Beneath All Its Masks, The Kashmir ‘Conflict’ Was Always About Islam

[krash]

You are confusing politics with separatism. Kashmirs in the valley support India but want to retain their autonomy. Abdullahs & Muftis would fight BJP tooth & nail on Article 370 but they DO NOT want to join Pakistan at all. They have nothing in common with Pakistanis. Heck Kashmiri language is not even spoken across the LOC. AJK is full of Punjabis. Don't even bother asking the Shias if they want to join Pakistan or not.

Jammu region:

Hindus - 66% (Pro-India)
Muslims - 30% (20% Shias, 10% Sunnis. Both are Pro-India)
Others - 4% (Pro-India)

Ladakh region:

Buddhists - 52 % (Pro-India)
Shias - 45% (Pro-India)
Others - 3 % (Pro-India)

Kashmir region:

Sunni Muslims - 60% (33% Autonomy under India, 18% Pro-India, 6% Pro-Independence, 3% Pro-Pakistan)
Tribes - 20% (Staunchly pro-India tribes likes Gujjars, Bakkarwals, Paharis, Baltis and Shins.)
Hindus/Sikhs - 15% (Pro-India)
Shias - 5% (Pro-India. Declared only. Many Shias declare themselves as Sunnis due to fear)

View attachment 409893

Please read the articles, you can google many times more. Stop mucking about.

 

[DineshS]

So in Plain & Simple words INDIA a country who claim to have a MULTICULTURAL & RELIGIOUS SOCIETY is facing an ISSUE because of CULTURAL DIFFERENCE OR because of DIFFERENCE OF RELIGION ..... ??

India does not NEED to claim anything. We are, since the constitution & political system has provided checks & balances to provide the same, Unlike theocratic nations.

The issues you mentioned are present in every modern, western, democratic, pluralistic nations in the word. Show me one non-theocratic nation which does not have the "ISSUES" you are talking about.

 

[HRK]

In India we have buddhists,parsis,jains,sikhs,tribals,christians...etc just bcos one of them runs amok does not mean the problem is with others.

So are YOU accepting India still has not SUCCEED to INTEGRATE all the RELIGIONS in its LIBERAL national fabric (or CULTURE as one of you countryman said previously) ....

 

[KRAIT]

So are YOU accepting India still has not SUCCEED to INTEGRATE all the RELIGIONS in its LIBERAL national fabric (or CULTURE as one of you countryman said previously) ....

You are such an idiot. Hindus Muslims Sikhs and Christians have positve population growth rate and they live well together.

There are over 800 million Hindus and 200 million Muslims. Except few cases, these people live in perfect harmony.

 

[Itaalvi]

Jammu region:

Hindus - 66% (Pro-India)
Muslims - 30% (20% Shias, 10% Sunnis. Both are Pro-India)
Others - 4% (Pro-India)

Ladakh region:

Buddhists - 52 % (Pro-India)
Shias - 45% (Pro-India)
Others - 3 % (Pro-India)

Kashmir region:

Sunni Muslims - 60% (33% Autonomy under India, 18% Pro-India, 6% Pro-Independence, 3% Pro-Pakistan)
Tribes - 20% (Staunchly pro-India tribes likes Gujjars, Bakkarwals, Paharis, Baltis and Shins.)
Hindus/Sikhs - 15% (Pro-India)
Shias - 5% (Pro-India. Declared only. Many Shias declare themselves as Sunnis due to fear)

What a brain fart.

You are such an idiot. Hindus Muslims Sikhs and Christians have positve population growth rate and they live well together.

There are over 800 million Hindus and 200 million Muslims. Except few cases, these people live in perfect harmony.

Yeah perfect harmony and because of this Muslim being happily lynched to protect Holy Cow.

 

[jetray]

So are YOU accepting India still has not SUCCEED to INTEGRATE all the RELIGIONS in its LIBERAL national fabric (or CULTURE as one of you countryman said previously) ....

The question is other way around, which religion has a problem all over the world from America,europe,australia,japan,china ...etc.
If one religion does not integrate is it problem with religion or is the problem with other religions that got integrated. The problem is not specific to India its the same around the world.

 

[KRAIT]

What a brain fart.
Yeah perfect harmony and because of this Muslim being happily lynched to protect Holy Cow.

Few incidents. Well, you are a fool. Now shoo.

 

[Itaalvi]

@waz

Since yesterday few Kids from India using very bad language abusing religion and trying hard to associate Kashmir freedom struggle with ISIS. I report them many times but no action was taken.

@KRAIT
@Nodata
@SarthakGanguly etc
and few others should be banned.

 

[HRK]

India does not NEED to claim anything. We are,

So are you WITHDRAWING form claim ....??

since the constitution & political system has provided checks & balances to provide the same,

BUT again PROBLEM IS STILL ALIVE .... or Am I wrong in assuming this ...???

Unlike theocratic nations.

Another Nation THEOCRATIC OR NOT should not be a PROBLEM in INDIA's 'INTERNAL MATTER' ....

The issues you mentioned are present in every modern, western, democratic, pluralistic nations in the word. Show me one non-theocratic nation which does not have the "ISSUES" you are talking about.

So all those present day "modern, western, democratic, pluralistic nations" are facing FREEDOM MOVEMENTS at the name of RELIGION or CULTURE ....???

 

[KRAIT]

@waz

Since yesterday few Kids from India using very bad language abusing religion and trying hard to associate Kashmir freedom struggle with ISIS. I report them many times but no action was taken.

@KRAIT
@Nodata
@SarthakGanguly etc
and few others should be banned.

Awww...crying like a bitch.

 

[HRK]

You are such an idiot.

BEHAVE FIRST & LAST WARNING ... if you can't contribute in DEBATE in positive manner then plz don't bother to interfere ....

 

[Logicaldude]

You may be right or may be wrong .... currently I am not debating about any religion or cultural at this moment I am as of now only raising queries to establish the first STEP of Problem solving REALIZE THE ISSUE we will move to next the step of Identifying the issue afterwards.

So in Plain & Simple words INDIA a country who claim to have a MULTICULTURAL & RELIGIOUS SOCIETY is facing an ISSUE because of CULTURAL DIFFERENCE OR because of DIFFERENCE OF RELIGION ..... ??

india is culturally diverse everywhere, not just in kashmir.

India has different religions everywhere, not just kashmir.

So neither.

 

[Itaalvi]

india is culturally diverse everywhere, not just in kashmir.

India has different religions everywhere, not just kashmir.

So neither.

Khalistan, Kashmir, Sikkim, Gorkhaland, Manipur + 20 more separatist movements, clock is ticking getting closer with each second. Union of India bye bye

 

[KRAIT]

BEHAVE FIRST & LAST WARRING ... if you can't contribute in DEBATE in positive manner then plz don't bother to interfere ....

Oh...I am scared.

 

[jetray]

@waz

Since yesterday few Kids from India using very bad language abusing religion and trying hard to associate Kashmir freedom struggle with ISIS. I report them many times but no action was taken.

@KRAIT
@Nodata
@SarthakGanguly etc
and few others should be banned.

please do , truth must be jarring to soul & mind.
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2...-militant-fight-islam-independence-zakir-musa
Kashmir conflict shifts with top militant vowing fight is for an Islamic state
Zakir Musa, a highly influential commander, distances himself from 70-year-old separatist movement and aligns himself with ideals of al-Qaida