You are confusing politics with separatism. Kashmirs in the valley support India but want to retain their autonomy. Abdullahs & Muftis would fight BJP tooth & nail on Article 370 but they DO NOT want to join Pakistan at all. They have nothing in common with Pakistanis. Heck Kashmiri language is not even spoken across the LOC. AJK is full of Punjabis. Don't even bother asking the Shias if they want to join Pakistan or not.
Jammu region:
Hindus - 66% (Pro-India)
Muslims - 30% (20% Shias, 10% Sunnis. Both are Pro-India)
Others - 4% (Pro-India)
Ladakh region:
Buddhists - 52 % (Pro-India)
Shias - 45% (Pro-India)
Others - 3 % (Pro-India)
Kashmir region:
Sunni Muslims - 60% (33% Autonomy under India, 18% Pro-India, 6% Pro-Independence, 3% Pro-Pakistan)
Tribes - 20% (Staunchly pro-India tribes likes Gujjars, Bakkarwals, Paharis, Baltis and Shins.)
Hindus/Sikhs - 15% (Pro-India)
Shias - 5% (Pro-India. Declared only. Many Shias declare themselves as Sunnis due to fear)
View attachment 409893