Wrong Facts on Chanakya

[RangerPK]

Again mods. You keep on giving infractions and handing out bans to me for discussing "banned topics".

I just have to give it a shot about what he really worships and this pathetic self loath will set himself off to meet his 72 (as promised).

Funny how you people come to a Pakistani site and be nothing but offensive to us, but when it comes your turn you go running to the mods..crying..

Lololololol

 

[Ammyy]

Funny, how Indus vally is not even located in India, but its mainly in Pakistan. It is our historical heritage. Not yours. Please stop stealing other people's stuff. I know you are jealous of us, but this is real low.

Funny how Pakistani muslim has nothing common as IVC .... Its a proof that you people latter converted to muslim from Hinduism.

 

[Chanakya's_Chant]

^^^Caution, A Troller AT Work!!!!^^^

Lol. Indian are criticizing our history taught in schools, while Indian governments brain washes their children in to believing, India borders Afghanistan. Lol.shows the height of delusion and lies. Indian government can not even accept its geography as reality. Lol they can not even get their present right, what can be said about their nut job history...lol

Are you so dumb that you cant even see the truth????? These texts have even drawn criticism from your scholars and journalists. In a 1995 paper published in the International Journal of Middle East Studies, historian Ayesha Jalal stated that "Pakistan's history textbooks amongst the best available sources for assessing the nexus between power and bigotry in creative imaginings of a national past." She points out authors whose "expansive pan-Islamic imaginings" detect the beginnings of Pakistan in the birth of Islam on the Arabian peninsula. One of your renowned journalists Nizam Sethi criticized it by referring it as youth brainwash... The re is a video on YouTube titled "What is in textbook of Pakistani school" in which your very own journalist exposes these crap texts...Google it and you will get to know the reality.....

 

[RangerPK]

Funny how Pakistani muslim has nothing common as IVC .... Its a proof that you people latter converted to muslim from Hinduism.

Regardless what the religion of our ancestors was. It is irrelevant to what our heritage is. Indus vally is located in Pakistan, thus it is the heritage of ours. It is not your heritage. I guess you are jealous of our heritage and have nothing to show for yourselves, thus you people shamelessly try to steal from others. How low can you get?

^^^Caution, A Troller AT Work!!!!^^^



Are you so dumb that you cant even see the truth????? These texts have even drawn criticism from your scholars and journalists. In a 1995 paper published in the International Journal of Middle East Studies, historian Ayesha Jalal stated that "Pakistan's history textbooks amongst the best available sources for assessing the nexus between power and bigotry in creative imaginings of a national past." She points out authors whose "expansive pan-Islamic imaginings" detect the beginnings of Pakistan in the birth of Islam on the Arabian peninsula. One of your renowned journalists Nizam Sethi criticized it by referring it as youth brainwash... The re is a video on YouTube titled "What is in textbook of Pakistani school" in which your very own journalist exposes these crap texts...Google it and you will get to know the reality.....

Thank you for warning us before you started trolling. This is post is irrelivent to the topic. Please stop derailing the thread. Make another thread to discuss this topic.

 

[Armstrong]

Not really buddy these were the texts derived from the Pakistani Studies Textbooks which I suppose is part of your national curriculum not any local one.....

The content of Pakistan's official textbooks has often been criticized by several sources including many within Pakistan for sometimes promoting religious intolerance and Indophobia, leading to calls for curriculum reform. (but in rare cases)

According to Hussain Haqqani, only officially published textbooks are used in Pakistan's schools and colleges since the era of Ayub Khan. This is used by Pakistani government to create a standard narrative of Pakistan's history. During the rule of General Muhammad Zia-ul-Haq a program of Islamization of the country including the textbooks was started. General Zia's 1979 education policy stated that "[the] highest priority would be given to the revision of the curricula with a view to reorganizing the entire content around Islamic thought and giving education an ideological orientation so that Islamic ideology permeates the thinking of the younger generation and helps them with the necessary conviction and ability to refashion society according to Islamic tenets".
According to the Sustainable Development Policy Institute, since the 1970s Pakistani school textbooks have systematically inculcated hatred towards India and Hindus through historical revisionism. There is no mention of Islamic invasion and conversion of Hindus. Many texts give an impression that ancient Indian heritage was not destroyed by Afghans and Turks but Muslim heritage was destroyed by Indians, which is a contradiction of the theory of international historians.

