Bangladesh stands by India; slams Pakistan for statement that India interfered during 1971 crisis

[Jf Thunder]

It says about the atrocities PA did in EP.
Go read, educate yourself.

no actually it drops the figure of 3 million to 20,000 and even calls that an exaggeration

 

[Neemo neemo]

no actually it drops the figure of 3 million to 20,000 and even calls that an exaggeration

Means you haven't read it. Read the actual one.

Even if it was 2,000 what would you call it? Collateral damage?

no actually it drops the figure of 3 million to 20,000 and even calls that an exaggeration

Look at the page 25 of the report as it describes the horrific incidents:

14. Maj. Gen. Nazar Hussain Shah, GOC 16 Division, conceded that
"there were rumors that Bengalis were disposed of without trial."
Similarly, Brigadier Abdul Qadir Khan (Witness No. 243) Commander 93
(A)? admitted that "a number of instance of picking up Bengalis did take
place." Lt. Col. S. S. H. Bokhari, CO of 29 Cavalry, appearing as Witness
no 244, stated that "In Rangpur two officers and 30 men were disposed
Hamoodur Rahman Commission Report 26
of without trial. It may have happened in other stations as well." An
admission was also made by Lt. Col. S. M. Naeem (Witness No 258) CO
of 39 Baluch that "innocent people were killed by us during sweep
operations and it created estrangement amongst the public."
15. Lt Col. Mansoorul Haq, GSO-I, Division, appearing as Witness No
260, has made detailed and specific allegations as follows:
"A Bengali, who was alleged to be a Mukti Bahini or Awami Leaguer, was
being sent to Bangladesh-a code name for death without trial, without
detailed investigations and without any written order by any authorised
authority."
Indiscriminate killing and looting could only serve the cause of the
enemies of Pakistan. In the harshness, we lost the support of the silent
majority of the people of East Pakistan.... The Comilla Cantt. massacre
(on 27th/28th of March, 1971) under the orders of CO 53 Field
Regiment, Lt. Gen. Yakub Malik, in which 17 Bengali Officers and 915
men were just slain by a flick of one Officer's fingers should suffice as an
example.

Another example on page 26 :

Salda Nadi area about 500 persons were killed.
When the army moved to clear the rural areas and small towns, it
moved in a ruthless manner, destroying, burning and killing. The rebels
while retreating carried out reprisals against non-Bengalis.
16. Several civilian officers have also deposed in a similar vein, and it
would suffice to quote here the words of Mr. Mohammad Ashraf,
Hamoodur Rahman Commission Report 27
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Dacca, to whose evidence we have
also referred earlier in another context. He stated that "after the
military action the Bengalis were made aliens in their own homeland.
The life, property, and honour of even the most highly placed among
them were not safe. People were picked up from their homes on
suspicion and dispatched to Bangladesh, a term used to describe
summary executions. .... The victims included Army and Police Officers,
businessmen, civilian officers etc....There was no Rule of Law in East
Pakistan. A man had no remedy if he was on the wanted list of the
Army.... Army Officers who were doing intelligence were raw hands,
ignorant of the local language and callous of Bengali sensibilities."
17. About the attitude of senior officers in this behalf, Brigadier Iqbalur
Rehman Shariff (Witness no. 269), has alleged that during his visit to
formations in East Pakistan General Gul Hassan used to ask the soldiers
"how many Bengalis have you shot."

 

[Jf Thunder]

Means you haven't read it. Read the actual one.

Even if it was 2,000 what would you call it? Collateral damage?

please, i am sure after we are finished with the Taliban, some Indian or Afghan will be writing a book as to how the big bad PA, killed 20,000 or so innocent tribals, and will forget to mention that they were terrorists and that they had killed 60,000+ Pakistanis

Means you haven't read it. Read the actual one.

Even if it was 2,000 what would you call it? Collateral damage?


