A Parting Gift to all North Indians and Western Indians

[Stephen Cohen]

He made most Indian members look like rabid dogs trying to defend a pile of trash.

He was an Out and out ; a totally political person wearing His Ideology on his sleeve

His ideas ie Maximum Autonomy to Kashmir
were clearly Anti National which is NOT acceptable to the Majority of Indians

Even the so called secular Congress did not dare to go down that road
when they were in Power

If his Bosses in India -- that is CPM politicians can be rebuked strongly
for parroting the same arguements

He was just another CPM member ; Our BATTLES with him were Purely political in Nature
Nothing Personal

But HE made them Personal by his abuses and insults

In India ; the LEFT is often ACCUSED to exercising Authority without Responsibility
which they did between 2004 and 2009 ; when they supported the Congress government
at the Centre

PS : In India it is the Left parties who are steadily going down the Garbage Chute

 

[Hellfire]

You are still FAR better than Him ; I wont mind your pin pricks

I don't even prick you. Indulgence is more of an apt term.

By the Way now that He has left ; Are you planning to take up his ROLE or job

What ROLE or what job? Not clear.

PS : your knowledge about Geopolitics is outdated

Then you better start praying hard .... that is all I shall say.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Sorry for wrong terminology

Chill. It happens. But we should not let the Left decide that we are 'Right'.

 

[DesiGuy]

All,

He has left...move on. Have a beer or 2 if you were so close to him. You will come across more Joes in future.

 

[SarthakGanguly]

Because he called a spade a spade and NOT a SINGLE Indian member was able to debate with him without having to resort to dodgy tangential arguments, repetitive parroting or personal attacks.

Because he silenced debates with abuses or negative ratings. While he rated and reported us, you graciously banned us. There was no scope for debate. Neither he nor you give much space for debate. And that is understandable.
I don't hold that against him much. I am used to it and don't take it personally.

Was Joe a communist?

No. Not at all. Communists are unpredictable.

But I am sure he will come back.

 

[T90TankGuy]

Whats up Joe Sir.. Dont tell me you are also leaving like Sir Gary..

@hellfire @jbgt90 - Whats up with this..

No clue , spoke to him today , all seemed fine.

 

[nair]

No clue , spoke to him today , all seemed fine.

May be he wanted to confuse few heads here......... But amusing to see the kind of hatred towards him....... Shocking by the way....

 

[PARIKRAMA]

No clue , spoke to him today , all seemed fine.

I was of the opinion if he is Hyderabad than its raining heavy so he might have taken a day or two's break.. seems its gonna be heavy downpour in next 24-48 hours there..

 

[T90TankGuy]

I was of the opinion if he is Hyderabad than its raining heavy so he might have taken a day or two's break.. seems its gonna be heavy downpour in next 24-48 hours there..

I am out of station , was not able to talk to him till this morning , will probably catch up with him tomorrow.

May be he wanted to confuse few heads here......... But amusing to see the kind of hatred towards him....... Shocking by the way....

Well those who hate are not able to look past his words(which some time are harsh) , if they did, they might see a different point of view. Not to say they are wrong and he is right or vice versa , its just that they have not reached the point in their lives where they realise you can "agree to disagree".

 

[Hellfire]

I was of the opinion if he is Hyderabad than its raining heavy so he might have taken a day or two's break.. seems its gonna be heavy downpour in next 24-48 hours there..

Weather just opened! Are you in vicinity?

 

[T90TankGuy]

Weather just opened! Are you in vicinity?

You too are stationed in HYD?

 

[Hellfire]

You too are stationed in HYD?

Yes. Joe Shearer and I had an interaction on this and you acknowledged it with ... A coffee or a malt

 

[VCheng]

Yes. Joe Shearer and I had an interaction on this and you acknowledged it with ... A coffee or a malt

Take Joe out for a cold one, and tell him I said this to be conveyed to him:

"There will be great bittersweet satisfaction when all those who pile it high and deep on PDF get their faces rubbed in it by reality."

 

[nair]

Yes. Joe Shearer and I had an interaction on this and you acknowledged it with ... A coffee or a malt

I remember posters from Hyd used to meet regularly.... I remember few threads on this.....

 

[Hellfire]

Take Joe out for a cold one, and tell him I said this to be conveyed to him:

"There will be great bittersweet satisfaction when all those who pile it high and deep on PDF get their faces rubbed in it by reality."

Wilco!
Planned in October as soon as I get sometime off.

I remember posters from Hyd used to meet regularly.... I remember few threads on this.....

Give a heads up if you are in vicinity ....