An eye opener for Indian Muslims

[Agha Sher]

It was Tipu Sultan who said "SHER KI AIK DIN KI ZINDAGI GEEDAR KI SOU SALA ZINDAGI SE BEHTAR HAI".. expect much more from the land where people like Tipu were born.

Could you kindly translate the words of Tipu Sultan for me?

 

[The BrOkEn HeArT]

My ancestors were Hindus. I love the fact that they accepted Islam. May Allah bless them!

I have no issue with anyone accepting Islam. Good for you unless you don't create issues for others because of your faith.

 

[PakSword]

Could you kindly translate the words of Tipu Sultan for me?

It's an urdu saying.. which literally means "A lion's one day is better than 100 years of a jackal".. English idiom is "A coward dies hundred times a day, the brave meets death but once!"

 

[Kaniska]

Your broken heart wasn't invited to respond to my comment. But to set the record straight, minorities in India aren't safe now and there are still protests happening despite corona scare. In Pakistan, we don't have any problem.

Comparing minorities between India and Pakistan is not valid...Neither you have equal rights in the constitution for minorities not you have 20% population who are minority....

But if some one give us any choice at a given day, we should love to make India, a Hindu Pakistan rather than the current day India....I seriously envy Pakistan for the right decision that your leaders have made at the right time....Now at least you do not have issues that we have to deal with it...

 

[Balbir]

For all of Muslim members from India....

https://twitter.com/x/status/1246095293264941057

He is correct about art 14 of Indian constitutions.

Art 14 though talks of equality of all Indian citizens before law.

Article 14 also permits classification, so long as it is 'reasonable' where broader definition of equality can be set aside.

For example, India's reservation law which reservation parliamentary seats, Govt job for SC/ST aka Dalits and Adivasi(tribals) and so also for OBCs.

One can argue since, everyone is equal why SC/ST, OBC are getting benefits for reservation while Upper Castes are deprived of it. Here indian constituton says, SC/ST who face caste discrimination can be classified as a special group who need special care, hence broder definition of equality Art 14 can't applied against reservation of law.

In that short clip, Swamy was giving his opinion why Art 14 can't applied for CAA law since Muslims from Pakistan and Bangladesh are not persecuted in their countries unlike non-muslims who classified as a group people eligible for CAA on basis of religious persecution they face in those countries. Btw this has nothing to do with Indian muslims or other citizens of India.

 

[Ace of Spades]

Comparing minorities between India and Pakistan is not valid...Neither you have equal rights in the constitution for minorities not you have 20% population who are minority....

But if some one at given day, I will love to make India, a Hindu Pakistan than the current day India....I seriously envy Pakistan for the right decision that your leaders have made at the right time....Now at least you do not have issues that we have to deal with it...

You can still lobby to split the country and carve another muslim state out of india

 

[Agha Sher]

It's an urdu saying.. which literally means "A lion's one day is better than 100 years of a jackal".. English idiom is "A coward dies hundred times a day, the brave meets death but once!"

What a man he was. Have read about his life and achievements several times.

 

[Kaniska]

You can still lobby to split the country and carve another muslim state out of india

Trust me....I am all for it...If Gandhiji would have been smart, we could have a peaceful South Asia...India should have been at least made a Non-Muslim nation with the clear cut demarcation of land where no one has any grievances about each other...But, we can not go back to history without any bloodshed and loss of human lives...So it is our choice which road to choose for our future....

 

[Ace of Spades]

Trust me....I am all for it...If Gandhiji would have been smart, we could have a peaceful South Asia...India should have been at least made a Non-Muslim nation with the clear cut demarcation of land where no has any grievances about each other...But, we can not go back to history without any bloodshed and loss of human lives...So it is our choice which road to choose for our future....

Bingo! you have found your purpose.

 

[SIPRA]

Bingo! you have found your purpose.

"Aaj man nain pa liya hae, zindagi ko bay niqaab"

 

[xeuss]

I have no issue with anyone accepting Islam. Good for you unless you don't create issues for others because of your faith.

Thanks. Now reflect upon your life and tell me how many Muslims have negatively affected your life or your livelihood. You will struggle to come up with any examples. And if they were any, they were more reflective of that person's personality rather than his religion. For example, if a person cheated you, it was because of his poor ethics, rather than his faith.

Most of your hatred towards Muslims has been fed by WhatsApp forwards, and the Radio Rwanda type of media. Get out of it.

 

[SIPRA]

Bingo! you have found your purpose.

These days these Hindutvadis are coming up with highly imaginative and fanciful theories, which I fail to gather, they get wherefrom.

 

[fisher1]

Easy to say when you are not one of them. They are awake, just cannot do anything about it except deal with it with patience. When the whole state machinery is against you at every level, it is not easy.

I know some of you will say that stand up and fight. That is a legitimate ask, but often the impression is that the fight is with violence only. There are other ways of fighting, and we are doing our best under the circumstances. Muslims are in the forefront of charitable acts, educating non-Muslims on them and using legal remedies where possible. Results are in the hands of Allah, and insha'Allah, one day we will prevail.

There is really no end in sight for the sufferings of Muslims in India. The are stuck in a country where the majority hate them for no fault of their own. Things will only get worse. Some people can emigrate and leave, but that is not the option for the majority of them. Today I live a comfortable life in the West, but I have no joy at my position. I feel I have abandoned my people.

It's quite funny actually.

Uighurs stood up to oppressors and the whole population got locked up. Now, neither Pakistanis or any Muslim leaders want to support them, in fact, they're called separatist terrorists.

Believe you me, if these Indian Muslims stood up and got locked up by India, from Pakistan to every Muslim leader in the world will call them separatist terrorists and support India instead.

Today, Muslims have the type of leaders to whom their small pieces of land are extremely valuable. It's foolish to depend on these leader's help. I suggest all Muslims in the world to slave over and be obedient servants and beg Allah to give us better leaders.

Look at Kashmir. Has anyone done anything for them except lip service?.

And it's not like Muslims don't have military power either. They do but it's just for show off and killing other Muslims.

 

[Ace of Spades]

Thanks. Now reflect upon your life and tell me how many Muslims have negatively affected your life or your livelihood. You will struggle to come up with any examples. And if they were any, they were more reflective of that person's personality rather than his religion. For example, if a person cheated you, it was because of his poor ethics, rather than his faith.

Most of your hatred towards Muslims has been fed by WhatsApp forwards, and the Radio Rwanda type of media. Get out of it.

You are confusing two things, there are indeed good and bad people. But when there is a mass campaign to smear a certain minority and that minority gets discriminated because of their religion, then it gets absurd. And that's exactly what's happening in India

 

[xeuss]

You are confusing two things, there are indeed good and bad people. But when there is a mass campaign to smear a certain minority and that minority gets discriminated because of their religion, then it gets absurd. And that's exactly what's happening in India

I know dude. Not that dumb. My point was most of those Hindus complaining about Muslims, have never had a bad experience with them in their lives. All this is fed by the smear campaign you speak about.