AAP sets 1-week delivery plan to fulfil radical promises

[MKI 30]

But pushing the AAP is not really a benefit for the Congress, since they lost even more votes to the AAP out of protest too. If there would have been only Congress and BJP, they might had lost, but not to such a big extend or? And with the big election coming, a small loss in Delhi would be still better wrt PR, that this huge loss they got now don't you think?
Not really sure about this theory.

And that is why there are not many takers of this theory. And i too can't find solid reasons for supporting this thought. Irrespective of the presence of AAP, Congress would have suffered a heavy defeat anyway. The mood among the public was very anti congress and with that rally of Modi Ji in Rohini it just proved to be the icing on the cake. Let me tell you that almost everyone from the middle class background was supporting AAP and to some it came as a surprise that BJP emerged as the single largest party and i find nothing but Modi Ji to be the reason for that. I think wining or losing in Delhi is more symbolic than anything. Being the state housing the PM, a BJP win in Delhi would have surely lead to a Modi environment being formed in each and every corner of the state.

 

[sancho]

And that is why there are not many takers of this theory. And i too can't find solid reasons for supporting this thought. Irrespective of the presence of AAP, Congress would have suffered a heavy defeat anyway. The mood among the public was very anti congress and with that rally of Modi Ji in Rohini it just proved to be the icing on the cake. Let me tell you that almost everyone from the middle class background was supporting AAP and to some it came as a surprise that BJP emerged as the single largest party and i find nothing but Modi Ji to be the reason for that. I think wining or losing in Delhi is more symbolic than anything. Being the state housing the PM, a BJP win in Delhi would have surely lead to a Modi environment being formed in each and every corner of the state.

Of course they would have lost, but loosing a local election with some dignity would still had given them reasonable chances for the coming big elections. This major hit and now 2 possible opponents that will get a huge ammount of votes is clearly working more against them, then just facing the BJP. Just as you said, many middle class people might have voted for the AAP, but if the AAP wouldn't be there, would they had automatically voted for BJP? I don't think so, many of them might had been Congress voters in the past and even if they had been angry about them, would they prefer to vote for the "enemy"?
The AAP offers a chance to many people to show their anger I guess, mainly about Congress and their allies, but in general about the current political establishment, which includes the BJP too. The Modi factor for example is surely a point, but isn't it also interesting that "although" it was clear that the voters will punish the Congress and "although" Modi is a symbol for many, it still wasn't enough for the BJP to get a majority?
That again shows, that the anger about Congress is one thing, but not everybody is fully convinced about the BJP either.

I feel AAP MUST be given a chance to prove themselves at Governance.

Not only must they get a chance, it is more worring that they actually don't want the chance! People seem to want some real changes and this is a chance for the AAP to show that they can do something. But all the promises and ideas that they have, might turn out as a burden for them.

Not sure how familiar you are with German politics, but at the moment it remembers me a lot on the Pirate party in Germany. Mainly protest voters, officials with very low clue about politics and not ready to take responsibility. Things like open democracy and public voting of the members on every issue sounded interesting in the begining, but turned out to be totally unrealistic in everyday politics.

I really hope that the AAP is more than that and could be a solid and reasonable alternative in India and could change something for the better, but that can be done with other parties not only in the ideal scenario of having the majority.

 

[jha]

AAP has probably set a target of 4 months to slash he electricity bill by 50 %... And today COngress spokes person was saying that since you have agreed to do this in 4 months,people will ask questions after 6 months...

AAP fell in a well crafted trap by both parties.

 

[KS]

Unlike the other sympathetic voices here I feel that AAP should not be allowed to flourish in India. Simple for the reason they are the biggest infiltration of the Communists into the educated middle class/urban space in over two decades and their policies reek of anarchy and thoughtlessness. Not only that they dont seem to understand that complete systemic change in a vast and diverse country like India will take atleast a decade - if not more- and seem to be rushing. Look at Kejriwal's slogan for example, its not Bharat Badlenge, its Bharat jaldi bhadlenge. We all know how the most recent "jaldi badlenge" movements turned out in the Arab world, dont we ? I dont want such a situation in India.

