Barred By Muslim Countries, Rohingya Muslims Sneaking Into India

[Vinod2070]

Stoning of adulterers or the other stuff has nothing to do with this topic. As for 1971, even though we acknowledge that crimes were committed by Pakistani soldiers, it is not relevant to this discussion. The discussion here is about Bengali Muslim people in certain parts of India and their alleged illegal status.

And you chose to use it to make uninformed comments like:

Indians seem to reserve extra special bigotry for Bengali speaking Muslims.

Same like you accused the Hindus and Parsis of certain things when the facts on the ground are completely opposite.

It is Islamic Pakistan that ethnically cleansed itself killing and banishing people from their own lands, not Dharmic India where we have almost the same number of Muslims as Pakistan.

And it is Islamic Iran that banished Parsis from their own land, not Parsis who threw out Arabs from their lands.

And you chose to portray the people at the receiving end of Islamic bigotry as the perpetrators rather than the victims!

There is only one explanation.

Weltanschauung — the mental makeup which selects and filters facts before they reach the conscious brain.

 

[Developereo]

You took it in wrong way. Aid to other countries are for strategic and economic benefits. We want their resources just like every other country.

My point is, these refugees are used as vote banks coz they will support anyone who give them basic necessities while to local one who wants more development. ts easier to satisfy 100 illegal immigrants than 100 local people.

Sir, even your govt. and people are fed up of millions of afghanistanis living in Pakistan. They are going to deport them. What will you call it, rational decision or stance just like India.

Every country has its own priorities, your frame of reference shows India's bigotry while ours shows need of the hour.

Perceive the things from other angle.

Assuming we are talking about official Rohingya refugees -- and not the general issue of alleged "pole vaulters" -- then every country has an international obligation to accept a certain number of refugees.

Muslim majority areas in Assam doesn't border West Bengal but Sylhet. Muslims in Assam speak in Syleti dialect.

So, ethnic Bengali people live in Indian Bengal, Bangladesh and even Burma. And you guys are saying that they cannot possibly be indigenous to Assam? Has there been a 50-foot wall separating the lands of Bangladesh from the lands of Assam throughout the centuries?

 

[kurup]

1. Look at the map. Height of imagination of somebody suggesting these ragtag refugees in ill health could cross montians, forests, survive malaria and wild animals not to talk of unfriendly local NE tribesmen to enter a poverty ridden insurgency full nation whose govt doesn't have control over half of the country. Rohingyas are strict Muslims and would not like to get into a country where Muslims are massacred and where their favorite food beef is mostly forbidden.

2. No Muslim nation has forbidden the Rohingyas, not least BD. Official pronouncements are another thing. At field level Rohingyas are helped by our BGB, Police, and most all, the local population. They have enteref and many more are entering although from time to time reports of "returns" are announced.

3. Yrs we will train them, arm them and send them into Jihad to evict the invader.

What an !diot ........

Persecuted Burmese tribe finds no welcome in Bangladesh | World news | The Guardian

BBC News - Bangladesh orders charities to stop aid to Rohingyas

 

[Developereo]

Same like you accused the Hindus and Parsis of certain things when the facts on the ground are completely opposite.

The facts on the ground, and in this forum, are that Indians are categorically dismissive of the legal status of Bengali Muslims in N.E. states. That attitude, on display every time, is relevant to the topic.

The rest of your post is not relevant.

 

[Vinod2070]

The facts on the ground, and in this forum, are that Indians are categorically dismissive of the legal status of Bengali Muslims in N.E. states.

Because we consider them illegal aliens who have no right to be in India.

And the locals of the areas seem to agree.

That attitude, on display every time, is relevant to the topic.

And so is the response.

The rest of your post is not relevant.

It is and remains relevant. Because it is based on actual facts.

 

[LaBong]

So, ethnic Bengali people live in Indian Bengal, Bangladesh and even Burma. And you guys are saying that they cannot possibly be indigenous to Assam? Has there been a 50-foot wall separating the lands of Bangladesh from the lands of Assam throughout the centuries?

Source: http://www.defence.pk/forums/centra...lims-sneaking-into-india-7.html#ixzz2393Sg86x

There are indigenous Bengalis, both Hindu and Muslim variety is Assam but they moved there after British came to power. Ahom kingdom ruled Assam for centuries in medieval age and they were not friendly towards Bengalis.

However in last 2, 3 decades Assam has witnessed unnatural growth of Bengali Muslim diaspora which caused the indigenous Bodos to be minority in their own land.

 

[ajtr]

