What's new

A Sikhnee Called Fatima Bibi

Kabir Panthi

BANNED
Joined
Mar 4, 2010
Messages
119
Reaction score
0
A Sikhnee Called Fatima Bibi

by MAJID SHEIKH


Lahore, Pakistan

On Friday, I went to attend the book launching ceremony of Jaswant Singh's book on Jinnah and the Partition of 1947 at a local private golf club. As I had read the book when it was first launched, a question lurked in my mind about what the future held for the ‘sub-continent of hate' that we live in.

As the book launch was consigned to ‘partial chaos' as participants launched, on invitation, into tea and cakes before the ceremony began, it was best to quietly leave and ponder over the suffering the partition of 1947 had brought to the poor of our land.

As the posh of Lahore tucked into sweet delights, outside the heat beat down harsh and fast. My thoughts swayed from my usual Sunday article to focus on the outcome of a remarkable person we are researching with regard to the events of 1947, a ‘holocaust' the sort the world has seldom seen, definitely the largest exodus in human history and one that our elders are still ashamed to discuss openly. For this I condemn my elders, for they have not been truthful about our past.

That is why what Jaswant Singh has to say in his book needs much deeper and honest appreciation by all, especially Indians.

Sadly, both sides have their eyes shut tightly to the reality of partition.

Let me dwell on my research subject, and as she lives on the edge of Lahore, her story needs to be described. We must not make the mistake our elders have made. We must confront the truth, and face it for a better future.

Last month, while on a research visit to a village near Cheechon-ke-Malian, just 18 miles outside Lahore to the west, I set off in search of an old woman a worker in my place of work described as a ‘Sikhnee'. The description had an allure to it, and as we are researching the subject, it made sense to meet this ‘Sikhnee'.

At first her son, the bearded village ‘mullah', refused to let us talk to the old woman. After a considerable persuasion, we managed with the promise not to direct others to their house, and that we would not name him or his mother. To this promise we stick.

We met this old woman, aged approximately 78 - if our calculations are correct - whose sun-tanned skin had freshness to it. The wrinkles on her face depicted her silent suffering. Maybe it was a thought in my mind. She was not bent as old women tend to be, but was a strong, well-set healthy woman used to working hard in the fields and in the house.

Her name now is Fatima Bibi. Her husband was also the village ‘mullah' and she married him in 1947. He died almost six years ago. "Jeth de pehli nu moya si," said Fatima Bibi. 'He died on the first of the month of Jeth."

She served me with a cold drink, and her great grandson also got one in the bargain.

Her story goes like this.

Her real name was Jindan Kaur and her father's name was Heera Singh Bhatti. They belonged to a village outside Sheikhupura just before Jandiala a hundred yards from the main ‘moogha' (water channel) as she put it.

In August 1947, their village was attacked by a Muslim mob. A few Sikh elders - aniticipating the usual brutalizing of women by the mobs - killed their daughters before the mob could reach the young girls. Ultimately, they were saved by the army who came in two trucks full of soldiers. The entire village of Sikhs was taken to the Sheikhupura railway station and they were put into a railway bogey stuffed like animals and bound for Lahore, from where they were to go onwards to Amritsar in the new India, their new home.

Jindan then described the blood-curdling event of how their train was attacked near Cheechon-ke-Malian railway station. Every male member, as well as children and old women, were hacked to pieces.

"Tottay kar ditay sadday!"- We were hacked into little pieces!

The young Jindan was taken away by the local toughs and they did what frenzied men do. "Javani lut lai-ee. Kakh na chaddaaya. Rool ditta. Jeenday jee maryaa ve nahi." - They looted our youth. Didn't even leave its ashes. Ruined us. Left us neither living nor dead!

There were no tears in her eyes, for mine had welted on listening to her description of events. She looked at me and said: "Baoo, athroo da koi faida nai jaddon mera bapoo tottay ho gay"- Sir, what's the point of tears when even my father was hacked into pieces!

The fate of her dear father had sealed time for her. She was the 15-year old Jindan when she talked lovingly of him. Her son was getting uneasy as she started to open up. I changed the topic to calm him. The ruse work well. After a while I started off again to listen to what happened to Jindan Kaur alias Fatima Bibi.

The train had about 105 women, most of them young. Jindan was then a mere 15-year old.

She was raped by a number of men, she does not recall the number. The young village mullah took her to his house after the ‘animals' had satiated their lust. He nursed her to health. He then advised that she convert to Islam and he would marry her.

