Why Sindhis were never Indians or Hindus in history

[Sindhi(Indus)]

People have this saying that just because Sindhis are on average darker than other Pakistanis that they're associated with Indian people

Well historically speaking, Sindh have never been apart of any body east of the Indus river. The Hindus in Sindh were 15% whereas 85% of the population was Buddhist at the time of Bin Qasim.

Persian geographer Al Ishtkari and also from old Turkish and Arab maps show that Sindh is a land that has been separate and also named after itself way before even names like Afghanistan, Balochistan, and Kashmir existed

Also skin tone wise Sindhis scientifically are not the same as Indians either

Punjabis and Kashmiris had caste systems and were hindus till this day

Sindh never had a caste system in history

 

[Sindhi(Indus)]

Also the few polytheist in Sindh were migrants from India

Hindus in Sindh were as much foreigners as Balochis were in Sindh.

Even the Portuguese knew there was a difference between Sindh and India

Also this might not be related however most maps show gog magog lands as northern European people

Persian geographer in his memoirs said that the people of Sindh were always distinct and also different from the people from hind however 15% of the population was Indian however the desert of Rajasthan is officially the borderline between Sindhi and Indians

That is why genetically speaking on PCA plots

Sindhis are NEVER near Gujaratis

Sindhis are near Balochis and also Brahui

Gujaratis are near South Indians

Also the few polytheist in Sindh were migrants from India

Hindus in Sindh were as much foreigners as Balochis were in Sindh.

Even the Portuguese knew there was a difference between Sindh and India

Also this might not be related however most maps show gog magog lands as northern European people

Persian geographer in his memoirs said that the people of Sindh were always distinct and also different from the people from hind however 15% of the population was Indian however the desert of Rajasthan is officially the borderline between Sindhi and Indians

That is why genetically speaking on PCA plots

Sindhis are NEVER near Gujaratis

Sindhis are near Balochis and also Brahui

Gujaratis are near South Indians

Here are gene population PCA plots

Notice that Sindhis are not remotely next to Gujaratis

That means the border for India was always the desert between Sindh and Gujarat

North Indians are next to south Indians

Northeast Indians are next to East Asians

Sindhis are next to Baloch and Pashtuns

Tajiks are also near Pashtuns too

Hazaras are next to Mongolians

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Also the few polytheist in Sindh were migrants from India

Hindus in Sindh were as much foreigners as Balochis were in Sindh.

Even the Portuguese knew there was a difference between Sindh and India

View attachment 536344

Also this might not be related however most maps show gog magog lands as northern European people

Persian geographer in his memoirs said that the people of Sindh were always distinct and also different from the people from hind however 15% of the population was Indian however the desert of Rajasthan is officially the borderline between Sindhi and Indians

That is why genetically speaking on PCA plots

Sindhis are NEVER near Gujaratis

Sindhis are near Balochis and also Brahui

Gujaratis are near South Indians

Sindhi nationalist. All power to you. Much respect to your ancient land. Sindh was there before anybody knew Ganga even existed. For a long time Sindh was on the edge of the world beyond which was unkown and darkness.

Your people laid the foundation of Pakistan by passing the resolution for Pakistan in 1940. I am agast why we don't have many Sindhi's on PDF. You are the foundation stone of Pakistan and need to express your land more.

 

[Sindhi(Indus)]

Sindhi nationalist. All power to you. Much respect to your ancient land. Sindh was there before anybody knew Ganga even existed. For a long time Sindh was on the edge of the world beyond which was unkown and darkness.

Your people laid the foundation of Pakistan by passing the resolution for Pakistan in 1940. I am agast why we don't have many Sindhi's on PDF. You are the foundation stone of Pakistan and need to express your land more.

Words like ganga, hindu, india, iran, afghanistan, punjab, tajikistan, all of these lands are new names, Sindh has been there before Herodotus times.

That is why every old ancient map has a difference of the two

You will never see the words India on any map from any geographer stretching over Sindh

The RSS propaganda is just lies and also deceit nothing more

Also Indus River is 99% in Pakistan so Pakistan is India and India is something else

 

[Indus Pakistan]

Sindh has been there before Herodotus times.

Long time before India even existed there was Sindh. A ancient land.

 

[Sindhi(Indus)]

Pakistan is

Punjab
Afghania
Kashmir
Iran
Sindh
Turkarstan
Afghanistan
BalochistaN

Its the punjabis who brought urdu to our lands

Its punjabis who endorse bollywood which is infidel any way

 

[Pan-Islamic-Pakistan]

Its punjabis who endorse bollywood which is infidel any way

Brother, some of us don’t watch Bollywood either and many of us want to see Pakistan distinct from India as well.

