A sincere and serious question to Indian right wingers here on PDF

[takeiteasy]

Gandhi and Godse were both men of their time.

Wow! Comparing a Nazi Hindutvavaadi terrorist and a traitor to a great man! Epic!

 

[OnlyTheTruth]

Why getting abusive?

Eat eggs. That's all you guys can manage anyways.

I've seen how excited you guys get when "baida curry" is made at home.

It's like the gastronomic highlight of the month.

Cheers, Doc

P.S. As I said to another newly minted/reincarnated neo sanghi some place else -

Pushed to the wall, every sanghi magically metamorphosizes into a cool dude, non geek, tall fair beef munching hunk.

Sadly for them, some of us actually live in this country and know the ground realities.

You were the one to start the trend.

I see you frantically type 'doc' at the end of every post and mistook you for a fellow doctor.

Thought we could have a scientific and informed discussion on the issue of beef consumption, protein intake and their relation with PEM.

I start by refuting your assertions point by point without any malice, but midway through the discussion realise you are no student of science! Your hatred to all things contrarian is palpably visible, quick to categorise alternate views in a bracket together.

People like you are ruining my country.

 

[zen master]

Is there a point in this post relevant to this thread little man?

The Sangh is larger than the sum total of its official cadre.

It has become a mindset. A cancerous ideology. That is splitting our nation.

Cheers, Doc

You should stop spewing this leftist tripe already.

People like you are ruining my country.

Good thing they're an every shrinking minority.

 

[padamchen]

You should stop spewing this leftist tripe already.

It is the mistake of others to assume I am.a sanghi.

I am.an Indian. First foremost and last.

And will fight anything and anyone who harms my country or countrymen.

Foreign or domestic.

Our Muslims are not aliens BC!

Cheers, Doc

 

[zen master]

Our Muslims are not aliens BC!

The one major point where a lot of people find themselves in agreement with the sangh is that Islam is a foreign ideology. We have a, to put it mildly, unpleasant history with it.

Muslims are fine, friends with many in fact but the religion is problematic, the sunni version anyway, shiites, ahmediya etc not so much.

 

[padamchen]

The one major point where a lot of people find themselves in agreement with the sangh is that Islam is a foreign ideology. We have a, to put it mildly, unpleasant history with it.

Muslims are fine, friends with many in fact but the religion is problematic, the sunni version anyway, shiites, ahmediya etc not so much.

Our Muslims are not aliens.

They belong to this soil and own it.

Live with it.

Cheers, Doc

 

[lastofthepatriots]

The one major point where a lot of people find themselves in agreement with the sangh is that Islam is a foreign ideology. We have a, to put it mildly, unpleasant history with it.

Muslims are fine, friends with many in fact but the religion is problematic, the sunni version anyway, shiites, ahmediya etc not so much.

I agree. Islam should not be tolerated in India.

 

[padamchen]

I agree. Islam should not be tolerated in India.

No aggravation.

I will not be aggravated.

I shall not aggravate.

Try it this time.

It seems to be working for me these past few days since my return.

Cheers, Doc

 

[lastofthepatriots]

No aggravation.

I will not be aggravated.

I shall not aggravate.

Try it this time.

It seems to be working for me these past few days since my return.

Cheers, Doc

There is no aggravation. If Indians feel that Islam is a not a part of Indian identity, they should not tolerate it. They should dump Islamic landmarks, influences of language, cuisine, and history.

Can you imagine how funny it sounds when an Indian soldier dies and Indians call them shaheeds, while at the same time cursing Pakistanis and Islam?

It's the height of hypocrisy and a complete joke. If you want to ban it, ban all of it. Being selective and picking and choosing certain things that you want to instill just makes the narrative laughable.

 

[Stag112]

Wow! Comparing a Nazi Hindutvavaadi terrorist and a traitor to a great man! Epic!

Pointing out a similarity in terms of both of them being irrelevant today (and that pointing out was made mandatory by the way the question was framed by what's probably your own second id) is not the same as comparing.

Your lack of comprehension, reason and your deep deep victimhood complex gives away your religious identity and the sect too.

Next time don't frame questions with Gandhi and Godse in it. Try Gandhi and Vivekanand or Tilak. But then how will you cry victimhood at every response?

