A Day in Cadet College in Wana - South Waziristan

[Imran Khan]

those whom can't use youtube


[video]https://www.facebook.com/video/embed?video_id=338284019639844[/video]

 

[Leader]

great, I was about to share it...

 

[Kompromat]

Most of the students in shinkai cadet college are not from local mehsud tribe, they are from neighboring settled districts.

Is that a good or a bad thing?

 

[TaimiKhan]

Most of the students in shinkai cadet college are not from local mehsud tribe, they are from neighboring settled districts.

Making a cadet college in an area doesn't means it has to be fully filled by the local people. Does MCJ / Cdt Clg Hasanabadal / Cdt Clg Kohat etc etc means they will all be having locals, NO. Main purpose of the cadet college in such far flung undeveloped areas is to bring in the concept of education and good education, bring awareness among the people and once that starts, people from local areas after seeing such development bring more of their children in such schools. Cadet College Razmak has students from all over KPK and even some students from other provinces have enrolled too.

So kindly as per usual tricks, dont try to make an issue out of something which has no issue.

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Making a cadet college in an area doesn't means it has to be fully filled by the local people. Does MCJ / Cdt Clg Hasanabadal / Cdt Clg Kohat etc etc means they will all be having locals, NO. Main purpose of the cadet college in such far flung undeveloped areas is to bring in the concept of education and good education, bring awareness among the people and once that starts, people from local areas after seeing such development bring more of their children in such schools. Cadet College Razmak has students from all over KPK and even some students from other provinces have enrolled too.

So kindly as per usual tricks, dont try to make an issue out of something which has no issue.

Absurd logic. The admission test for cadet college is difficult, they wont be able to take admission on the basis of merit and its fee is too much for local tribals which means they wont benefit from this cadet college. Instead of spending too much money on cadet college why not build normal schools and colleges exclusively for mehsuds with quality teaching staff? . Instead of this why not issue scholarships for those mehsuds interested in seeking education. One must remember that FATA has lowest literacy rate in Pakistan, 22%, they need exclusive attention.
Cadet college razmak was in north waziristan, like you said most of its students were from KPK......but unlike your claim it didnt accelerate literacy rate among tribesmen of razmak region, they were Oblivious to its existence.

 

[TaimiKhan]

Absurd logic. The admission test for cadet college is difficult, they wont be able to take admission on the basis of merit and its fee is too much for local tribals which means they wont benefit from this cadet college. Instead of spending too much money on cadet college why not build normal schools and colleges exclusively for mehsuds with quality teaching staff? . Instead of this why not issue scholarships for those mehsuds interested in seeking education. One must remember that FATA has lowest literacy rate in Pakistan, 22%, they need exclusive attention.
Cadet college razmak was in north waziristan, like you said most of its students were from KPK......but unlike your claim it didnt accelerate literacy rate among tribesmen of razmak region, they were Oblivious to its existence.

P.S: have some respect for freedom of speech and forum rules and stop deleting my every post.
@Aeronaut, @Leader

Cadet Colleges are an initiative from the army, and one cadet college can not increase the literacy rate nor it can provide which you just asked. Army uses cadet colleges to bring good image and prepare officer level cadets for future induction into PMA. So even inf there are 20 mehsud tribe related students and among them even 5 get selected for armed forces, it will bring good and visible change on the ground. And just multiple it with the each year which passes, after a few years time frame good number of mehsud tribal men can be officers. And they can bring in good change to their home towns / villages.

For what you asked, that is what the govt should do, increase number of schools, provide special scholarships through HEC and other organizations so that more and more students can come out and study and become a part of the society.

Army is doing what it can do on its level.

 

[Armstrong]

For what you asked, that is what the govt should do, increase number of schools, provide special scholarships through HEC and other organizations so that more and more students can come out and study and become a part of the society.

Army is doing what it can do on its level.

Waisee Taimi Bhai why isn't the Civil Society of those areas inclined towards these things ?

I know an Auntie here in my neighborhood who started a school in her garage & she'd ask all the poor children from the neighborhood to come & study there. As incentive she used to give them books, stationary & lunch.

As the school grew she started asking for 'recyclable trash' from the Neighbors which she'd then sell to the Kabariyaaa & others for some money that would fund the school.