It was a noble deed by any reckoning. He took her glazed eyes and her silence as acceptance for his offer. A year later, soldiers came to the village and offered all kidnapped Hindu and Sikh women to get on an army lorry to be taken to India. They, however, warned, that Sikhs were killing all their own women who had been dishonoured. [A ruse to terrify such women further - tens of thousands of them - so that they would not avail of the bi-national exchange scheme and opt for staying in Pakistan!]

Life continued to offer no choices.

Jindan was pregnant. She had no family to go to. Life did not offer a choice. For her life began and ended that fateful day. The rest has been mere existence and she waits for the day when she will be released from her mortal remains. The old Punjabi woman described her fate as only she could:

"Baoo, mera akhri saah barra mitha hoyay ga." - Sir, my last breath will be a very sweet one!

Her son scolded her for the remark.

The victims of 1947 abound in the villages of Punjab.

In 2010, they are forgotten.

The description ‘Sikhnee' is a slur that she bears without malice. Her four sons and five daughters do not like the way people call her. Hate has an unforgiving element. Inconspicuous references hide a story, often one of pain and suffering.

If only she could again call herself Jindan Kaur with pride and without feeling guilty. That day will surely come, of this I have no doubt.

There are thousands like her in Pakistan and India. They are the forgotten people our elders shut their eyes to. That is why preserving the truth of 1947 is critical if we are to claw our way back to normalcy.

That is why what Jaswant Singh has to say matters too.

That is why I left the ‘tea and cakes' mob to think about Jindan Kaur.

Life still does not offer her any choice.



[Courtesy: The Dawn]

April 27, 2010

sikhchic.com | The Art and Culture of the Diaspora | A Sikhnee Called Fatima Bibi
 
.
By reading this article i recall another article by a Pakistani author who found a muslim women loudly crying and questionng the dead why they left her.......and sikh calling her their mother and forcing her to come home....upon investigation it was revealed tht the old women was kidnapped by some bastard and married her forcefully and the sikh men were her children..........Sad bastards were there on both sides who did wat even shames animals.
 
. .
By reading this article i recall another article by a Pakistani author who found a muslim women loudly crying and questionng the dead why they left her.......and sikh calling her their mother and forcing her to come home....upon investigation it was revealed tht the old women was kidnapped by some bastard and married her forcefully and the sikh men were her children..........Sad bastards were there on both sides who did wat even shames animals.

and they movies like "partition" lol
 
.
A touching tale.

A harsh reality of the times , created by those unmindful of effect of the lines they drew sitting in Delhi in '47 with no regard to those whose lives it would impact.

Reinforces the fact that the partition was a good thing done in the most ham handed manner possible - which is at the root of the grief we find ourselves .
 
. .
In all instances of the story, I think Pakistan Army did a good job by first saving them and sending them off on the train, then offering them to be repatriated to Amritsar. The mob's were bastards in this story, but I don't know why without any evidence the Pak Army's good gestures and warnings are being called a ruse. Seems like yellow journalism - zilch evidence provided for these things as they seem like the Author's own interpretation of events.

Its sad what happened to her, but the PA should be thanked at least for saving her once from the Sikhs and then offering to repatriate her. I mean this was an extremely horrible time and in that context the gestures from Pak Army were incredible.
 
.
In all instances of the story, I think Pakistan Army did a good job by first saving them and sending them off on the train, then offering them to be repatriated to Amritsar. The mob's were bastards in this story, but I don't know why without any evidence the Pak Army's good gestures and warnings are being called a ruse. Seems like yellow journalism - zilch evidence provided for these things as they seem like the Author's own interpretation of events.

Its sad what happened to her, but the PA should be thanked at least for saving her once from the Sikhs and then offering to repatriate her. I mean this was an extremely horrible time and in that context the gestures from Pak Army were incredible.

Maybe it wasn't a ruse. Honour, especially of women in Punjab was a valued and esteemed thing in those days. I have heard/read of countless incidents of Sikhs killing their own women family members to 'save' them from marauding hordes. I am sure that would have been the case for Muslim families as well.
 
.
Aasim, there are recorded instances of Sikh massacres in Lahore, Rawalpindi and the surrounding areas. I've read books about them. Master Tara Singh is on record asking for revenge but later he retracted his statements.

Khalid Hasan wrote about the murders in Mirpur some while ago.

This paper has a whole chapter dedicated to massacres from both sides. As usual, objectivity is the key and this paper keeps it in mind.

