American Muslims celebrate 4th of July

[Ehsan]

Every 4th of July Americans celebrate their Independence Day and American Muslims following the teaching of Prophet Muhammad SAW that “Love of one's homeland (country) is part of faith” celebrate the occasion with their fellow Americans. ‪‬‪#‎4thofJuly‬‪ #‎Islam‬‪ #‎America‬‪ #‎Muslims‬

Rabwah Times - Every 4th of July Americans celebrate their... | Facebook

 

[rockstar08]

Great Job

 

[Kaniska]

Of course...they always celebrate...What is the big deal in it...They are American...Even Indian Muslim celebrate India independence day..

 

[VCheng]

@Irfan Baloch @Oscar Sirs, is the title of the thread correct, given the OP's content?

 

[SQ8]

@Irfan Baloch @Oscar Sirs, is the title of the thread correct, given the OP's content?

They are American muslims and celebrating 4th of July? What are you insinuating?

 

[terry5]

Every 4th of July Americans celebrate their Independence Day and American Muslims following the teaching of Prophet Muhammad SAW that “Love of one's homeland (country) is part of faith” celebrate the occasion with their fellow Americans. ‪‬‪#‎4thofJuly‬‪ #‎Islam‬‪ #‎America‬‪ #‎Muslims‬

Rabwah Times - Every 4th of July Americans celebrate their... | Facebook

Sorry i dont mean to be offensive but i Dont see any Muslims in the pictures .

Can the title of the thread be changed please as this is offensive to the posters on here who your prophet has classed as Kaafir .

 

[VCheng]

They are American muslims and celebrating 4th of July? What are you insinuating?

They are as much Muslims as their man in Tuvalu who was recently honored was a Pakistani. I have no problem with it, but their claims run counter to official Pakistani policy. That's all.

 

[SQ8]

They are as much Muslims as their man in Tuvalu who was recently honored was a Pakistani. I have no problem with it, but their claims run counter to official Pakistani policy. That's all.

Does it say Pakistani there? Im not seeing it anywhere

 

[syedali73]

Does it say Pakistani there? Im not seeing it anywhere

The pictures posted are certain individuals who belong to Ahmadya community and not a whole lot of Muslims. Though the title in general terms is not incorrect, it does not match with the post and pictures posted therein.

If Ahmadi or Qadyani really think they are Muslims or think non-Ahmedia are also Muslims, there is no need to use word 'Ahmadya Muslims'. It is like a bunch of Shia or Sunni or Barelvi or Aga Khani organized a gathering and hold banners that read "Shia Muslim community', 'Sunni Muslim community', etc. This does not look right for such banners divide, not unite.

 

[SQ8]

The pictures posted are certain individuals who belong to Ahmadya community and not a whole lot of Muslims. Though the title in general terms is not incorrect, it does not match with the post and pictures posted therein.

If Ahmadi or Qadyani really think they are Muslims or think non-Ahmedia are also Muslims, there is no need to use word 'Ahmadya Muslims'. It is like a bunch of Shia or Sunni or Barelvi or Aga Khani organized a gathering and hold banners that read "Shia Muslim community', 'Sunni Muslim community', etc. This does not look right for such banners divide, not unite.

Their organization is called that and hence they are advertising that. I see less malicious intent in there. It is best not to pointlessly incite divide where there is none.

 

[VCheng]

Their organization is called that and hence they are advertising that. I see less malicious intent in there. It is best not to pointlessly incite divide where there is none.

There is already this thread:

Happy 4th of July

 

[syedali73]

Their organization is called that and hence they are advertising that. I see less malicious intent in there. It is best not to pointlessly incite divide where there is none.

It is not an organization rather a community or cult and my assertions are not as pointless either. With those banners, they were not representing Muslims rather Ahmadya community and reassuring Americans that Ahmadya community is loyal to America. By displaying those banners, they affectively separated themselves from the rest of the Muslims.

 

[Ehsan]

It is not an organization rather a community or cult and my assertions are not as pointless either. With those banners, they were not representing Muslims rather Ahmadya community and reassuring Americans that Ahmadya community is loyal to America. By displaying those banners, they affectively separated themselves from the rest of the Muslims.

So let me get this straight

First you don't consider them Muslims and say they have nothing to do with Islam and then you object to them having a banner that supposedly separates them from rest of the Muslims ? Whet is the logic in that ?

 

[syedali73]

So let me get this straight

First you don't consider them Muslims and say they have nothing to do with Islam and then you object to them having a banner that supposedly separates them from rest of the Muslims ? Whet is the logic in that ?

I did not say any of what you wrote.

 

[Ehsan]

And you know what I think you should appreciate the fact that these "non-Muslims" are out there spending their time and money to show a good name of "your religion" is it that bad ?

I did not say any of what you wrote.

But what you said basically meant what o wrote. Let me explain so if they remove their organization name would you just suddenly accept them as Muslims ? And if they have the org name the you think they are trying to separate themselves from the mainstream Muslim community.