TaiShang
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2014
- Messages
- 27,848
- Reaction score
- 70
- Country
- Location
Canada has a high rate of gun ownership, but they have a low number of gun-related homicides?
Is this the case? Could it have something to do with the US over reliance on pharmaceutical medications? Or is that actually not the cause but the result of something else, i.e. they are trying to self-medicate due to feeling something else is wrong.
@TaiShang I would be interested in your views on the topic of America's gun culture.
Very good point. Canada is also a relatively high gun ownership society with very low gun-related homicide rates. Besides, Canadian people are also exposed to violent images/movies in popular culture.
It is then difficult to explain the high homicide rates in the US. Some people argue that the difference lies in culture (how could the US and Canadian cultures be possibly different drastically?). I guess what they mean is the psychology of the people which is one of fear and distrust in the US and less fear and less distrust in Canada.
Fear, accordingly, drives people to quickly refer to a gun to solve their problems or avoid potential (perceived) threats.
But it is not just the regular people to blame, I guess. The war and blood culture is promoted by the government organs. The eternal worship on the concept of "doing good by being a military person" generates a more friendly image of a gun holding person.
Besides, the US non-military security apparatus is also over-equipped. The regular police on patrol will look like a gun holding rambo in real life. This generates an image of fear as well as awe. Imagine a kid growing up seeing cops and swats in full military gear.
So, here is the US government dilemma. The (federal and state) governments cannot tell the people to disarm without themselves being disarmed to some degree. It is hypocritical. So, I do not ascribe the gun ownership of the US people to an innate desire for freedom, but to fear.
Fear from government has nothing to do with democracy or tyranny, in a sense, the US government is the most tyrannical because of its capacity to inflict fear and terror in citizens. Even some absolute autocratic countries, the state is not to be feared (or hated) this much.
I believe that the entire US state apparatus is the primary suspect and regular people are victims even when they are criminals. Here is the US dilemma: The source of the problem won't be able to solve it.
So, I guess the problem is both political and socio-psychological. It is just too demanding to be solved. They have to learn to live with that and, I guess, they are doing that. Those who cannot cope with that -- the high consumption of strong medication explains their situation. The high opioid use even cost them average life expectancy.