What's new

Wombs available for surrogacy in India - ethical issues

DESERT FIGHTER

ELITE MEMBER
Joined
Jan 1, 2010
Messages
46,973
Reaction score
95
Country
Pakistan
Location
Pakistan
Surrogate pregnancy, an assisted reproductive technique (ART) in which a woman carries in her womb the baby of another woman, has seen a spurt in India.

Due to the healthier lifestyles of to-be mothers and lower costs compared to the West, the country could become a global hub in the field, gynaecology experts say.

"The reason why surrogate pregnancy is rising is mainly because of the low-cost factor, and the preferably healthy lifestyle of Indian women, much needed during pregnancy," Shivani Sachdev Gour, fertility expert and gynaecologist, said.

"Women here are less exposed to a lifestyle with drugs, alcohol and smoking, which has a positive impact on the health of the baby as well as the mother. Also surrogacy laws in India are much lenient as compared to other countries," added Gour.

She says she gets around 25 patients every month from countries like Britain, the US, and countries in the Middle East at the Surrogacy Centre of India Healthcare, a private hospital she runs in south Delhi.

While the cost of treatment and expenses involved in surrogate pregnancy vary between Rs 50,000 and Rs 100,000 ($1,000 and $2,000) in India, the cost in other countries like the US and Britain is nearly five times that in India, said Gour.

"Surrogacy is advised in cases of malformed uterus, or when pregnancy is life-threatening. But the reasons are slowly expanding in our country," said Alka Kriplani, professor at the department of obstetrics and gynaecology at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS).

According to experts, the success rate of surrogate pregnancy at centres in India is higher than in other countries.

"In over 60 per cent of cases, the prospective mother carries back a healthy baby, while the miscarriage rate is less than 15 per cent," said Gour.

Experts also emphasise on the need for stringent surrogacy norms at ART centres.

"A proper screening process is required. Apart from the carrier's age, which should be between 21 and 35 years, their medical, personal and family history should also be gauged to decipher her mental and physical well-being," explained Gour.

After the preliminary screening of the surrogate, a well detailed contract as per Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) guidelines is made between the surrogate and the couples in question. The process involves all the three main parties - the parent, child and the surrogate.

Prospective parents - mostly coming to India from the US, Britain and Israel - have discovered that the surrogacy laws of other countries often come in the way of parents returning home with their children, experts said.

"Surrogacy is rising and it is important to keep an eye on the use of the technique. It can be misused also as poor women are lured into becoming surrogate mothers because of the money involved," said Kriplani.

The draft Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) Regulation Bill, 2010, that lays down guidelines for the practice of surrogacy, states that the birth certificate of a baby born out of rent-a-womb arrangement should be in the names of the intended parents, who would automatically become the newborn's legal parents.
:tdown:shame

Rent-a-womb: India becoming surrogate pregnancy hub
 
.
there was a program on BBC about this called "google babies"
 
.
Already posted mate. The article is from Feb and already posted and discussed.
 
.
Amazing what science can do these days...
 
. . .
Surrogate pregnancy, an assisted reproductive technique (ART) in which a woman carries in her womb the baby of another woman, has seen a spurt in India.

Due to the healthier lifestyles of to-be mothers and lower costs compared to the West, the country could become a global hub in the field, gynaecology experts say.

"The reason why surrogate pregnancy is rising is mainly because of the low-cost factor, and the preferably healthy lifestyle of Indian women, much needed during pregnancy," Shivani Sachdev Gour, fertility expert and gynaecologist, said.

"Women here are less exposed to a lifestyle with drugs, alcohol and smoking, which has a positive impact on the health of the baby as well as the mother. Also surrogacy laws in India are much lenient as compared to other countries," added Gour.

She says she gets around 25 patients every month from countries like Britain, the US, and countries in the Middle East at the Surrogacy Centre of India Healthcare, a private hospital she runs in south Delhi.

While the cost of treatment and expenses involved in surrogate pregnancy vary between Rs 50,000 and Rs 100,000 ($1,000 and $2,000) in India, the cost in other countries like the US and Britain is nearly five times that in India, said Gour.

"Surrogacy is advised in cases of malformed uterus, or when pregnancy is life-threatening. But the reasons are slowly expanding in our country," said Alka Kriplani, professor at the department of obstetrics and gynaecology at the All India Institute of Medical Sciences (AIIMS).

According to experts, the success rate of surrogate pregnancy at centres in India is higher than in other countries.

"In over 60 per cent of cases, the prospective mother carries back a healthy baby, while the miscarriage rate is less than 15 per cent," said Gour.

Experts also emphasise on the need for stringent surrogacy norms at ART centres.

"A proper screening process is required. Apart from the carrier's age, which should be between 21 and 35 years, their medical, personal and family history should also be gauged to decipher her mental and physical well-being," explained Gour.

After the preliminary screening of the surrogate, a well detailed contract as per Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR) guidelines is made between the surrogate and the couples in question. The process involves all the three main parties - the parent, child and the surrogate.

Prospective parents - mostly coming to India from the US, Britain and Israel - have discovered that the surrogacy laws of other countries often come in the way of parents returning home with their children, experts said.

"Surrogacy is rising and it is important to keep an eye on the use of the technique. It can be misused also as poor women are lured into becoming surrogate mothers because of the money involved," said Kriplani.

The draft Assisted Reproductive Technologies (ART) Regulation Bill, 2010, that lays down guidelines for the practice of surrogacy, states that the birth certificate of a baby born out of rent-a-womb arrangement should be in the names of the intended parents, who would automatically become the newborn's legal parents.
:tdown:shame

Rent-a-womb: India becoming surrogate pregnancy hub


Shame for whom? Before calling it a shame think about the couple who cannot have a baby. Agreed, the laws should be tightened to avoid misuse.
 
.
Shame for whom? Before calling it a shame think about the couple who cannot have a baby. Agreed, the laws should be tightened to avoid misuse.

Selling a part of ur body.... its like prostitution.... u get paid... u deliver...
 
.
Selling a part of ur body.... its like prostitution.... u get paid... u deliver...

so you are also against those who sell their kidneys? and if you are wise enough then you will understand the difference between renting and selling...
 
. .
.
Selling a part of ur body.... its like prostitution.... u get paid... u deliver...
Do you know that surrogacy even happens in countries like the US, where Army wives act as surrogates ? Well, if the what you say is what taught in the Land of the Pure, then all i can say is they are doing a fine job as an advocate of tolerance and free-spirited thinking.
 
.
Do you know that surrogacy even happens in countries like the US, where Army wives act as surrogates ? Well, if the what you say is what taught in the Land of the Pure, then all i can say is they are doing a fine job as an advocate of tolerance and free-spirited thinking.

Do they do it for the money? like these indian women? is america the hub of commercial surrogate pregnancy? Heck no!
 
.
.
Selling a part of ur body.... its like prostitution.... u get paid... u deliver...

Think of it this way, your family's bread winner has passed away or is a drunk abuser,
your mom has to find a way to feed the family and child , unable to make ends meet with occupation like labour.
She"ll have finally 2 choices
1.Prostitution
2.this thing you call shameful

What would you want her to do?

Besides in nations like Pakistan and India where infant and maternal mortality rates are high ,surrogacy can be of help as it enables a women to better understand the precautions to take during pregnancy,
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom