Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Yes, I know the first british vessels on the soils of Indian subcontinents are your great people not for just trade but to back stab in the Muslim empire of Mughals, I agree you are Tr***s right from the begining. Congratulations.
lol what ignorance!
Go to South India and force anyone to speak Urdu, you will be smacked before you say Urd!
Or South Indian Muslims are not included to your definition of subcontinents Muslims! ;-)
NOt sure about that. I had few south Indian Tamil Muslim friend who frowned at me when they learned that I cant speak Urdu. They used to speak Tamil with Hindus but talked Urdu amongst other muslims.
NOt sure about that. I had few south Indian Tamil Muslim friend who frowned at me when they learned that I cant speak Urdu. They used to speak Tamil with Hindus but talked Urdu amongst other muslims.
Could you please briefly explain this to me please why you think so. Either here or through a pm, thanks bro. I personally have no problem with Urdu, I study Urdu myself whenever I have free time. But I would be against having Urdu as the ONLY national language given the large number of non-Urdu speakers in East Pakistan who are also away from Urdu influence unlike the non-Urdu speakers in West Pakistan.
Tameem said:Secondly, Yes, I admit the native speakers of Urdu are short but the influence and acceptance level which it posses amongst Muslim populous of the whole subcontinent is so huge that it cannot be ignored, thats the reason, our Quaid simply refuse to accept Bengali side by side with Urdu bcz once there is Bengali than why not Punjabi, Pashtu, Sindhi etc., the whole idea of one nation will simply lost in this race.
Saying so, sure we could have a united pakistan as everybody belived that Muslim in sub continent are all same. But after 1947, it was evident that West Pakistanis are the most intolerant society to live with. Bengalis did accept Urdu as a national language as we thought you are comfortable with it and we expected that you will do the same by accepting Bangla as national language as well. But you never taken that in your heart neither you incorporated that in your curriculam except printing currency and on postal stamp.
first of all what does urdu has to do with anything being Muslim?.
You are wrong again. Urdu did not have any influence in Bengali Muslim whatsoever.
You must have no association with Islamic education because otherwise you would know that Urdu was prime language in Qomi Madrasa until around 80's in Bangladesh. You do know that Arabic/Farsi/Urdu still the language of higher Islamic education in Bangladeshi Madrasa. It would not make you less Bengali if you accept that Urdu has better acceptance among Islamic scholars throughout the history from Indus Vally to Bengal.
I am sure it will not make anyone any less Muslim if he/she speaks Bengali with a different script. Islam doesn't discriminate against different race, languages, tribes, caste, etc right? So whats the big deal? Let them speak what ever they want.
Well My name is Zakir because I am a Muslim. I would still be Muslim if I call my self Vijay so long I believe in Allah and Rasul (s.w.s) but name Zakir associate with Islam/Muslim while Vijay with Bharat/Hindu so similarly Arabic based script associate with Islam and Sanskrit with Bharat/Hindu. Are you clear now?
It is the principal that I am arguing about my friend.