Look at the page 25 of the report as it describes the horrific incidents:

14. Maj. Gen. Nazar Hussain Shah, GOC 16 Division, conceded that
"there were rumors that Bengalis were disposed of without trial."
Similarly, Brigadier Abdul Qadir Khan (Witness No. 243) Commander 93
(A)? admitted that "a number of instance of picking up Bengalis did take
place." Lt. Col. S. S. H. Bokhari, CO of 29 Cavalry, appearing as Witness
no 244, stated that "In Rangpur two officers and 30 men were disposed
Hamoodur Rahman Commission Report 26
of without trial. It may have happened in other stations as well." An
admission was also made by Lt. Col. S. M. Naeem (Witness No 258) CO
of 39 Baluch that "innocent people were killed by us during sweep
operations and it created estrangement amongst the public."
15. Lt Col. Mansoorul Haq, GSO-I, Division, appearing as Witness No
260, has made detailed and specific allegations as follows:
"A Bengali, who was alleged to be a Mukti Bahini or Awami Leaguer, was
being sent to Bangladesh-a code name for death without trial, without
detailed investigations and without any written order by any authorised
authority."
Indiscriminate killing and looting could only serve the cause of the
enemies of Pakistan. In the harshness, we lost the support of the silent
majority of the people of East Pakistan.... The Comilla Cantt. massacre
(on 27th/28th of March, 1971) under the orders of CO 53 Field
Regiment, Lt. Gen. Yakub Malik, in which 17 Bengali Officers and 915
men were just slain by a flick of one Officer's fingers should suffice as an
example.

Another example on page 26 :

Salda Nadi area about 500 persons were killed.
When the army moved to clear the rural areas and small towns, it
moved in a ruthless manner, destroying, burning and killing. The rebels
while retreating carried out reprisals against non-Bengalis.
16. Several civilian officers have also deposed in a similar vein, and it
would suffice to quote here the words of Mr. Mohammad Ashraf,
Hamoodur Rahman Commission Report 27
Additional Deputy Commissioner, Dacca, to whose evidence we have
also referred earlier in another context. He stated that "after the
military action the Bengalis were made aliens in their own homeland.
The life, property, and honour of even the most highly placed among
them were not safe. People were picked up from their homes on
suspicion and dispatched to Bangladesh, a term used to describe
summary executions. .... The victims included Army and Police Officers,
businessmen, civilian officers etc....There was no Rule of Law in East
Pakistan. A man had no remedy if he was on the wanted list of the
Army.... Army Officers who were doing intelligence were raw hands,
ignorant of the local language and callous of Bengali sensibilities."
17. About the attitude of senior officers in this behalf, Brigadier Iqbalur
Rehman Shariff (Witness no. 269), has alleged that during his visit to
formations in East Pakistan General Gul Hassan used to ask the soldiers
"how many Bengalis have you shot."

and do please rad about the massacres of the West Pakistanis by the Mukhti Bani before 23 March and after 16 December

 

[Neemo neemo]

please, i am sure after we are finished with the Taliban, some Indian or Afghan will be writing a book as to how the big bad PA, killed 20,000 or so innocent tribals, and will forget to mention that they were terrorists and that they had killed 60,000+ Pakistanis


and do please rad about the massacres of the West Pakistanis by the Mukhti Bani before 23 March and after 16 December

Some Indian or Afghan you say?

That's why i said you should read and educate yourself.

Chief JusticeHamoodur Rahman (Bengali: হামুদুর রহমান; Urdu: حمود الرحمن‎; November 1, 1910 – October 31, 1975) was the seventh Chief Justice of Pakistan and the vice-chancellor of the Dhaka University as well as professor of law at the Karachi University

Chief Justice Hamoodur Rahman remained a respectable and honorable name in Pakistan's judiciary, and he was publicly hailed by the Chief Justice Khalil-ur-Rehman Ramday. His commission's fact finding and, even for his personal role, is widely regarded as the most honorable commission

And yeah 1 more very important thing.

Justice Hamoodur Rahman held various dignified positions during his judicial career. He was a member of the International Court of Arbitration (The Hague, 1959–60), chairman of the Commission on Students Problems and Welfare (1964), member of Law Reforms Commission (1967), member of War Enquiry Commission (1972), member of United NationsCommittee on Crime Prevention and Control (1972–1973), and chairman of the Council of Islamic Ideology, Pakistan (1974–1977). Hamoodur Rahman chose to remain a citizen of Pakistan after the Bangladesh Liberation War.

Hamoodur Rahman - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

 

[airmarshal]

Bangladesh. A country which traded freedom to be colony of India. Such a shame.

 

[Neemo neemo]

and do please rad about the massacres of the West Pakistanis by the Mukhti Bani before 23 March and after 16 December

Go ahead, Educate me.