 

[takeiteasy]

Hindutva/RSS is destroying the country. But, they're assuming they are achieving Hindu unity by doing this. The imagery of a Islamic/Christian enemy is not enough to unite Hindus under RSS terror rule. Sorry! India is too diverse to assume your Cow dung ideologies to realise. It is a divided country united agreeing on keeping the diversity and respecting it. But, TFI and Shankhnaad reading average Cow dung Sanghi won't get this. After all, they are brainwashed to believe that the Videsi religions are the enemy. Learn to live with this. Muslims and Christians are here to stay. The dream of Yogi Adityanath, Golwalkar, Savarkar will end up in a civil war and destruction of India. Banning RSS is the first step to reclaiming India.

your deep deep victimhood complex

What complex! The first myth to be shattered is I am not a Muslim. Most Sanghi retards ends up in shock after learnign this. Then comes the attack as missionary? Then comes the Communist? It goes on. Read my sig. That's enough for Swayamsevaks to know who I'm. Burn the Chaddi, Enjoy the freedom, Embrace secularism.

 

[padamchen]

There is no aggravation. If Indians feel that Islam is a not a part of Indian identity, they should not tolerate it. They should dump Islamic landmarks, influences of language, cuisine, and history.

Can you imagine how funny it sounds when an Indian soldier dies and Indians call them shaheeds, while at the same time cursing Pakistanis and Islam?

It's the height of hypocrisy and a complete joke. If you want to ban it, ban all of it. Being selective and picking and choosing certain things that you want to instill just makes the narrative laughable.

Bhai aap to serious ho gaye. It was generic strategic headsup to a returning rival in the most banned stakes.

Coming to your point though - we have Indian Muslims fighting in our army.

Hardcore Sunni namazis.

So I give two figs to what neo minted sanghis believe or do not.

Blood is blood. Something the Persians forgot. And the Indians are trying to.

Cheers, Doc

 

[zen master]

Our Muslims are not aliens.

They belong to this soil and own it.

Live with it.

Cheers, Doc

sure, but Indians across the belief spectrum (xtians, buddhists, jains, sikhs, atheists, whathavyou) are still wary of Islam.

That religion is the problem, not everyone who practices it.

I agree. Islam should not be tolerated in India.

If Indians feel that Islam is a not a part of Indian identity, they should not tolerate it. They should dump Islamic landmarks, influences of language, cuisine, and history.

If you want to ban it, ban all of it. Being selective and picking and choosing certain things that you want to instill just makes the narrative laughable.

No desire to ban it. It's here, we have to live with it, and try to peacefully coexist without violence.

I can sit at the grounds of the Taj mahal all day admiring it's magnificence while eating yummy biryani but still discuss Islamic theology and the violence in those texts and about all the problems it has caused around the world, there is no hypocrisy in it.

we have Indian Muslims fighting in our army.

Hardcore Sunni namazis.

logical fallacy spotted, let me crush it into easily digestible bits for you.

pointing out individual cases when the other is talking about a trend, is not an argument.

I don't have the numbers but compared to their percentage in the national population, they make up a very tiny negligible number of the Indian Army. By that same metric, the sikhs are over represented (which is a good thing), and good on the hardcore sunni namazis in the Indian Army. I can say without shame that they are doing more to serve this country than I can perhaps ever hope to, good on them, Jai Hind.

 

[padamchen]

sure, but Indians across the belief spectrum (xtians, buddhists, jains, sikhs, atheists, whathavyou) are still wary of Islam.

That religion is the problem, not everyone who practices it.




No desire to ban it. It's here, we have to live with it, and try to peacefully coexist without violence.

I can sit at the grounds of the Taj mahal all day admiring it's magnificence while eating yummy biryani but still discuss Islamic theology and the violence in those texts and about all the problems it has caused around the world, there is no hypocrisy in it.


logical fallacy spotted, let me crush it into easily digestible bits for you.

pointing out individual cases when the other is talking about a trend, is not an argument.

I don't have the numbers but compared to their percentage in the national population, they make up a very tiny negligible number of the Indian Army. By that same metric, the sikhs are over represented (which is a good thing), and good on the hardcore sunni namazis in the Indian Army. I can say without shame that they are doing more to serve this country than I can perhaps ever hope to, good on them, Jai Hind.

For me this is not a logical academic debate.

Some of those namazis, senior Colonels, are my batchmates.

I know what they feel.when they fight for the same guys who abuse them and their faith.

Don't bother being glib with me. You'll get it straight, both fists, face to face.

I know no other way.

Cheers, Doc

 

[zen master]

Some of those namazis, senior Colonels, are my batchmates.

I know what they feel.when they fight for the same guys who abuse them and their faith.

There you go, doing it again.

what part of this

pointing out individual cases when the other is talking about a trend, is not an argument.

did you fail to understand ?

Don't bother being glib with me. You'll get it straight, both fists, face to face.

I know no other way.

Cheers, Doc

your argument utterly destroyed, your assbrain handed to you on a platter, and you turn to violence, indeed, you have much common cause to make with the jihadis of India.