ANMDT
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 9, 2014
- Messages
- 1,278
- Reaction score
- 10
- Country
- Location
Who says our Bridge and roads infrastructure cant handle 60 -70 tonnes vehicles? You should know many construction, plantation and mining vehicles can easily pass such weight, Not to mention such measly weight of 60-70 tonnes MBT like Leopard 2 or Abrams. The only reason why islands Nations like Indonesia, Japan and other Not fielding MBT in such large number like Turkey, India or Pakistan is the difficulties to transport them over the seas between Islands WE had. Logistic is the Main issue here considering our geography lay out as Archipelagic country, if we want to procure 2000 MBT we must considering Not only lowbed transporter to move them at one point to other point but also LST and LHD to move them over the seas, if we want to purchase more LST or LHD WE must considering how many warship in class of corvettes or Frigates to escort them, meaning all of seemingly simple purchase would affect the entire Armed forces purchasing strategy or even the lay out of our doctrine. Thats why even Japan, one of the richest country in This world seem very conservative in their heavy armor purchase, Not to mention us.
We dont intend to insult by saying infastructure may not support heavy tanks but you seem to be offended by that. The above lines refer to Type 90 MBT of Japan and the statement is from Japanese Report. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Type_90_Kyū-maruBeing 12 tonnes heavier than its predecessor Type 74 tank made Type 90 more challenging to operate outside Hokkaido. Some politicians therefore criticized the effectiveness of Type 90 due to difficulty in transportation. In fact, more than 65% of major bridges in Japan were still considered passable for Type 90 while overseas main battle tanks such as Challenger 2 and Leopard 2 could only use 40% of bridges in Japan
Moreover Japan has an effective inter-island transportation plan, fast ferries which may carry their earlier Type 74 smoothly. You cant rely on LHD or LPD to carry all the tanks. Indonesia lacks that effective inter-island transportation and this would cause issues when they need to combine their land forces at an island. FNSS Kaplan is lightweight and effective, can be easily carried and most of roads/bridges can handle it.
FYI Turkey doesnt usually transport Leopard II or in future the Altay by roads, mostly using railways and tank transporters. The mentioned case of using roads/bridges bare relates to wartime.