 

[nForce]

Bangladesh. A country which traded freedom to be colony of India. Such a shame.

Read the Hamoodur Rahman Commission Report. It's written by a Pakistani, appointed by the govt. of Pakistan.

 

[Sliver]

All effect of Pure land movement. None of these had happened at this scale. People wouldnt die during partition, in 1971, in Kashmir, in Assam and in Arakan. Regional people should have partitioned based on common ethnicity and culture not religion. Above all we shouldnt have formed any kinds of union with now known Pakistan.

that one line has so much value!
Ethnicity is the real "identifier"
religion can change very easily - at the drop of a hat I can change my religion. But that doesnt change my ethnicity.
It would perhaps be easier on the world if the political boundaries were based on ethnicities

 

[Jf Thunder]

Go ahead, Educate me.

im not here to type whole essays,
Read "Blood and Tears"
"Truth Behind the Three Million" by Abdul Munim Chaudry
"Betrayal of East Pakistan" by Lt Gen A.A.K Niazi
"Dead Reckoning" by Sarmila Bose

Some Indian or Afghan you say?

That's why i said you should read and educate yourself.

Chief JusticeHamoodur Rahman (Bengali: হামুদুর রহমান; Urdu: حمود الرحمن‎; November 1, 1910 – October 31, 1975) was the seventh Chief Justice of Pakistan and the vice-chancellor of the Dhaka University as well as professor of law at the Karachi University

Chief Justice Hamoodur Rahman remained a respectable and honorable name in Pakistan's judiciary, and he was publicly hailed by the Chief Justice Khalil-ur-Rehman Ramday. His commission's fact finding and, even for his personal role, is widely regarded as the most honorable commission

And yeah 1 more very important thing.

Justice Hamoodur Rahman held various dignified positions during his judicial career. He was a member of the International Court of Arbitration (The Hague, 1959–60), chairman of the Commission on Students Problems and Welfare (1964), member of Law Reforms Commission (1967), member of War Enquiry Commission (1972), member of United NationsCommittee on Crime Prevention and Control (1972–1973), and chairman of the Council of Islamic Ideology, Pakistan (1974–1977). Hamoodur Rahman chose to remain a citizen of Pakistan after the Bangladesh Liberation War.

Hamoodur Rahman - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

did I talk about Hommod Ur Rehman

 

[Rocky25]

im not here to type whole essays,
Read "Blood and Tears"
"Truth Behind the Three Million" by Abdul Munim Chaudry
"Betrayal of East Pakistan" by Lt Gen A.A.K Niazi
"Dead Reckoning" by Sarmila Bose

Ha ha ha... A thief is writing his own judgement!

 

[riasat]

As for honour, you guys killed your own founding father. Your country is run by India, so come back to us when you are not an Indian colony. Cheers.

The people who killed the founding father were either hanged or is currently absconding...

The other part of your statement where you mentioned "BD run by India" does not even warrant a response..... u watch too much zaid hamid may be...

 

[Neemo neemo]

im not here to type whole essays,
Read "Blood and Tears"
"Truth Behind the Three Million" by Abdul Munim Chaudry
"Betrayal of East Pakistan" by Lt Gen A.A.K Niazi
"Dead Reckoning" by Sarmila Bose

Oh yeah, Conspiracy theory masala book for teatime snack. Is that the best you got?

You are quoting these jokes in comparison to Chief Justice of Pakistan's commission's report on an international atrocity? Really? Let me salute you Fuhrer.

 

[IceCold]

Its time we start supporting other factions in BD. Sheikh Hasina's government is illegitimate to begin with. She is selling the blood of people of BD in return for India's support to keep her in power. Pakistan should become more vocal about it.

 

[salarsikander]

P.S. @Horus himself tops the list of trolling.

Hi,

@Horus this is what Indians have view about you, I guess its time you spoke with them in your own tongue.

Hi,
Nothing less was expected from you anyway, A clear sign of trolling.

I only responded when you went personal, So in essence you started it first.

 

[Neemo neemo]

Hi,

@Horus this is what Indians have view about you, I guess its time you spoke with them in your own tongue.

Hi,
Nothing less was expected from you anyway, A clear sign of trolling.

I only responded when you went personal, So in essence you started it first.

Responded how exactly?

Oh yeah, By being personal yourself.