Myanmar invites OIC probe of sectarian unrest

YANGON: Myanmar has invited an influential Islamic body to visit a state rocked by sectarian violence, official media said Friday, in an effort to diffuse mounting outcry over the treatment of the Muslim Rohingya.
In a rare conciliatory move over the issue, President Thein Sein said he welcomed a visit by the Saudi-based Organisation of Islamic Cooperation (OIC), the world’s largest Muslim grouping, which has urged a probe into violence between Buddhist Rakhine and Rohingya that left scores dead.
“The president said he hoped the OIC secretary could witness the reality (in Rakhine),” state mouthpiece the New Light of Myanmar said, adding tens of thousands of displaced people from both sides are being given food and shelter.
Thein Sein’s comments came as the visiting foreign minister of Muslim-majority Turkey offered aid to the strife-stricken Rakhine state.
He also urged “the Turkish minister to explain the realities in Myanmar” to the OIC, the report added.
OIC head Ekmeleddin Ihsanoglu on Sunday proposed sending a mission to probe “massacres… oppression and ethnic cleansing” of Rohingya in Rakhine, adding weight to calls by Egypt and Saudi Arabia for an investigation into the unrest.
The initial outbreak of fighting in western Rakhine state killed some 80 people from both sides in June, official figures show.
Renewed violence between Buddhists and Muslim Rohingya left several people dead in Myanmar on Sunday, underscoring tensions in the area.
Human rights groups have alleged the number of dead could be much higher, but Friday’s report said “only 77 persons” from both sides died.
The bloodshed has cast a shadow over widely praised reforms by President Thein Sein, including the release of hundreds of political prisoners and the election of opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi to parliament.
Myanmar’s government has rejected accusations of abuse by security forces in Rakhine, after the United Nations raised fears of a crackdown on Muslims.
The entire state has been under emergency rule since early June with a heavy army and police presence.
New York-based Human Rights Watch has accused Myanmar forces of opening fire on Rohingya, as well as committing rape and standing by as rival mobs attacked each other.
Decades of discrimination have left the Rohingya stateless, and they are viewed by the United Nations as one of the world’s most persecuted minorities.
Speaking a Bengali dialect similar to one in neighbouring Bangladesh, the Rohingya are seen as illegal immigrants by the Myanmar government and many Burmese, and many have attempted to flee overseas in rickety boats.

 

[Markx]

there is no place for Bangladeshi people in india , these people hate india , Hindus , Non-muslims , But wants to live in INDIA !

We should kick out them. many of them are involved in Terrorist activities

 

[TopCat]

There are indigenous Bengalis, both Hindu and Muslim variety is Assam but they moved there after British came to power. Ahom kingdom ruled Assam for centuries in medieval age and they were not friendly towards Bengalis.

However in last 2, 3 decades Assam has witnessed unnatural growth of Bengali Muslim diaspora which caused the indigenous Bodos to be minority in their own land.

But your last census said there is no unnatural growth of population in the state which is even less than national average. Besides millions of persecuted muslim from UP/Bihar and other part of India moving towards eastward and a natural outcome.

 

[INDIC]

But your last census said there is no unnatural growth of population in the state which is even less than national average. Besides millions of persecuted muslim from UP/Bihar and other part of India moving towards eastward and a natural outcome.

They are migrating to beautiful Bangladesh, the land of milk and honey.

 

[TopCat]

The facts on the ground, and in this forum, are that Indians are categorically dismissive of the legal status of Bengali Muslims in N.E. states. That attitude, on display every time, is relevant to the topic.

The rest of your post is not relevant.

India stole Karimganj and other Barak valley areas claiming that those were Hindu majority. But in reality those were Muslim majority to start with. Now these idiots are saying that every resident of Karimganj and Barak Valley are illegal citizen as they were Muslim and opting for ethnic cleansing. Bangladesh will no way allow that.

They are migrating to beautiful Bangladesh, the land of milk and honey.

Nope BGB is keeping a vigil eye. But those people try to relocate themselves close to BD border just for in case.

Good for us as they are creating a buffer zone for our military.

 

[INDIC]

India stole Karimganj and other Barak valley areas claiming that those were Hindu majority. But in reality those were Muslim majority to start with. Now these idiots are saying that every resident of Karimganj and Barak Valley are illegal citizen as they were Muslim and opting for ethnic cleansing. Bangladesh will no way allow that.

Talking bullshit but won't mention Khulna.

 

[LaBong]

But your last census said there is no unnatural growth of population in the state which is even less than national average. Besides millions of persecuted muslim from UP/Bihar and other part of India moving towards eastward and a natural outcome.

Yes that's why I said 2, 3 decades. Illegal migration has been reduced in last decade after border fencing and bsf getting more proactive.

Muslims are not persecuted in UP and Bihar. Both states haven't seen riot in recent time. There are economic migrants from bihar and up to Calcutta but Bihari and up muslims speak urdu not syleti.

India stole Karimganj and other Barak valley areas claiming that those were Hindu majority. But in reality those were Muslim majority to start with. Now these idiots are saying that every resident of Karimganj and Barak Valley are illegal citizen as they were Muslim and opting for ethnic cleansing. Bangladesh will no way allow that.



Nope BGB is keeping a vigil eye. But those people try to relocate themselves close to BD border just for in case.

Good for us as they are creating a buffer zone for our military.

Barak valley is 90 percent Bengali and majority of them are Hindus since pre partition era. These incidents are not happening in Barak valley.

 

[asad71]

What an !diot ........

Persecuted Burmese tribe finds no welcome in Bangladesh | World news | The Guardian

BBC News - Bangladesh orders charities to stop aid to Rohingyas

You are a Himalayan Idiot. A Super Idiot from Super Poor Rep of Hindustan. First read the post before fingering your laptop.

 

[Vinod2070]

India stole Karimganj and other Barak valley areas claiming that those were Hindu majority. But in reality those were Muslim majority to start with. Now these idiots are saying that every resident of Karimganj and Barak Valley are illegal citizen as they were Muslim and opting for ethnic cleansing. Bangladesh will no way allow that.



Nope BGB is keeping a vigil eye. But those people try to relocate themselves close to BD border just for in case.

Good for us as they are creating a buffer zone for our military.

Kya Piddi.

Kya piddi ka shorba.