These are all regular servicemen, not "peons' etc. I think this was an isolated case of poor showing. The military bands generally do orchestra well.
The videos you included (Thanks) are good but because only bigger bands are used and the mediocrity therefore does not show as much.
Bhai my point was - whatever one's origin in life (could be low financial/social status) a Navy serviceman (or woman) needs to be groomed with the requisite training and resources (tools) to rise to the best of their ability. We have bad managers, not bad conscripts.
Somewhere the training/grooming process failed and the result is an extremely poor showing. We may pay them less at our navy's pay scale, but why will their talents be any less than what a US Navy conscript has?
Is IQ low?
If it is, then we can surely pick from better IQ candidates. Our population is (for Allah's sake) bigger than Russia and one third that of the US.
We simply have no excuse.
Our GDP per capita is better than that of India, most standards should be better than theirs too....
Participating in their republic day parade, it became apparent how bad our band standards are compared to theirs.
This "No-one-gives-a-shit" ism (lack of accountability) pervades everything in our National sphere and our national discourse.
No wonder the British bundled "Dogs and Indians" in the same class and did not want to allow them in their clubs. They knew what we are collectively made of.
Band-wise we need to try a lot harder....