A Christian Province in Pakistan?

[Gin ka Pakistan]

^^^^ Give freedom of changing religion to low cast Hindus in India so they all can convert to Christianity and Indian be a Christian country.

 

[TruthSeeker]

Basically have an area where Christians can govern themselves according to their own laws, and are granted protection et cetera.

It is healthier for the Pakistani Nation to give this protection to all Pakistanis, all over Pakistan and mean it. Any "laws" that are contradictory between or among the tenets of multiple faiths should not be State laws but left up to the consciences of the adherents to obey without State enforcement. Any religious group can "excommunicate" or shun or withhold blessings from members who transgress their principles. Leave it to each faith to enforce any unique rules of behavior. Then, Pakistan could be a nation where children of all faiths could grow up and feel they are true citizens.

 

[SSGPA1]

you mean to say for little percentage of people

No for the occupied peopele of a disputed territory. Occupied Kashmir's population is not part of the Indian population.

 

[SSGPA1]

So the two nation theory, which has succeeded in splitting that 30% into three nations does not apply to pakistani christians only because their numbers are small? Whats the minimum percentage required by this grand theory? at what percentage can direct action be taken?

Get over the partition of India and stop harping on Kashmir issue, what say practice what u preach. in both the matters really!!!

A percentage which could bring a change in the Parliament. India will not allow Sikhs Khalistan who are a far bigger share of population in India.

Kashmir issue is a disputed territory and unfinished business of partition which needs to be addressed ASAP.

If the 2% population is granted a change in Pakistan then by the same formula, India will be divided into many smaller countries.

 

[Goodperson]

A percentage which could bring a change in the Parliament. India will not allow Sikhs Khalistan who are a far bigger share of population in India.

Kashmir issue is a disputed territory and unfinished business of partition which needs to be addressed ASAP.

If the 2% population is granted a change in Pakistan then by the same formula, India will be divided into many smaller countries.

Lets stick to thread topic.

 

[notsuperstitious]

A percentage which could bring a change in the Parliament. India will not allow Sikhs Khalistan who are a far bigger share of population in India.

Kashmir issue is a disputed territory and unfinished business of partition which needs to be addressed ASAP.

If the 2% population is granted a change in Pakistan then by the same formula, India will be divided into many smaller countries.

India is not based on 3 nation theory, you are.

 

[Kompromat]

How should even Christians think about it when rest of the " Christendom" has banned Our Minartes , Banned Beard , Banned Burqa if a Muslim lady is following her religion she would be fined 750 Euros.

They appreciate those who make fun of our Beloved Prophet PBUH and dump it under the mask of " Freedom of speech" .

Tough Christians are in a highly low number in Pakistan and since Pakistan is an Islamic republic they would live with us in harmony and peace not as a separate entity.

No more division of Pakistan..!!

 

[RobbieS]

Forming states based on religious affiliation is a bad idea. Taking India as an example, there are multitudes of religions followed over the country but none of the states have been formed on the basis of that. Linguistically and ethnically yes, but religion wise, bad idea!

 

[Kompromat]

^^ Not really , Pakistan was formed on the basis of Religion but you must have responsible numbers.

 

[RobbieS]

^^ Not really , Pakistan was formed on the basis of Religion but you must have responsible numbers.

This kind of relates to the "mixing religion with politics" concept. A strict no no.

No offense meant and I don't want to blame any country or people, but Pakistan and Israel are the only two countries formed on the basis of religion and these very regions are today hotbeds of trouble. South Asia and Middle East. Is this a coincidence?

 

[Kompromat]

This kind of relates to the "mixing religion with politics" concept. A strict no no.

No offense meant and I don't want to blame any country or people, but Pakistan and Israel are the only two countries formed on the basis of religion and these very regions are today hotbeds of trouble. South Asia and Middle East. Is this a coincidence?

Lets not flame this thread!

 

[jarnee]

Christians are just 1.6% of Pakistan's overall population , what sense does this make to make pieces of Pakistan for 2.8 million people?

Can someone explain to me.

It is not time to divide Pakistan but this is a right time to divide those who want to divide us on those foolish basis of Language , ethnicity , race , religion.

Pakistan will stand as one and no province must be divided .

I am sorry but you got yourself stumped here!. Idea of Pakistan and creation of Pakistan was itself based on division in name of religion so what advice are they going to take from you.
However if Pakistan changes as you mentioned above then there is no difference between her and India.
Some one rightly said above, Pakistan is an Islamic state.

 

[Kompromat]

I am sorry but you got yourself stumped here!. Idea of Pakistan and creation of Pakistan was itself based on division in name of religion so what advice are they going to take from you.
However if Pakistan changes as you mentioned above then there is no difference between her and India.
Some one rightly said above, Pakistan is an Islamic state.

If religion can divide then India would be divided at least into 30 pieces .

And do not " Lecture " me. Freedom of religion is a scar on your " so called democracy ".

 

[RobbieS]

Lets not flame this thread!

Agreed. For the sake of a productive discussion we'd rather not head in this direction!

 

[SSGPA1]

India is not based on 3 nation theory, you are.

India was partitioned on 2 nation theory and all of your leaders accepted that.