Communists have become history in India, for good reasons and their neo-avatars too mustnt be allowed to flourish.

 

[Kaniska]

Aam Admi Party (AAP) is promising the moon in Delhi, as per their party manifesto they will:

- Reduce the electricity bill by 50%

- 700 liters of free water each day to each family

- Legalize each and every 1000 of illegal residential colonies.

- New govt. apartment to the each and every slum dweller.

- 500 new schools

- Permanent Govt. job to over 300,000 temporary teachers, sanitary staff, doctors, nurses, computer operators etc. etc. (Obviously those who will get permanent they will not work like other govt. employees.)

the list is very very long.

- AAP says the Batla house terrorist encounter is fake

- And their founder member Prashant Bhushan says give Kashmir to pakistan -

- Army responsible for killing of Kashmiris

i will be delighted if he makes it out...But couple of things is reallu disturbing...

AAP says the Batla house terrorist encounter is fake

- And their founder member Prashant Bhushan says give Kashmir to pakistan -

- Army responsible for killing of Kashmiris [/quote]

These are the points that makes AAP as another copy of Congress ....If AAP is really want to tap Muslim vote...why do not you talk with muslims in a way that they feel proud of...What is the point in taking such a stand like Batla house encounter..and Kashmir issue...So although i like Arvind...I can survive without less electricity and free water...by i can not compromise on Kashmir issue.

 

[Indischer]

Not only must they get a chance, it is more worring that they actually don't want the chance! People seem to want some real changes and this is a chance for the AAP to show that they can do something. But all the promises and ideas that they have, might turn out as a burden for them.

Not sure how familiar you are with German politics, but at the moment it remembers me a lot on the Pirate party in Germany. Mainly protest voters, officials with very low clue about politics and not ready to take responsibility. Things like open democracy and public voting of the members on every issue sounded interesting in the begining, but turned out to be totally unrealistic in everyday politics.

I really hope that the AAP is more than that and could be a solid and reasonable alternative in India and could change something for the better, but that can be done with other parties not only in the ideal scenario of having the majority.

Wrong choice of wording on my part. It should have read: the AAP must be persuaded to form a Govt in the current scenario.

The PiratenParty doesn't really have many issues of substance to counter the other Political Parties. But in India, there's enormous potential for the AAP to spread and gain a vote bank should they work in earnest and fulfill even half of their promises.

 

[ranjeet]

Is this delivery time has been fixed after asking the JANTA ?

 

[JayAtl]

Complete U-turn of the pre-election stand of AAP and Arvind Kejriwal that they would not seek support from Congress/BJP for forming the government. AAP fought the election to throw out Congress from Delhi and now it is readying to form the government with the support of same Congress. Any way, Best of Luck!!!!

well if it gives them the chance of getting their priorities, then they win...the previous stance basically tells everyone who voted for them that they threw away their votes.

You have to look at it from a logical perspective. It is not like they asked to come short of the seats needed. The hand dealt is the hand dealt

But as far as policies goes, free socialist giveaways is going to ruin your economy.

Apparently, most of the members on PDF knows that I support NaMo for PM & in delhi elections, I voted for BJP. However, you are assuming too much... I appreciate the person/Party whomsoever does good for Delhi or my country.

AAP should not form Govt. at this moment. It is not right time, as it will take at least 1 to 1.5 year to give results for AAP and the Congress after 6-7 months will not only claim that all the promises made by AAP are not workable but also try to expose AAP the promises made by AAP is only to influence delhi voters and to get hold on the State Assembly. Cong will not wait even for 6 months. They will simply submit a letter to LG of no support next day. LG will ask to prove the majority. The main aim of both BJP as well as Cong. is to keep engage AAP into DELHI only. We can wait for next 6 months and can bear the burden of another elections as we are since independence.

would it not be better for delhi citizenry if congress indeed shows that AAP policies are economic disaster? assuming you are of the thinking that AAP is indeed socialist?

 

[Star Wars]

Aravind is heading for a failure of epic proportions...

 

[Soumitra]

It is like Abhimanyu in Mahabharat. He could somehow get inside the chakravyuh but once insie he could not get out.

 

[utraash]

Aam Admi Party (AAP) is promising the moon in Delhi, as per their party manifesto they will:

- Reduce the electricity bill by 50%

- 700 liters of free water each day to each family

- Legalize each and every 1000 of illegal residential colonies.

- New govt. apartment to the each and every slum dweller.

- 500 new schools

- Permanent Govt. job to over 300,000 temporary teachers, sanitary staff, doctors, nurses, computer operators etc. etc. (Obviously those who will get permanent they will not work like other govt. employees.)

the list is very very long.

- AAP says the Batla house terrorist encounter is fake

- And their founder member Prashant Bhushan says give Kashmir to pakistan -

- Army responsible for killing of Kashmiris

Problem of indians happens to be too much critical when sumthing is very promising... Same time if we had been same for congress & BJP situtation of this country wud not hav been so pathetic... People of delhi also understand few of AAPs promises cud not implemented easily but people do understand if he able to make few fundamental change in style of governance the rest of the problem can be settled...... Though I am against any free scheme of any party.........

 

[Victory]

the list is very very long.

- AAP says the Batla house terrorist encounter is fake

- And their founder member Prashant Bhushan says give Kashmir to pakistan -

- Army responsible for killing of Kashmiris

They can't do that.

 

[utraash]

Apparently, most of the members on PDF knows that I support NaMo for PM & in delhi elections, I voted for BJP. However, you are assuming too much... I appreciate the person/Party whomsoever does good for Delhi or my country.

AAP should not form Govt. at this moment. It is not right time, as it will take at least 1 to 1.5 year to give results for AAP and the Congress after 6-7 months will not only claim that all the promises made by AAP are not workable but also try to expose AAP the promises made by AAP is only to influence delhi voters and to get hold on the State Assembly. Cong will not wait even for 6 months. They will simply submit a letter to LG of no support next day. LG will ask to prove the majority. The main aim of both BJP as well as Cong. is to keep engage AAP into DELHI only. We can wait for next 6 months and can bear the burden of another elections as we are since independence.

I am also a BJP supporter but I also know what kind of politics they played being in Opp......... Party with the difference also followed congress foot prints manytimes..... Its the right time for BJP as well to correct thr policies & politics ....... Do you think if Namo becums PM then it wud easier for him to run a coalition gov............?

 

[JayAtl]

Aam Admi Party (AAP) is promising the moon in Delhi, as per their party manifesto they will:

- Reduce the electricity bill by 50%

- 700 liters of free water each day to each family

- Legalize each and every 1000 of illegal residential colonies.

- New govt. apartment to the each and every slum dweller.

- 500 new schools

- Permanent Govt. job to over 300,000 temporary teachers, sanitary staff, doctors, nurses, computer operators etc. etc. (Obviously those who will get permanent they will not work like other govt. employees.)

the list is very very long.

- AAP says the Batla house terrorist encounter is fake

- And their founder member Prashant Bhushan says give Kashmir to pakistan -

- Army responsible for killing of Kashmiris

Holy macro! this is a manifesto for economic disaster! This is like a communist manifesto of socialist programs!

 

[GURU DUTT]

The problem (at least as far as I understood it so far) is, that once the AAP would be dependent on the Congress party, which actually were seen as the bad once with all the scams and corruption. So they would have to team up with a partner that they actually oppose.
On the other side, I think it was easier to make promises during elections, when you don't actually think that you could get into power and need to take responsibility and not that they are, they can't do things as they want, but have to compromise with the congress. That is politics! To take responsibility and rule with allies or partners and find compromises if needed.



What do you mean with constructive opposition?

they wanted to do opposition to ruling party and contineousli poking into them so they dont deviate from there promises in the menifesto and always to be on there toes