working people like the Bengali's are constantly treated badly in South Asia. They are good people who have had bad luck in my eyes. They are one of the least fanatical group of people among muslims. Keep your biases out when talking about them. I have a feeling you too will one day get banned.

I had a Bihari friend in Karachi whose family moved after 71, his father still has some business in BD and there was no proper way to send money between two countries. So he would take money from Bangalis working in Karachi and pay that money to their relatives in BD. I onces asked one of the Bangali guys why didnt you go back after 71, he said I just came from BD last year, I asked him how did you get here and he said thru India..chuptey chupatey, somewhere we took a bus, somewhere we walked...I asked him how much time it took you and he said 2 months. Then he told me some horror stories when BSF catches them and what they do, I asked what about Pakistan borders he said they dont bother us so much they rather sympathize with us because we went thru so much trouble to get here (Muslim brotherhood again i guess).

We should not worry about Bangalis, they are nice hard working people mostly do jobs that locals wont do and never creates any kind of problems.

I think we Pakistanis were and continue to be very harsh on Bengalis. i would like a reunion with a Bengali president and prime minister-if it ever happens anyway. Indians well they are harsh on Bengalis-they don't share the same religion.

 

[FULL_METAL]

Mocking the bengalis is the only pass time you have and it is sad that a hard working people like the Bengali's are constantly treated badly in South Asia. They are good people who have had bad luck in my eyes. They are one of the least fanatical group of people among muslims. Keep your biases out when talking about them. I have a feeling you too will one day get banned.
I think we Pakistanis were and continue to be very harsh on Bengalis. i would like a reunion with a Bengali president and prime minister-if it ever happens anyway. Indians well they are harsh on Bengalis-they don't share the same religion.

I have several other pass times, mocking Bangladeshis just being one of them

 

[Max]

Deport the good hard-working men to Bangladesh and the rotten Salafist bunch to the UK.

50 to 60% Pakistanis are Barelvi (Sufi Sunni) while 10 to 15% are shia.. rest are Deobandi Tablighi for whom u hold biggest Jalsa in Bangladesh .. TTP and all other Terrorist organization are follower of Deobandi sect.. only 2% or may be less then that are salafist and they are peaceful here atleast..

3million Bangladeshi illegally living in Pakistan is unbelievable. If so many illegal Bangladeshi's live in Pakistan then surly we would have heard about them in Bangladeshi main stream. Media. But I never heard a word about them.

lol.. i live in Karachi and my two childhood friends were Bengalis

 

[extra terrestrial]

I had a Bihari friend in Karachi whose family moved after 71, his father still has some business in BD and there was no proper way to send money between two countries. So he would take money from Bangalis working in Karachi and pay that money to their relatives in BD. I onces asked one of the Bangali guys why didnt you go back after 71, he said I just came from BD last year, I asked him how did you get here and he said thru India..chuptey chupatey, somewhere we took a bus, somewhere we walked...I asked him how much time it took you and he said 2 months. Then he told me some horror stories when BSF catches them and what they do, I asked what about Pakistan borders he said they dont bother us so much they rather sympathize with us because we went thru so much trouble to get here (Muslim brotherhood again i guess).

We should not worry about Bangalis, they are nice hard working people mostly do jobs that locals wont do and never creates any kind of problems.

About Biharis, I have no idea about the ground realities in Pakistan, I hope the situation is quite improved now. My father grew up in Old Dhaka where there used to be many Biharis (or rather non-Bengalis since all of them were not Biharis but Urdu-speaking people from different ethnicities). Some of them were quite good school friends of my father. After the war, most of them (the non-Bengali friends of my father) moved to Pakistan. However, from the last few years they have started to contact my father. They want to resettle in Bangladesh because of the poor security situation in Karachi. They seem to be well off as well. Last year, one of his friend came to our house with his family and had dinner with us. After talking to them, what I understood is that many Pakistanis are actually hoping to settle in Bangladesh, while settling in Dubai is their second option which will cost higher.

About Bengalis illegally entering Pakistan, let's be frank, Pakistan is a beautiful country with a rich heritage, but when it comes to economic conditions, it's surely not that much attractive that would warrant a journey, crossing two of the world's deadliest borders and taking all those risks. Still, I agree there might be some illegal Bangladeshis in Pakistan. That's because Pakistan is a major destination for Islamic education and many Qawmi madrassa students in Bangladesh aspire to have higher education in the Pakistani madrassas. However, the Qawmi madrassas are not registered by the government, hence, their degrees have no official affiliation which compels these students to migrate to Pakistan illegally. Another fact is that, Pakistan is a major transit point in the route for human trafficking to Europe. It's possible some Bangladeshis couldn't reach Europe and became stranded in Pakistan. Above all, even after the presence of illegal Bangladeshis, most of the Bengalis in Pakistan are those who have been living there since before 1971 and shouldn't be tagged as illegals.

