Search results

No your analogy is not correct. It would be if the muazzin would be replaced rather than using a loudspeaker since in this case you are replacing the sighting of the moon. Loudspeakers have been allowed through fatwas since many people complained of it disturbing the peace. Please read the...

Your analogy is incorrect. Now if loudspeakers were not used as a tool and replaced the muazzin with a recorded sound, then it would be Bidah. The use of loudspeakers comes with backing of numerous fatwas. Even in Saudi Arabia they use telescopes for viewing the moon and not the naked eye. We...

I tagged and reported in another thread. I also posted in GHQ. No action has been taken as of yet. What i reported is quite an open and shut case of racism(in the other thread on Karachi)

It is every bit as valid today. Your point also valid. I am an advocate of using science as an aid. Science can tell you when you can view the moon, at what degree and for how much time. But, as per Hadith, anything not done IN RELIGION BY THE PROHET (ﷺ) IS BIDAH. Following is what the Same...

Don’t waste your time with the mods. I already tried. Some of them think this is legitimate discussion and saying anything against this is trolling. Go figure.

I do not need a lesson in astronomy. I am quite aware of how the moon orbits and how it has phases. Now that that’s out of the way, please tell me where in your post did you reply when i showed you where an islamic country still does moon sighting? Verbosity does not make a point more valid...

You automatically become hostage when half your countrymen are anti-army in one way or the other. Just check some of the posts on this very forum. I am pretty sure the security establishment are more aware of the network and operation of PTM then us sitting in our homes. At that level you...

I am glad our security apparatus is not as short sighted as many of the people on this forum. The same people also saying we should have killed Bipin on 27th Feb. Once they shot at the security apparatus, they cracked down on them. Had they cracked down on these idiots beforehand, the other...

Am I supposed to spell it out for you? If you haven’t done your due diligence how can you propose a system that is allegedly better? Saudi Arabia prints an Islamic calendar, uses the Islamic calendar as official dates yet takes the time out to sight the moon ONE DAY BEFORE. That is what the...

They are being dealt with behind closed doors. You don’t broadcast everything that is being done against PTM. Ali Wazir was presented before an Anti-Terrorism court and remanded. The other b!tch is on the run. As for the armed forces, they are wanting to avoid it looking like the State cracking...

The Islamic way is what is prevalent since 14 centuries and works everywhere except Pakistan. The controversy here is purely political between two Mullahs. That is all. Otherwise the rest of the Islamic world is quite fine with the Islamic way.

You may disagree but Islam is not based on our whims. Whatever is established in Sunnah is not for us to review. Also for your analogy , there is no scenario where the entire country is under cloud cover for days. Thats why witness statements are also acceptable. It IS mandatory . Please...

Though the intentions are good, we cannot solely use a lunar calendar for deciding Islamic months. The sighting of the moon is Sunnah and the physical act (or bearing witness of this act) is established as mandatory by multiple fatwas. We can however use this calendar to remove the controversy...

I think this article might be to deflect from the fact that Scotty Bipin was in the building. Face saving more than anything. Two commanders are way more palatable to the Indian masses then us knowing exactly where their COAS was and missing deliberately.

Firebrand and brilliant. You ve got to like his honesty and straightforward questions.

It is exactly what i am afraid of. If we can’t control it here, where the majority are somewhat educated, how can we expect to control the real thing. Sad state of affairs.

I agree with your post in principle. But there are better ways of resolving such a sense of deprivation than resorting to racial chauvinism. That is the point i am trying to make. In our scenario, the mods should have put a stop to this , them being the “leaders “ in this time and place. An...

Your post is exactly what is wrong with this thread. You on one hand try to counter the racism with your opening para, then proceed to spew the same racial superiority nonsense that everyone is spewing on this thread. What separates your post from the others on this thread? An honest...

Exactly. Doob marnay ka hi maqam hai.

If you didn’t care you wouldn’t be venting . Also none of your purported links show destabilising of the country. Army was involved in politics. That’s an altogether different debate. Ok thanks for taking to the time to reply. If you don’t wish to reply then there is no debate. Have a nice day.