In a few years time that initiative of hers grew out of her garage to now 3 Schools where a few hundred poor children are taught, given uniforms, stationary, books & the afternoon meal - Without charging a penny to them !

Why didn't the Maliks or the Sardars or some of the more Influential people from FATA thought of something similar ? Maybe building a small Poly-Technic College over there or a High School for the children ?

Or is FATA a bit Feudal like parts of Punjab, Interior Sindh & Baluchistan too ?

' @Pak-one @chauvunist

 

[Imran Khan]

Maliks or the Sardars or some of the more Influential people from FATA thought of something similar ? Maybe building a small Poly-Technic College over there or a High School for the children ?

Or is FATA a bit Feudal like parts of Punjab, Interior Sindh & Baluchistan too ?

Source: http://www.defence.pk/forums/milita...lege-wana-south-waziristan.html#ixzz2bVYd6uPW

lollz what a cllasic qes man . if these poor get education then who on earth will stay malik sradar vadeera khan ? man they all are anti education and they want us uneducated robots which worship them .

 

[Armstrong]

lollz what a cllasic qes man . if these poor get education then who on earth will stay malik sradar vadeera khan ? man they all are anti education and they want us uneducated robots which worship them .

Yaaar lakin koi tou achaaa loggon ka khair khwaa bhi tou ho gaa unn mein seii ?

 

[Imran Khan]

Yaaar lakin koi tou achaaa loggon ka khair khwaa bhi tou ho gaa unn mein seii ?

koi apna apni aal ulaad ka dushman hai yahaan ? or syed die his son take one saeen die his son take one khan die his sone take power just look peer pagara he died his son take his seat . how on earth they cut down money power seats in NA PA for their kids? is kahndaani chaker se niklny ka aik hi rasta hai knowledge education .

 

[Marwat Khan Lodhi]

Waisee Taimi Bhai why isn't the Civil Society of those areas inclined towards these things ?

I know an Auntie here in my neighborhood who started a school in her garage & she'd ask all the poor children from the neighborhood to come & study there. As incentive she used to give them books, stationary & lunch.

As the school grew she started asking for 'recyclable trash' from the Neighbors which she'd then sell to the Kabariyaaa & others for some money that would fund the school.

In a few years time that initiative of hers grew out of her garage to now 3 Schools where a few hundred poor children are taught, given uniforms, stationary, books & the afternoon meal - Without charging a penny to them !

Why didn't the Maliks or the Sardars or some of the more Influential people from FATA thought of something similar ? Maybe building a small Poly-Technic College over there or a High School for the children ?

Or is FATA a bit Feudal like parts of Punjab, Interior Sindh & Baluchistan too ?

' @Pak-one @chauvunist

Malaks of FATA are not wealthy people like feudals of sindh and punjab neither they have control over affairs of each household........and they themselves are mostly uneducated or least educated. Actually Mullah can play more important role than malak. Both mullah party and malak party are not against education but it is also not included in their priorities...................
Your idea is good one but the problem is no one would be ready to even visit waziristan because of its reputation......

Tribal people seek education in institutions of KPK, after becoming sucesful men career wise, they permanently settle in KPK or any other part of pakistan rather than going back to their FATA.....so their is brain drain in FATA.....due to continuous war for last 10 years, the place is not suitable for living as any kind of existing infrastructure is destroyed while prior to that not even basic facilities like education, health, roads, industry etc were absent.

 

[Javed Mgi]

Hey and salam to all of you my dears, am new here and studying in 10th standard, my 9th marks is 421 out of 550. My family condition is poor and am want to continue my studies but it is unlikely, am also want to join a cadet college and then join PAF, Pak army or pak navy As an officer, so am here to know about the cadet colleges in pakistan. Anyone one here who can guide me about this?

For information: am from khyber agency, FATA, peshawar pakistan.

 

[Javed Mgi]

Hey and salam to all of you my dears, am new here and studying in 10th standard, my 9th marks is 421 out of 550. My family condition is poor and am want to continue my studies but it is unlikely, am also want to join a cadet college and later join PAF, Pak army or pak navy As an officer, so am here to know about the cadet colleges in pakistan under government. Anyone one here who can guide me about this?

For information: am from khyber agency, FATA, peshawar pakistan.