 

[django]

That is incorrect. A Bengali can be both Indian or Pakistani and it is incorrect to call a Pakistani or Indian Bengali a Bangladeshi which is a national name not an ethnic name. This is like the Afghans calling all pashtuns Afghan. An idiotic stand to say the least-no offense intended

Yaar they are not part of our nation. they have their own

 

[Basel]

Those people who supported BD returned after 1971 by mutual agreement. If anyone entered after 1971 illegally, its your gov's responsibility to deport them accordingly. BD dont have any problems. Come up with proper articles on this matter. Not everyday joe's inquiry.

Few hundred thousand illegal (many have NICs due to corruption) Bangladeshi live just a kilometre away (who came dice Pakistan accepted Bangladesh) from my home. Many worked Inoue area and there new generation is now a mafia in the area.

Deporting means sending them back to their home country and Bangladesh is not ready to accept them.

 

[django]

I just don't understand why can't these lungis just go and try their luck in Olympics if they have such sheer passion for pole vaulting instead of being fcuking parasites and sucking resources from other countries

they truly are the sick man of south asia oooops south east asia

I had a Bihari friend in Karachi whose family moved after 71, his father still has some business in BD and there was no proper way to send money between two countries. So he would take money from Bangalis working in Karachi and pay that money to their relatives in BD. I onces asked one of the Bangali guys why didnt you go back after 71, he said I just came from BD last year, I asked him how did you get here and he said thru India..chuptey chupatey, somewhere we took a bus, somewhere we walked...I asked him how much time it took you and he said 2 months. Then he told me some horror stories when BSF catches them and what they do, I asked what about Pakistan borders he said they dont bother us so much they rather sympathize with us because we went thru so much trouble to get here (Muslim brotherhood again i guess).

We should not worry about Bangalis, they are nice hard working people mostly do jobs that locals wont do and never creates any kind of problems.

Their has to be consequences for anyone entering the country illegally, I say throw them all out into ugly gremlin sheikh hasinas lap.

About Biharis, I have no idea about the ground realities in Pakistan, I hope the situation is quite improved now. My father grew up in Old Dhaka where there used to be many Biharis (or rather non-Bengalis since all of them were not Biharis but Urdu-speaking people from different ethnicities). Some of them were quite good school friends of my father. After the war, most of them (the non-Bengali friends of my father) moved to Pakistan. However, from the last few years they have started to contact my father. They want to resettle in Bangladesh because of the poor security situation in Karachi. They seem to be well off as well. Last year, one of his friend came to our house with his family and had dinner with us. After talking to them, what I understood is that many Pakistanis are actually hoping to settle in Bangladesh, while settling in Dubai is their second option which will cost higher.

About Bengalis illegally entering Pakistan, let's be frank, Pakistan is a beautiful country with a rich heritage, but when it comes to economic conditions, it's surely not that much attractive that would warrant a journey, crossing two of the world's deadliest borders and taking all those risks. Still, I agree there might be some illegal Bangladeshis in Pakistan. That's because Pakistan is a major destination for Islamic education and many Qawmi madrassa students in Bangladesh aspire to have higher education in the Pakistani madrassas. However, the Qawmi madrassas are not registered by the government, hence, their degrees have no official affiliation which compels these students to migrate to Pakistan illegally. Another fact is that, Pakistan is a major transit point in the route for human trafficking to Europe. It's possible some Bangladeshis couldn't reach Europe and became stranded in Pakistan. Above all, even after the presence of illegal Bangladeshis, most of the Bengalis in Pakistan are those who have been living there since before 1971 and shouldn't be tagged as illegals.

Nonsense.

Few hundred thousand illegal (many have NICs due to corruption) Bangladeshi live just a kilometre away (who came dice Pakistan accepted Bangladesh) from my home. Many worked Inoue area and there new generation is now a mafia in the area.

Deporting means sending them back to their home country and Bangladesh is not ready to accept them.

If they have a mafia, rangers need to show the little cretins who is in charge.

 

[Basel]

they truly are the sick man of south asia oooops south east asia


Their has to be consequences for anyone entering the country illegally, I say throw them all out into ugly gremlin sheikh hasinas lap.


Nonsense.


If they have a mafia, rangers need to show the little cretins who is in charge.

Rangers and police conducted raids but you know how corrupt system is and how mafias work by paying bribes to the corrupt people.

 

[Jaanbaz]

they will make good spies to go in india one day..

Nope most of them are bat shit crazy, future candidates for ISIS.