BlackenTheSky
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Oct 26, 2009
- Messages
- 1,809
- Reaction score
- 0
- Country
- Location
By the way i finished reciting quran first time when i was only 7.
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
In my humble opinion, this is 'zulm'. He is just a eight year old kid, making him memorizing the entire Quran in 4 months is only possible if he was allowed not to do anything else but to learn the verses by heart. I dont think that is something very humane.
Allah knows better.
Would you have said that if he was sent to school every day forcefully?
Nope, they they are supposed to teach children science that is based on proven facts & history from a neutral standpoint. They are taught languages to communicate and mathematics to solve problems facing humanity.
It does not compare to something u are forced to adopt just bcoz u were born in a certain family
OK, there is no need to get emotional. I say the same for the kids who engage in activities such as spell bee etc. Once I was watching an interview of a kid who had won the first prize; was an Indian and his parents were telling proudly that he memorizes the Dictionary eight hours a day… Those eight hours were in addition to the time he used to spent in doing his School homework etc. Fine, now what about the play time? Time for extra-curricular activities? Great that he was a spell bee champion but at what cost? Wearing a high number spectacles at the tender age of 11-12, in poor health, far behind in athletic and social skills than his peers! What he or rather his parents achieved from making him a spell bee champion while ignoring many other things extremely important for his personality?Would you have said that if he was sent to school every day forcefully?
In my humble opinion, this is 'zulm'. He is just a eight year old kid, making him memorizing the entire Quran in 4 months is only possible if he was allowed not to do anything else but to learn the verses by heart. I dont think that is something very humane.
Allah knows better.
OK, there is no need to get emotional. I say the same for the kids who engage in activities such as spell bee etc. Once I was watching an interview of a kid who had won the first prize; was an Indian and his parents were telling proudly that he memorizes the Dictionary eight hours a day… Those eight hours were in addition to the time he used to spent in doing his School homework etc. Fine, now what about the play time? Time for extra-curricular activities? Great that he was a spell bee champion but at what cost? Wearing a high number spectacles at the tender age of 11-12, in poor health, far behind in athletic and social skills than his peers! What he or rather his parents achieved from making him a spell bee champion while ignoring many other things extremely important for his personality?
Irrespective of how intelligent or even genius a kid maybe, he still has a total of twenty four hours a day. In these twenty four hours, he has to sleep, he has to eat, and he has to play in addition to going to the School or Madrassa. I can make my son finish his one year syllabus in merely three months (in a quarter of an year), but to achieve this, I would have to make him work harder, much harder, at the cost of the time reserved for the sleep, playing and social interaction. Yes, he will finish his syllabus, but at a certain price.
There is a reason why curriculum is designed and spreaded over a period of three quarters a year; some are harder working than others, and manage to finish their syllabus ahead of their peers, but not in one quarter of the time. Those who do that, almost always lack in other abilities and skills.
Therefore, I don’t like the idea when somebody is made to achieve something forcefully. I am positive that the kid had no choice whatsoever but to do what his parents and teachers asked him to do. At this tender age, all he learnt is to memorize the full Quran, without perhaps understanding even 1% of it. I won’t blame him, as this was something that had to be thought about by his parents and teachers. Other than being able to repeat the Quranic verses like a parrot, what he achieved? And at what cost? It is like memorizing something in Chinese or French, but what good it would do to you if you are clueless about the meaning of it?
But don’t hear me, I may be a misfit. As a parent however, I would never make my sons learn anything unless they are ready to grasp the meaning and importance of it.
Nope, they they are supposed to teach children science that is based on proven facts & history from a neutral standpoint. They are taught languages to communicate and mathematics to solve problems facing humanity.
It does not compare to something u are forced to adopt just bcoz u were born in a certain family
FYI schools are a means to develop ur own reasoning, not quite common in organized religion.
In my humble opinion, this is 'zulm'. He is just a eight year old kid, making him memorizing the entire Quran in 4 months is only possible if he was allowed not to do anything else but to learn the verses by heart. I dont think that is something very humane.
Allah knows better.