Amitabh Bachchan in legaltrouble over Quran remark

[Icewolf]

^^ I can just laugh, you know from inside where you stand in your argument. I rest my case, all the world know the difference so does we.

Running away so soon? Can't you revoke my argument? Lol!

 

[trident2010]

Running away so soon? Can't you revoke my argument? Lol!

Well there is nothing to run away, we can see the position where my country stands and where your country is falling. We don't need to argue from someone where systematic ethnic cleansing is norm. No use to argue with losers !!

 

[Icewolf]

Well there is nothing to run away, we can see the position where my country stands and where your country is falling. We don't need to argue from someone where systematic ethnic cleansing is norm. No use to argue with losers !!

Dalit & Muslim are tortured, persecuted in India. They are being ethnically cleansed from India. Just recently one of your ministers said to Muslims "Go back to Pakistan".

And you have the gall to talk about Pakistan?

 

[notsuperstitious]

@trident2010 must you? This must be causing you IQ points, the damage may be irreversible. why do you want to take the risk?

 

[KRAIT]

President position in India have no value. It's just a ceremonial post.As for the Muslim "Cheif" Justice in India, you are mistaken. Those are just average Justices. No Muslim Chief Justice in India yet.I agree. There is no comparison.
Non-punjabis, Shia, Ahmedi, Muhajir live much better than Dalit, Muslim in India.
They get WAY more representation in govt & Army than Sunnis than Muslim or Dalit in India..
Pakistan has had a Pasthun, Balochi, Muhajir, Shia President
Same with COAS.
Same with PM as well.
Can you name a Muslim PM? Hell, you just had a Muslim FM after 65 years of independence.

Out of the twelve Presidents of independent India, three were Muslims – Zakir Hussain, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and A.P.J. Abdul Kalam.

Currently 5 Muslim Chief Justice of Supreme Court. And I am just talking about present. There has been many before.
Current Vice President is Muslim.
Narendra Modi Chief Minister belongs to backward class.
Mayawati, ex- Chief Minister of UP. from Dalit class.
Umar Abdullah, Chief Minister of J&K,


As for Pashtuns, etc. we are talking of minorities from different religion.
Did you ever had Sikh or Hindu, President, Prime Minister, even Finance Minister ?

 

[notsuperstitious]

Out of the twelve Presidents of independent India, three were Muslims – Zakir Hussain, Fakhruddin Ali Ahmed and A.P.J. Abdul Kalam.

Currently 5 Muslim Chief Justice of Supreme Court. And I am just talking about present. There has been many before.
Current Vice President is Muslim.
Narendra Modi Chief Minister belongs to backward class.
Mayawati, ex- Chief Minister of UP. from Dalit class.
Umar Abdullah, Chief Minister of J&K,


As for Pashtuns, etc. we are talking of minorities from different religion.
Did you ever had Sikh or Hindu, President, Prime Minister, even Finance Minister ?

Krait, can't you see the snivelling scum is just lying and pulling up ''facts'' from its backside. Must you entertain such lowlives?

 

[Mav3rick]

go cry me a river or read the meaning of secularism.

Pakistanis talking about secularism is like evil preaching the bible.

Matter of fact, a Pakistani is showing you the mirror to prove beyond doubt what a hypocrate country you Indians are! Doing the exact same things that you blame us for. Atleast we do not preach secularism to the world and portray ourselves as an example while indulding in all sorts of terrorism and minority suppression!!

Pakistanis speaking about religious tolerance .........Funny day .

It's funny to you because you have never understood anything. We have always spoken of religious tolerance and respect for all religions, including Islam.

 

[Mav3rick]

Well if it takes something as small as this, that too unintentional, for Muslims to get offended, then maybe Muslims like this nut case petitioner should lock themselves up in a cave or something.

Its India, we have Indian Penal Code not Shariah. I hope this clown gets fined for wasting the court's time.

I wonder what makes you the authority to decide what is small and what is big in some one elses religion. So often I refrained asking genuine questions about Hinduism from my Hindu friends so as to not hurt their sentiments even though I considered the things to be trivial. Besides, trivial words uttered by important men do become important by virue of the person's stature, is that not true?

 

[kurup]

It's funny to you because you have never understood anything. We have always spoken of religious tolerance and respect for all religions, including Islam.

Ever reducing minority population , abduction , rape and forcefull conversion of minority women and minorities escaping to India ---- That is some weird form of religious tolerance you have understood.

 

[Roybot]

I wonder what makes you the authority to decide what is small and what is big in some one elses religion. So often I refrained asking genuine questions about Hinduism from my Hindu friends so as to not hurt their sentiments even though I considered the things to be trivial. Besides, trivial words uttered by important men do become important by virue of the person's stature, is that not true?

I wonder if you actually bothered to read the "question" which seem to offended this particular Muslim.

