Attack on Pak will be attack on China: report

[IND151]

Korean war:

- China told the USA to stop pushing into North Korea
- The USA refused
- China attacked, and pushed American forces completely out of North Korea

Sino-Indian War:

- China told India to stop pushing into Chinese territory
- India refused
- China attacked, and pushed Indian forces completely out of Aksai chin

The Indian members here, should learn from history. The Chinese government doesn't bluff very often.

1971 war

china had relations with Pakistan. India waited for winter and started Bangladesh liberation war. India defeated Pakistan. this weakened Chinese position in south Asia.


1984

India took siachen glacier.

both times china couldn't do anything.

1999 kargil war

India retook land and peaks captured by Pakistani army.

again china couldn't prevent victory of India.

 

[Developereo]

I can't believe this ridiculous thread is still going!

This should be merged with the 'Whatever' thread because it is pointless ping pong.

Bottom line: even if the US declares official war on Pakistan, China will NOT intervene militarily and put its cities at risk. The statement is meaningless diplomatic nonsense.

 

[roadrunner]

I wouldn't be too sure that China can do nothing. China could not do anything for a long time. But the last five years have seen J-9s, J-10s, even J-20s.

Plus economic influence and China can start thowing some of its influence around.

 

[Developereo]

I wouldn't be too sure that China can do nothing. China could not do anything for a long time. But the last five years have seen J-9s, J-10s, even J-20s.

Plus economic influence and China can start thowing some of its influence around.

Do you honestly think China will put Beijing under the gun for Islamabad?
No country is going to fight the US for anyone else. Only if they are themselves attacked directly.

The only time that was a credible deterrent was when there was an explicit military alliance to that effect, i.e. the Warsaw Pact.

Right now, even the SCO and BRICS have no military obligations to their members.

 

[roadrunner]

I honestly don't know what China would do, or whether it would do nothing.

China has interests in Pakistan, China says it will regard it as an attack on China. You can interpret that how you like. Personally I see China's economic leverage as quite strong though I wouldn't discount its military leverage either.

If China isn't strong enough to use its military it most likely won't use it.

 

[huzihaidao12]

I can only say, it is possible, as long as the security commitment is true.

 

[Protectionist Gareth]

Now our military might and the friendship with Pakistan is on another level.

If anything like 1971 has repeated again, then you will soon see our PLA army conducting a military parade in Delhi.

They think of doing that...their D!cks will be chopped off!

 

[below_freezing]

I can't believe this ridiculous thread is still going!

This should be merged with the 'Whatever' thread because it is pointless ping pong.

Bottom line: even if the US declares official war on Pakistan, China will NOT intervene militarily and put its cities at risk. The statement is meaningless diplomatic nonsense.

We went to war for North Korea of all countries even after US threatened to nuke us.

What's the US gonna do if we go in? Nuke Beijing? We can't nuke NYC and Washington?

 

[ChinaToday]

Do you honestly think China will put Beijing under the gun for Islamabad?
No country is going to fight the US for anyone else. Only if they are themselves attacked directly.

The only time that was a credible deterrent was when there was an explicit military alliance to that effect, i.e. the Warsaw Pact.

Right now, even the SCO and BRICS have no military obligations to their members.

well we did fight the US for North korea and vietnam.

 

[secularbuster]

Already the americans are inciting the Afghans to attack Pakistan. This afternnon the Afghan military positions inside Pakistan were blown to pieces by PAF. Afghans would not dare do it without backing from Washington. Washington is gambling, the americans are forcing Pakistan to act in self defence, they are speculating that China won't get involved.

 

[secularbuster]

I wouldn't be too sure that China can do nothing. China could not do anything for a long time. But the last five years have seen J-9s, J-10s, even J-20s.

Plus economic influence and China can start thowing some of its influence around.

It's time that China starts using its economic and military stick to humble uncle sam or else things are going to go out of control pretty soon.

 

[Vinod2070]

Do not pretend to care for the suffering Pakistanis because we all know that the more Pakistanis who suffer, the more happy you indians get.

Pakistan does not need carrot-on-a-stick aid. Pakistan needs trade and business to stand on its own feet and China always has offered Pakistan that.

China has done more than plenty to help the flood victims in Pakistan.

China pledges $250m flood aid to Pakistan

Check out the actual money given, not pledged.

It was less than $ 20 million as per the reports on your own country's web site.

 

[Outman]

It's just a message directed to countries that might feel the slightest urge to fight proxy wars for uncle sam, while hoping the nato potatoes and what not would align with them in the process.

Ten years ago I would say with absolute certainty that we were set on a ever peaceful path, but right now I am much less convinced.....The top brass of military seems more and more eager for a showtime, since the possibility of an all-out CN-US war is now next to zero, I dont believe they are as reluctant to get involved in a regional conflict as before with all the new toys they've got recently and will be getting in the coming years.

People who understand how important south asia is to china wont take this lightly, finger crossed these are the people in charge.

 

[Vinod2070]

We went to war for North Korea of all countries even after US threatened to nuke us.

What's the US gonna do if we go in? Nuke Beijing? We can't nuke NYC and Washington?

You went for your own interests. Don't pretend it was done for charity.

Why the special love for North Korea and not South Korea? They are the same people.

Why are you not taking over Taiwan if it is so easy for you to clash with the US?

 

[Vinod2070]

Now our military might and the friendship with Pakistan is on another level.

If anything like 1971 has repeated again, then you will soon see our PLA army conducting a military parade in Delhi.

I see you like to fight a war while sitting safely in Canada.

You care a damn for the millions of your civilians and soldiers who face danger from a likely nuke war.