What's new

Search results

  1. Talwar e Pakistan

    History of Punjabis

    How is this related to 'History of Punjabis'?
  2. Talwar e Pakistan

    Requesting South Asian history section

    I think there should just be Pakistan History and General History, for non-Pakistan related historic content.
  3. Talwar e Pakistan

    Mohenjo Daro existed in early Harappan era no absence of monumental buildings/elites

    It is a nonsensical notion that they just packed up their bags and left, with IVC just 'randomly' disappearing one day. What instead occurred was a sharp decline in urban settlements, with many cities being abandoned for a multitude of reasons, the remaining inhabitants most likely returned to...
  4. Talwar e Pakistan

    Indus script was possibly used to write a known language (Amorite)

    No, I am stating that the links you spammed from every corner of the internet postulating fringe theories are blatantly rejected by the scholarly consensus. I too can also spam links of "research" claiming that the Egyptian Civilization was Black African.
  5. Talwar e Pakistan

    Indus script was possibly used to write a known language (Amorite)

    Man... I knew North Indians were obsessive larpers, but South Indians? That is a surprise and a disappointment.
  6. Talwar e Pakistan

    What will happen to Pakistan's GDP Growth Rate?

    Possibly negative growth followed by a rapid recovery.
  7. Talwar e Pakistan

    Pakistani folk dances regardless of ethnicity are very similar to each other

    I had noticed this too, the 'clapping' and swaying step is interesting, there are similar depictions in Gandharan reliefs.
  8. Talwar e Pakistan

    Indus Valley Civilization, bronze age info thread

    It's very interesting that certain people postulate the idea that because of "climate change" the inhabitants of the Indus Valley decided to leave their rich and fertile river valleys to trek across a 400 mile desert to find salvation somewhere in India. If that was the case, Indian ethnic...
  9. Talwar e Pakistan

    Featured Pakistan: The Archaeological Marvel

    I thought that was a "Hindu Dvaja" according to you.
  10. Talwar e Pakistan

    Kalash, the lost tribe of Alexander: Beautiful People in a Beautiful Valley | Pakistan Travel Vlog

    I think the correct wording would be, modern-day Pakistan once consisted of the Greco-Bactrian Kingdom. They were one of many trans-Indus states.
  11. Talwar e Pakistan

    Dancing in the Indus Valley Civilization

    Now go make a thread on how descendants of the Mesopotamians are now living somewhere in Uttarpradesh, because of some squatting position dance.
  12. Talwar e Pakistan

    Kalash, the lost tribe of Alexander: Beautiful People in a Beautiful Valley | Pakistan Travel Vlog

    Even without the genetic research that has far debunked this nonsense, the whole theory was flawed to begin with. Alexander and his army never even stepped foot that far up North. All of the Greek settlements were along the Indus. Nor do Greeks typically have colored hair/eyes.
  13. Talwar e Pakistan

    Kalash, the lost tribe of Alexander: Beautiful People in a Beautiful Valley | Pakistan Travel Vlog

    This nonsense has been debunked, they are a genetic isolate group, on the PCA chart, the closest ethnic groups to them are other Pakistani ethnic groups. Once you convert to Islam, you are no longer considered a 'Kalash'. A large portion, if not half of the surrounding valleys at one point...
  14. Talwar e Pakistan

    Dancing in the Indus Valley Civilization

    He's been lately trying to go to the most random extents in his irrational bid to connect IVC to some Biharis living a thousand miles away. In his previous thread, he attempted to relate an IVC seal to a "Shunga coin" from somewhere in Bengal. Looking at his location, it seems he belongs to...
  15. Talwar e Pakistan

    Coins of Indian iron age provides strong links to bronze age IVC

    and you concluded all that from this?
  16. Talwar e Pakistan

    Mohenjodaro, extent of excavation

    The plan on burying that 10% to avoid erosion.
  17. Talwar e Pakistan

    Coins of Indian iron age provides strong links to bronze age IVC

    Now show me how the '8th' BCE century coin here, besides the square shape, is in any way, familiar to an IVC seal.
  18. Talwar e Pakistan

    Coins of Indian iron age provides strong links to bronze age IVC

    Please read my post again, where did I state the contrary. I only stated that depiction of animals and written script on coinage were introduced by the Greeks. The Shunga Empire lasted 185 BCE–75 BCE, how in the hell were their coins dated back to 855 BCE. Does your 'GR Sharma' belong to the...
Back
Top Bottom