Allow me to quote it for you,

On September 28, 2011, Amitabh as show host had asked a Fastest Finger First participant to organise Bible, Gurugranth Sahib, Quran and Ved in the sequence of their compilation.

Now couple of things,

Had this not been a trivial issue, how come it took this Muslim man almost year and a half to feel offended? I mean there are like 150 Million Muslims in India, if this was such a blatant disrespect to Islam or whatever how come no one else noticed it all this time?

Secondly, whats wrong about asking about when the Quran was compiled? Wasn't it compiled at some point of time? Sure, according to you guys it was words of God, but the book itself was compiled by someone, a human being!

Had it not been the case, why are Muslim organizations and Muslims themselves talking about the compilation of the Quran?

A quick google search will spit out hundreds, if not thousands of examples,

The QUR`AN - How it was Revealed and Compiled

The Quran Compiled by Imam Ali (AS)

When Quran was compiled?

Compilation of the Quran

Compilation and Infallibility of the Qur'an | Religion | Islamic Insights


Now tell me, if Muslims themselves, and Islamic organizations themselves are talking about the compilation of the Quran, why the heck should Amitabh be apologizing to anyone?

You lots need to let go of this victim mentality of yours.

 

[Mav3rick]

Ever reducing minority population , abduction , rape and forcefull conversion of minority women and minorities escaping to India ---- That is some weird form of religious tolerance you have understood.

That does happen in Pakistan too, however the cause is land and goods and not religion. It's just easier to suppress minority. But can 1 wrong be justified by another?

I wonder if you actually bothered to read the "question" which seem to offended this particular Muslim.

Allow me to quote it for you,



Now couple of things,

Had this not been a trivial issue, how come it took this Muslim man almost year and a half to feel offended? I mean there are like 150 Million Muslims in India, if this was such a blatant disrespect to Islam or whatever how come no one else noticed it all this time?

Secondly, whats wrong about asking about when the Quran was compiled? Wasn't it compiled at some point of time? Sure, according to you guys it was words of God, but the book itself was compiled by someone, a human being!

Had it not been the case, why are Muslim organizations and Muslims themselves talking about the compilation of the Quran?

A quick google search will spit out hundreds, if not thousands of examples,

The QUR`AN - How it was Revealed and Compiled

The Quran Compiled by Imam Ali (AS)

When Quran was compiled?

Compilation of the Quran

Compilation and Infallibility of the Qur'an | Religion | Islamic Insights


Now tell me, if Muslims themselves, and Islamic organizations themselves are talking about the compilation of the Quran, why the heck should Amitabh be apologizing to anyone?

You lots need to let go of this victim mentality of yours.

Ofcourse, Qur'an was compiled. But if you look at the first post the words used were "Racha Gaya" which point more towards writing rather than compiling. If I have misunderstood then it is my mistake.

 

[trident2010]

we muslims came from outside n ruled you hindus n sikhs for a thousand years

Its a very confusing situation, on the one side you said that arab muslims (not you lot, as you all were converts) ruled thousand of year but somehow you reached in such a pathetic state by 1900's that muslims were most backward and poor people in Indian subcontinent and Hindus/Sikhs/Parsi communities were ruling your lot?

Now you have Pakistan but with same story?

May be country like Pakistan creates such a doubt in other countries that they don't trust muslims, so by doing what you do in your country you are risking the future of muslims in other country too.

 

[Roybot]

Ofcourse, Qur'an was compiled. But if you look at the first post the words used were "Racha Gaya" which point more towards writing rather than compiling. If I have misunderstood then it is my mistake.

Racha Gaya or Rachna means Created/Creation, it can also mean compiled if used in a different context. If in this case the question meant creation/created, even that wouldn't be wrong or offensive, as it was a creation of God as per your belief, right?

Am not sure if you are familiar with the format of KBC, but the questions are asked both in Hindi and English, so there should be no ambiguity over the use of word "racha gaya" as it meant compiled in this case.

 

[kurup]

That does happen in Pakistan too, however the cause is land and goods and not religion. It's just easier to suppress minority. But can 1 wrong be justified by another?

You are just trying to create dark by closing eyes.

The fact is religious tolerance in India is much better than pakistan .

We have a growing minority while you have been systematically eliminating your's.

 

[notsuperstitious]

Limus test - Hafiz saeed the charity worker and eminent water conservationist has invited shahrukh khan to move to islamic republic of pakistan.

If he moves to pakistan (or any other country as he's a famous billionaire who any country will happily accept) where he will obviously be safer because its an islamic republic, then we will accept the state of minorities is the same in both countries, as there are so many cases of hindus and sikhs moving to India from PK lately. Otherwise we will accept you guys are too insecure and always trying to misread anything an indian muslim says.

Untill then, your silly propaganda means nothing, and as to the case, the indian supreme court headed by chief justice almatas kabir - a muslim himself, ably assisted by solicitor general nariman - a parsee, is more than capable of handling the issue. You guys can breate easy, do yoga, helps.