A post Islamic Iran will be more dangerous to Pakistan.

[Old School]

But I still don’t understand how anyone can be certain a ‘new’ Iran would be pro Western? What would Saudi think of that?

Because, western powers are the sponsors of this regime change adventure. They somehow managed to get green lights from the pro West faction to kill Gen Solaimani who was even more popular than the supreme leader among the hardliners. Do not count on Russia China and Saudis as long Trump is in power.

Any regime change will cause serious civil war in Iran most probably which might tear it.

A civil war errupting in Iran will shoot the oil price to the ceiling and the non Gulf oil exporters will reap the benefits, such as Russia. Not to mention, USA is also a new emerging oil exporter. Millions of refugees can pour into our borders.

 

[Taimoor Khan]

There is a western backed regime change process rapidly unfolding in Iran in the forms of targeted assassinations and color revolution. Our ties with Iran have been far from being on the same page since birth in 1947. Iran's foreign policies involving Afghanistan and India have not been in line with ours as these two neighbors in the east and west are the most strategically crucial factor for the very survival of the state of Pakistan.
The big question is if the Islamic regime falls in Iran and it is replaced by a pro West secular regime, how it is going to impact our strategic interests. Are we going to see an Iranian Modi in our western frontier?

Indians will descend like locust swarm on Iranian soil under the patronage of cia/mossad. Exactly the same Afghanistan template. Only hundred times worse, as our border with Iran is least protected and we have nobody to fight our wars inside Iran.

 

[JonAsad]

Why Pakistan is so afraid of iran it is ridiculously stupid..

 

[Sineva]

Also, remember that a nationalistic Iranian regime will be very close to the Americans, West and the Israelis.

And by definition also hindu fascist run india,which in addition to massively increasing its energy purchases will also be going full steam ahead on chabahar as there would be no remaining economic barriers to its development.

 

[B.K.N]

Because, western powers are the sponsors of this regime change adventure.

If they want a regime change in Iran then you or other PDF members can't stop them. And Pakistanis don't care who rules Iran. Iran and Pakistan are irrelevant for each other.

 

[Old School]

If they want a regime change in Iran then you or other PDF members can't stop them. And Pakistanis don't care who rules both Iran and Pakistan are irrelevant for each other.

Then you are not a Pakistani. What are you doing in PDF ?

 

[-blitzkrieg-]

Are we going to see an Iranian Modi in our western frontier?

No we will have a bigger version Ashraf Ghani to take care of..It will be a nightmare.

 

[B.K.N]

Then you are not a Pakistani. What are you doing in PDF ?

I am Pakistani and you? And at PDF i am reading the comments of PDF members

 

[Old School]

I am Pakistani and you? And at PDF i am reading the comments of PDF members

You are not a Pakistani.

 

[Yankee-stani]

This is what I have been warning many of Defense.PK chest thumper's for a while a regime change in Iran will not only be bad for the region but we dont know who will be in charge of Iran but it seems that under the Trump Admin. we are seeing the MEK a cult group led by the Rajavi family may mount a takeover bid in the ensuing chaos they are going give US bases easily maybe right even on our borders also we will be dealing with increased imperialist regime that could look at annexing our Balochistan, also this will be a boon to the American Empire as it will make it status from life support to full recovery forget about the Indian presence in Chabahar but major US Naval ships right up near Gwader, China and Russia will blocked out and will get weaken without major Eurasian pole right up their spheres Pakistan will be much weaker as well Iran can be annoying but I rather have cordial ties with Tehran than have B-52 bombers right up our nose and another Afghanistan anyways I dont see the regime going anywhere tho the protests will likely lose steam like in 2017 and 2009 so no big deal there is big difference between the Tehran liberals and the provincial Iranian who is likely to be pro regime

If they want a regime change in Iran then you or other PDF members can't stop them. And Pakistanis don't care who rules Iran. Iran and Pakistan are irrelevant for each other.

They ones that want regime change are fifth columns and idiot youths who dont understand what tf they are doing they can curse their parents for 1979 but the situation of the world is much more hotter now than ever before anyways the Tehran liberals will be swamped by the provincial Iranian anyday

No we will have a bigger version Ashraf Ghani to take care of..It will be a nightmare.

And the chest thumpers here think another Shah will take place

 

[Philosopher]

This is what I have been warning many of Defense.PK chest thumper's for a while a regime change in Iran will not only be bad for the region but we dont know who will be in charge of Iran but it seems that under the Trump Admin. we are seeing the MEK a cult group led by the Rajavi family may mount a takeover bid in the ensuing chaos they are going give US bases easily maybe right even on our borders also we will be dealing with increased imperialist regime that could look at annexing our Balochistan, also this will be a boon to the American Empire as it will make it status from life support to full recovery forget about the Indian presence in Chabahar but major US Naval ships right up near Gwader, China and Russia will blocked out and will get weaken without major Eurasian pole right up their spheres Pakistan will be much weaker as well Iran can be annoying but I rather have cordial ties with Tehran than have B-52 bombers right up our nose and another Afghanistan anyways I dont see the regime going anywhere tho the protests will likely lose steam like in 2017 and 2009 so no big deal there is big difference between the Tehran liberals and the provincial Iranian who is likely to be pro regime



They ones that want regime change are fifth columns and idiot youths who dont understand what tf they are doing they can curse their parents for 1979 but the situation of the world is much more hotter now than ever before anyways the Tehran liberals will be swamped by the provincial Iranian anyday



And the chest thumpers here think another Shah will take place

Few points, MEK could never set foot in Iran. The Iranian people would tear them apart. Those subhuman fought with saddam against Iran.

Also, Iranians are too nationalistic. They will not allow US bases on their soil. I just can't see that happening.

 

[B.K.N]

This is what I have been warning many of Defense.PK chest thumper's for a while a regime change in Iran will not only be bad for the region but we dont know who will

But what can PDF chest thumpers do to stop regime change in Iran. Can PDF chest thumpers stop America from attacking Iran if it wants to attack or can they stop Iranians from firing missiles at Americans?
Why you want anti Iran posters to write pro Iran comments let them say whatever they want.

 

[Yankee-stani]

Why Pakistan is so afraid of iran it is ridiculously stupid..

No one is afraid of Iran respect of culture and history yes but the fear of a unstable frontier should open the minds of Pakistanis the problem with PDF is its the view of folks living abroad far away from the action I can only speculate others in Pakistan probably live in the big cities far from frontier so that does not help easy to be a keyboard warrior than to think in strategic terms

 

[Philosopher]

And by definition also hindu fascist run india,which in addition to massively increasing its energy purchases will also be going full steam ahead on chabahar as there would be no remaining economic barriers to its development.

Good point. I agree.

 

[El Sidd]

Why Pakistan is so afraid of iran it is ridiculously stupid..

I blame too much drama watching