May be right now they have been removed from the same (If not then the officials should serious consider removing the same) but those facts and texts that I just listed were from Wikipedia, and some of you reputed dailies such as the Tribune and the Dawn....

Sorry my post count is still below 30 that's why I am not able attach the links but you can Google the same keywords and you will get to known those credible sources from where I have taken such texts....

I've seen links to it aplenty so don't bother along with excerpts taking out from these books. There is no 'National Board' in Pakistan. There are numerous local boards throughout the country & Pakistan Studies are taught across the length & breadth of them.

I've gone through the same system but I've never come across anything of the sort so I dunno where those texts are coming from !

At the same time because History deals with narratives & even 'facts' are narratives its a bit hard to discount or affirm everything with utmost certainty ! And at the same time many of the so-called overtones might not be all that unacceptable were they looked at through a different prism.

But like I said I've never come across them in any of my Pakistan Studies or before that Social Studies Curriculum so I don't know where its coming from & in what context any of those excerpts were written !

 

[RangerPK]

Dnt confuse your idol as Hindu....

You can worship pigs not hindu.

Hindu pig God is called Varaha. You people worship pigs....

Here are some pictures

But Pigs are your idol and you people do worship it? Were you trying to insult when you said those lines? What must you think about yourselves then... Oh my... I can see the inferiority complex emitting from you. Psychologically projecting your inferiority complexes upon others. No wonders, you people try to steal our heritage, because inside you know you feel inferior to us, and want to become our equals... quite pathetic really.

 

[Ammyy]

Regardless what the religion of our ancestors was. It is irrelevant to what our heritage is. Indus vally is located in Pakistan, thus it is the heritage of ours. It is not your heritage. I guess you are jealous of our heritage and have nothing to show for yourselves, thus you people shamelessly try to steal from others. How low can you get?

Dnt post BS ... Indus vally was located well within India and Pakistan .... (if you can see map)

Heritage is what you yourself carrying.... But you people converted to Islam and leave your haritage on the other hand Indians practicing same.

 

[RangerPK]

Dnt post BS ... Indus vally was located well within India and Pakistan .... (if you can see map)

Heritage is what you yourself carrying.... But you people converted to Islam and leave your haritage on the other hand Indians practicing same.

India was created in 1947....lol are you really this delusional? Oh my God. but then again, a moment ago you were saying hindus don't worship pigs, and wala, you were lieing to the core as usual...

I guess, you are jealous of us ...lol Its ok if you are jealous... but don't reduce yourselves to being petty thieves.. that's very undignified.


It is IRRELLVENT, what religion, the people of punjab, Sindh, Baluchistan, KPK, used to have.... Indus vally is our heritage. Since it is located in OUR LAND. not yours...lol... I guess common sense is not your cup of tea..

I guess you are jealous of our heritage and achievements.. lol... Its ok if you are jealous from us, but reducing yourselves to petty thieves is very undignified...lol.. shame...inferiority complex at its best..

 

[curioususer]

Funny, how Indus vally is not even located in India, but its mainly in Pakistan. It is our historical heritage. Not yours. Please stop stealing other people's stuff. I know you are jealous of us, but this is real low.

Then why isn't Pakistan named India?

 

[RangerPK]

Then why isn't Pakistan named India?

Lol, Oh my God, another jealous Indian troll. That did not even make any sense...lol

 

[Ammyy]

India was created in 1947....lol are you really this delusional? Oh my God. but then again, a moment ago you were saying hindus don't worship pigs, and wala, you were lieing to the core as usual...

I guess, you are jealous of ...lol Its ok for you to be jealous... but don't reduce yourselves to being petty thieves.. thats very undignified.


It is IRRELLVENT, what religion, the people of punjab, Sindh, Baluchistan, KPK, used to have.... Indus vally is our heritage. Since it is located in OUR LAND. not yours...lol... I guess common sense is not your cup of tea..

This is the map of IVC

well within present day India.

Jealous of what ???? You people converted to islam and we are not ::

I am not talking about country but people .... Some people shamelessly converted to other religion and talking about common sense ... amazing

 

[RangerPK]

This is the map of IVC

well within present day India.

Jealous of what ???? You people converted to islam and we are not ::

I am not talking about country but people .... Some people shamelessly converted to other religion and talking about common sense ... amazing

Do you lack comprehension abilities this bad? Indus Vally, it does not matter, what religion our ancestors were. Indus vally is located in our land, and is thus is our heritage.

As for converting to Islam? do we really need to elaborate that? We worship the one true God who has created everything, he is one, He has no equal he is unique. and what do you worship ? Pigs? seriously? and you are proud of worshiping pigs? Good luck on the day of judgment explaining to God that, don't complain when God would throw you in hell for being proud of worshiping something which you were denying five minutes ago out of shame...

 

[Ammyy]

Do you lack comprehension abilities this bad? Indus Vally, it does not matter, what religion our ancestors were. Indus vally is located in our land, and is thus is our heritage.

As for converting to Islam? do we really need to elaborate that? We worship the one true God who has created everything, he is one, He has no equal he is unique. and what do you worship ? Pigs? seriously? and you are proud of worshiping pigs? Good luck on the day of judgment explaining to God that, don't complain when God would throw you in hell for being proud of worshiping something which you were denying five minutes ago out of shame...

Only if you cant see even with open eyes ....

Just read this ...IVC is Indian heritage and world know this fact ...
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indus_Valley_Civilization

And I can understand your problem .... You dnt have your own heritage ... you simply converted to religion what invaders impose you.


And about worship .... Your forefathers worship same idols ... so indirectly you insulting them not us.

 

[Chanakya's_Chant]

Regardless what the religion of our ancestors was. It is irrelevant to what our heritage is. Indus vally is located in Pakistan, thus it is the heritage of ours. It is not your heritage. I guess you are jealous of our heritage and have nothing to show for yourselves, thus you people shamelessly try to steal from others. How low can you get?



Thank you for warning us before you started trolling. This is post is irrelivent to the topic. Please stop derailing the thread. Make another thread to discuss this topic.

Now what to do when you guys are never in a state to accept the truth!!!! #Who cares, the remarks made by that stupid anchor were no doubt a result of these sorts of such misconceptions and poorly compiled history which are an eternal part of your society even now also....

 

[RangerPK]

Only if you cant see even with open eyes ....

Just read this ...IVC is Indian heritage and world know this fact ...
Indus Valley Civilization - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

And I can understand your problem .... You dnt have your own heritage ... you simply converted to religion what invaders impose you.


And about worship .... Your forefathers worship same idols ... so indirectly you insulting them not us.

It does not matter what religion our fore fathers had. Indus vally, the INDUS RIVER, is located in Pakistan, and our lives are centered around it. Indus Vally is located in Pakistan, thus it is our heritage. There is NO, Indus river in your land. lol...are you really this delusional and jealous? lol

Islam is the only true religion, There is nothing worthy of worship except The God, and Muhammad is His prophet.

This is the fact, which our fore fathers were wise enough to accept and leave their pagan traditions. What about you guys? you still worship pigs....look at yourselves for a moment and think about it? is this what God wants you to do? worship pigs?

Surely, our ancestors were wise and made the right decision , yours were not, you still worship pigs...

Are you really this jealous? lol, that no you would steal our river in our land from us....lol of course you can't, its physically impossible, but it wont stop you from making up lies out of jealousy..lol

There is NO Indus River in India...lol.... You people depend on other river system for your livelihood, but of course, you people are Jealous of us and our River Indus...because you have nothing to show for yourselves...