Sindhis have a great and ancient culture. Glad to see you here.

Please keep the blame on Punjab to a minimum.

Do you support PPP, by the way? What do you say about their lack of development in Sindh.

 

[Yankee-stani]

Brother, some of us don’t watch Bollywood either and many of us want to see Pakistan distinct from India as well.

Sindhis have a great and ancient culture. Glad to see you here.

Please keep the blame on Punjab to a minimum.

Do you support PPP, by the way? What do you say about their lack of development in Sindh.

He is kinda right I despise Bollywood yet many Punjabis love it sadly

 

[cocomo]

Pakistan is

Punjab
Afghania
Kashmir
Iran
Sindh
Turkarstan
Afghanistan
BalochistaN

Its the punjabis who brought urdu to our lands

Its punjabis who endorse bollywood which is infidel any way

I heard in a documentary where a Hindu claims that Sindhi Hindus aren't Hindus and that Sindhis worship their own deity called "Johle LaL". I know presently it is attributed to Saint Lal Shahbaz Qalandar but It seems like it is connected to practices of old Sindhis.

 

[Sindhi(Indus)]

I heard in a documentary where a Hindu claims that Sindhi Hindus aren't Hindus and that Sindhis worship their own deity called "Johle LaL". I know presently it is attributed to Saint Lal Shahbaz Qalandar but It seems like it is connected to practices of old Sindhis.

Sindhi Hindus are Indians who migrated from India

Sindhi Baloch migrated from Balochistan

52% of Baloch live in Sindh

The original Sindhis were Mohanna Indus people, nowadays Sindhis is almost 85% Baloch or Mujhair with Mujhairs being in the cities more, the Pashtuns from Waziristan have also populated Sindh now too

 

[paritosh]

Words like ganga, hindu, india, iran, afghanistan, punjab, tajikistan, all of these lands are new names, Sindh has been there before Herodotus times.

That is why every old ancient map has a difference of the two

You will never see the words India on any map from any geographer stretching over Sindh

The RSS propaganda is just lies and also deceit nothing more

Also Indus River is 99% in Pakistan so Pakistan is India and India is something else

Isn't the name "India" a derivative of "Sindhu"?

 

[Sindhi(Indus)]

If Sindhis were like Pashtuns, we would have massacred the Mujhairs to pieces and told them to make their urdustan in Punjab or any other province.

The reason I did my research is because they're Sindh world organization funded from Mossad and Zionist who are trying to link us to Indians.

They said Indians and Sindhis are both of the Indus Valley, wrong

Isn't the name "India" a derivative of "Sindhu"?

The word India is from Greeks Indo, the word India was used on western maps, british, greeks, and portuguese

The westerners didn't say Hindu or Hind

Hind was how Arabs and Turks referred to the land

India and Hindu are both names given to the people of the ganges

 

[paritosh]

If Sindhis were like Pashtuns, we would have massacred the Mujhairs to pieces and told them to make their urdustan in Punjab or any other province.

The reason I did my research is because they're Sindh world organization funded from Mossad and Zionist who are trying to link us to Indians.

They said Indians and Sindhis are both of the Indus Valley, wrong

View attachment 536357


The word India is from Greeks Indo, the word India was used on western maps, british, greeks, and portuguese

The westerners didn't say Hindu or Hind

Hind was how Arabs and Turks referred to the land

India and Hindu are both names given to the people of the ganges View attachment 536358

The name came from the Sanskrit word for the river Indus - Sindhu which also is the reason the area around the river was called Sindh. The Greeks picked up Sindhu and dropped the "S" and the "h".
https://www.ancient.eu/article/203/etymology-of-the-name-india/

 

[HariPrasad]

I heard in a documentary where a Hindu claims that Sindhi Hindus aren't Hindus and that Sindhis worship their own deity called "Johle LaL"

And Jule Lal is believed to be the incarnation of loard VIshnu who is one of the three main gods of Hindus.

 

[Sindhi(Indus)]

The name came from the Sanskrit word for the river Indus - Sindhu which also is the reason the area around the river was called Sindh. The Greeks picked up Sindhu and dropped the "S" and the "h".
https://www.ancient.eu/article/203/etymology-of-the-name-india/

This is a Greek map of the world

India is written after the Indus

The whole Sindh province is Gedrosia and Ariana