Aircraft carrier Liaoning vs Vikramaditya

[Hellraiser007]

when its completing? Oh is it also like tejas
and yeah china started building 2 aircraft carriers and totaly planned to build 4 aircraft carrirs

LCA tejas mark 1 is about to enter serial production.

LCA Tejas mark 2 is under development and is about to be completed at the end of 2013.

IAC 2 will enter service in 2017.

 

[Beast]

INS Vikramaditya will have new techs mate

There is another carrier in the making which is much more advanced than INS Vikramaditya.

Indian Carriers have Brahmos supersonic missiles and Indo-Israeli sams which are advanced than Chinese.

Really ? Anti warship like ASBM or mid course interception which Israel has not demonstrated?

 

[GR!FF!N]

why dont you guys first put them on vikrant?

first,Vikrant is retired like,15 years ago(or more)..its Viraat.

2nd,Mig-29K can't be operated from Viraat.

3rd,Liaoning and Vikramaditya can't be compared(one is a training ship,another is air defence ship,their tonnage is different too.its like comparing apple with orange.),neither is J-15 and Mig-29k as their roles are different.also,Viki was a aircraft carrying cruiser,not a aircraft carrier,thats why it carries less aircraft.but it will get job done for us.

 

[Maleesh]

LCA tejas mark 1 is about to enter serial production.

LCA Tejas mark 2 is under development and is about to be completed at the end of 2013.

IAC 2 will enter service in 2017.

serial production right?
How much have been ordered? I guess less than 60 right. and you call that a serial production?

first,Vikrant is retired like,15 years ago(or more)..its Viraat.

2nd,Mig-29K can't be operated from Viraat.

3rd,Liaoning and Vikramaditya can't be compared(one is a training ship,another is air defence ship,their tonnage is different too.its like comparing apple with orange.),neither is J-15 and Mig-29k as their roles are different.also,Viki was a aircraft carrying cruiser,not a aircraft carrier,thats why it carries less aircraft.but it will get job done for us.

yeah its viraat, im sorry
im always not good with names.
But liaoning has combat readiness and its planned vastly to operate within indian ocean and all over the world. And about comparing apple and orange there is always something that tastes good! Im just asking a question like that

 

[Soumitra]

Ofcourse there is no substitute of Indian technology and experience as we can see in Pictures.

Indian

Chinese

रहिमन देखी बढ़ें को, लघू न दीजे टारी । जहॉ काम अावे सुई, कहा करे तलवारी ।।

(Rahiman Dekhi Baden ko , Laghu Na Dije Daari. Jahaan Kaam Aawe Sui, Kaha Kare Tarwari)

Translation Rahim says - When looking at the big don't forget the importance of small. Where a needle can work, a sword has no use

 

[Hellraiser007]

serial production right?
How much have been ordered? I guess less than 60 right. and you call that a serial production?

120 are ordered, You must go through the details before posting anything ignorantly.

 

[Beast]

your talking about 60 years old lady not new one ok... so you don't need to laugh or make comments...

We are not talking about comparing old tech. We are talking about the first place why a tractor exist onboard an carrier deck? This show something wrong with Indian navy doctrine. The so called years of experience operating an carrier is nothing but hot air. Tractor shall stay at farm land.

 

[Capt.Popeye]

oh you think you can operate a carrier with a untrained marines?

Do marines operate Carriers? Marines are armed soldiers who are carried on Ships and landed ashore from ships to fight.
Still waiting for your enlightened response on all aspects of carrier operations and how PLAN is training for them?

 

[Maleesh]

We are not talking about comparing old tech. We are talking about the first place why a tractor exist onboard an carrier deck? This show something wrong with Indian navy doctrine. The so called years of experience operating an carrier is nothing but hot air. Tractor shall stay at farm land.

who knows india maybe planning to harvest the sea too

 

[Hellraiser007]

yeah its viraat, im sorry
im always not good with names.
But liaoning has combat readiness and its planned vastly to operate within indian ocean and all over the world. And about comparing apple and orange there is always something that tastes good! Im just asking a question like that

You have no idea Lioning is not combat ready, India has lot of carriers in Indian oceans (Islands) and each one can accommodate lot of aircraft and marines.

 

[KRAIT]

People see tractor and go nuts. Its India, we always try to find alternative solutions.

We are like this, deal with it.

 

[Maleesh]

120 are ordered, You must go through the details before posting anything ignorantly.

what is your source?and please not stupid blogs controled by indian trol hounds

 

[Hellraiser007]

Really ? Anti warship like ASBM or mid course interception which Israel has not demonstrated?

Israel has already demonstrated their quick reaction anti missile interception in recent Palestine conflict.

what is your source?and please not stupid blogs controled by indian trol hounds

You can check it out, I have given the info.

Seems something is burning here.

 

[danger007]

We are not talking about comparing old tech. We are talking about the first place why a tractor exist onboard an carrier deck? This show something wrong with Indian navy doctrine. The so called years of experience operating an carrier is nothing but hot air. Tractor shall stay at farm land.

your problem is?

 

[Maleesh]

You have no idea Lioning is not combat ready, India has lot of carriers in Indian oceans (Islands) and each one can accommodate lot of aircraft and marines.

do they have shifting facilities? To postions as they want. And if china wants they can use our ports as hubs too.