Global security summarizes it as follows:-
The migrations and the violence were regionally confined. They were not all-India phenomena. Partition brought, by one estimate, five million refugees from east Punjab to west Punjab after the British decided to leave their Indian empire in the hands of the successor states of India and Pakistan. While 5 million people left India for Pakistan, about the same number of people moved in the other direction. By another estimate, 4 million Hindus and Sikhs moved from West to East Punjab and 5 to 6 million Muslims moved from East to West Punjab. In the late 1940s, more than one-quarter of Punjab’s population of about 19 million was made up of refugees. Sikhs, caught in the middle of Punjab's new "line," suffered the highest percentage of casualties. Most Sikhs finally settled in India's much-diminished border state of Punjab. Some though the Punjab disturbances were the direct result of Mountbatten's unwisdom in accelerating the date of partition, and that if Punjab had been given time, the terrible massacre of August, September and October could have been avoided.

The death toll of this terrible episode remains very much contested. Hundreds of thousands of people died, as Hindus and Sikhs fled to India, Muslims to Pakistan, and many others were caught up in a chaotic transition. A consensus figure of 500,000 is often used, but the sources closer to the truth give figures that range between 200,000 and 360,000 dead. By other estimates, Partition resulted in as many as 1.5 million deaths. The word genocide did not come to the minds of observers at the time, though there were genocidal aspects to what finally developed.

This isn't some Indian propaganda to create an Akhand Bharat. Atrocities were committed on both sides. If the state wants you to forget them, it does not mean you should forget them. Cleansing your elders of their crimes isn't a noble thing to do.
 
.
This article reminds me of the movie pinjar which has a pre and post partition setting, an excellent and a must watch movie. Theme revolves around how barbaric people could get and then there is this human side of a muslim chap played by manoj bajpai who repents the misdeed committed by him where he forcefully kidnaps a hindu girl played by urmila and how in the end the same hindu girl forced to convert to islam willingly wont leave Pakistan and her husband, the man who forced her to marry her, even when her family which had migrated to India was ready to accept her, along with the guy she was supposed to marry initially.

Another movie which has a fantastic story to tell and has a setting of the partition is deepa Mehta directed and arim khan starred earth.

Those of you who can lay your hands on these two movies, do check them out.

I am sure there are many more such tales on both sides of the border, people who would have gone through that phase of their lives would have been witnessed to hell on earth.
 
Last edited:
.
Aasim, there are recorded instances of Sikh massacres in Lahore, Rawalpindi and the surrounding areas. I've read books about them. Master Tara Singh is on record asking for revenge but later he retracted his statements.

Khalid Hasan wrote about the murders in Mirpur some while ago.

This paper has a whole chapter dedicated to massacres from both sides. As usual, objectivity is the key and this paper keeps it in mind.

Global security summarizes it as follows:-


This isn't some Indian propaganda to create an Akhand Bharat. Atrocities were committed on both sides. If the state wants you to forget them, it does not mean you should forget them. Cleansing your elders of their crimes isn't a noble thing to do.
No denials there, I'm just talking about the apparent tinge of "take a punch at Pakistan Army every chance you get" exhibited in the article. Focus upon the massacre and the plight of the women. We the people, were a part of the massacre, don't lessen our guilt by pinning some on the army of a brand new country facing a very tough job.
 
.
I agree that PA should have appreciated in the article but as we all know that DAWN news has an army bashing agenda so they will never write any thing appreciating PA.........

but anyways coming to the topic.... this is very sad story and this not the only one...... I don't how people living with each other for years can do this to themselves. :frown:
In punjab woman has a great honour and respect at least I have seen this...... anything bad related bad to a woman is not tolerated here..... I think PA was rightly saying that returned women from Paksitan were killed by sikhs in the name of honour, and there is a clear possibility that it might have happened in Pakistan also.... :frown::frown:
 
.
we are lucky that we are born after the partition. We should Respect each others freedom now.. both have sacrificed alot for this.
wat more can i say... i am having goosebumps even if i think of that time... :frown:
 
.
DAWN news has an army bashing agenda so they will never write any thing appreciating PA.........
Actually, Dawn is the most pro-establishment newspaper and the establishment is almost entirely the military. Any news that does not agree with your point of view or what you believe in does not make the other a basher or a hater.
 
.
Actually, Dawn is the most pro-establishment newspaper and the establishment is almost entirely the military. Any news that does not agree with your point of view or what you believe in does not make the other a basher or a hater.

Yeah?i always thought it was a 100% neutral paper whose founder was Quaid-e-Azam Muhammad Ali Jinnah?
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom