Why 'secular' Narendra Modi bashers must be ignored

[KS]

very valid & solid argument. then again.. are we going to keep dwelling on this riots thing for ever? what about all those good things he is been doing so far? we have people taking pot shots on modi at every opertunity. but when people start praising his good work.. everyone seems to have a problem & modi suddenly becomes untouchable & yucky kind of person!! why is this hypocrisy? oh.. i know... the so called progressive alliance headed by congress relies on mudslinging on modi to mask their own shortcomings in every aspect of their governance!!

Exactly.

If one is guilty of mis-management (though one could hardly call it mis-management considering the history of Gujarat as one of the states worst affected by riots for a long long time and how much the emotions would be when news of 60 persons including women and children have been burnt to death. Actually to his credit he contained the riots within 3 days, contained the spread of riots to other areas), then MMS too is guilty of mis-management on a garangutan scale.

But its always rose-petals for one mis-management while brick-bats for the other. Hypocrisy is sickening.

 

[KS]

The silent majority??????
See around man..........MMS is not getting any support in this forum
If thats the point you are saying that he has demolished temples /...........and so he cannot be puppet of RSS............well he stopped after daddy RSS objected!!!!!

Gurudaras , temples , masjids everything gets cleared in punjab If it comes in the way...../.....and every govt does the same weather its is congress or akali dal ( partner of BJP)

No he did not stop and still they are going on. And don't forget during the last Guj elections the differences between Modi and RSS/VHP came out in the open, though they later denied it.

See I am no big hater of MMS either. Infact I liked the way he conducted himself during the Nuclear deal and I opposed the BJP/Narendra Modi whoever opposed that.

But MMS' second term is a disaster in terms of management. The manner in which he handled the 2G spectrum, the Thomas-CVC case all point that he is just a puppet behind the Gandhi family.

But on contrast, Modi has done an excellent administrative work in Guj. But he gets brick bats all the time for an incident 10 years ago while the clearly less competent MMS is always showered with rose petals.

Why this hypocrisy ?

 

[Prometheus]

state emergency declared in India when Indira Gandhi was PM she killed thousand of People that time
Sikh riots occur when congress in Power what they did that time ???? jagdish tytler still roaming freely

Warren anderson(Killer of thousands) was allowed to leave county by your f**** rajiv gandhi

Plz control the feelings.( and ofcourse the language)
I am no fan of gandhis.
But i am certainly a fan of MMS ...........
That man has struggled at each of point of its life.......
Its not easy to leave his home land bussiness etc behind and migrate to other place.......watching riots during his early years of age ........leaving his dear ones behind.
Still not leaving hope......from poverty.....from nothing .......to become so much succesful is a sign of a great man himself.
When in the hell we can get a PHD leader????
When we can get Finance minister who can work for a rupee a month during crises( read 1990)
Just because many scams has surfaced under him......doesnt mean he is not a great man and he should be insulted and called pu$$y coward impotent etc.

And about anti sikh roits ..........I m not a supporter of congress
My grands has been part of panchayat from last 5 decades and he is akali not congressee

 

[Prometheus]

No he did not stop and still they are going on. And don't forget during the last Guj elections the differences between Modi and RSS/VHP came out in the open, though they later denied it.

See I am no big hater of MMS either. Infact I liked the way he conducted himself during the Nuclear deal and I opposed the BJP/Narendra Modi whoever opposed that.

But MMS' second term is a disaster in terms of management. The manner in which he handled the 2G spectrum, the Thomas-CVC case all point that he is just a puppet behind the Gandhi family.

But on contrast, Modi has done an excellent administrative work in Guj. But he gets brick bats all the time while the clearly less comepetent MMS is always showered with rose petals.

Why this hypocrisy ?

Read my comment 79.
I like Narender for his administration.........but that cannot become a tool to insult MMS.

 

[Prometheus]

People are comparing a self made man and a RSS made man

People are comparing a A leader who is running a colation govt. With a person a who has a absolute majority govt.
People are comparing a person who is a PM of 121 crores people to a person who is just a CM of a small part of that same nation

Aaaaahhhhh......what a comparisn

 

[KS]

Read my comment 79.
I like Narender for his administration.........but that cannot become a tool to insult MMS.

Why not ? Is there not a single standard for all ?

Im not saying you hate Modi, but if he can be singularly attacked for his alleged mismanagement of an incident 10 years ago, why not MMS be criticized for what is happening RIGHT NOW in the country. ?

If you don't want anyone to criticize MMS please ask him to resign as the PM of this country. But till he is the leader of the Govt he will be criticized for the shortcomings of the Govt and its mis-management.

Its nothing personal.

People are comparing a self made man and a RSS made man

People are comparing a A leader who is running a colation govt. With a person a who has a absolute majority govt.
People are comparing a person who is a PM of 121 crores people to a person who is just a CM of a small part of that same nation

Aaaaahhhhh......what a comparisn

Ahhh....If Modi is RSS made, then MMS is Congress made.

Surely he did not win a seat as an independent and become the PM. He won on Congress ticket.

And surely these cannot be the excuses for mis-management.

 

[Abingdonboy]

Okay I understand you guys want development but at what cost?? Selling your souls to the devil? This man is a bigoted criminal. End of story. India is a secular country, it was built from the ground up with this ideal, it is in the constitution. Just because he has managed successful development in his stare doesn't mean he should be the PM of a country that is proud of its diversity.

 

[Prometheus]

Why not ? Is there not a single standard for all ?

Im not saying you hate Modi, but if he can be singularly attacked for his alleged mismanagement of an incident 10 years ago, why not MMS be criticized for what is happening RIGHT NOW in the country. ?

If you don't want anyone to criticize MMS please ask him to resign as the PM of this country. But till he is the leader of the Govt he will be criticized for the shortcomings of the Govt and its mis-management.

Its nothing personal.



Ahhh....If Modi is RSS made, then MMS is Congress made.

Surely he did not win a seat as an independent and become the PM. He won on Congress ticket.

And surely these cannot be the excuses for mis-management.

So that means both are MMS and narender are Pu$$y ( as in the language of a user here)
Both are not fit to be leader

 

[Prometheus]

Okay I understand you guys want development but at what cost?? Selling your souls to the devil? This man is a bigoted criminal. End of story. India is a secular country, it was built from the ground up with this ideal, it is in the constitution. Just because he has managed successful development in his stare doesn't mean he should be the PM of a country that is proud of its diversity.

Sssshhhhhhhhhh .............keep quiet. Many here has sold their souls to the devil

 

[Mech]

Modi is great.......for gujarat. I do not want to see that retard within a 1000 mile radius of prime ministers office. Why a medieval party like BJP is still in existance today is beyond me. There are no justification for modis atrocities and those of BJP as a whole. India was, is and must always remain secular. Last time BJP came into power, they brought the threat of a whole friggin war right on our door steps.

I know all you hindu folks in the forum want to see BJP in power...but im thankful it will remain that way only in this forum.

Congress has done a whole load of good for our country and the people, except for occasional speed bumps. Now dont go ranting off about 2G scam. The minister was prosecuted.

 

[Mech]

You retards forget who saved the country back in the 90's. It was none other than manmohan who championed the reforms and started the progress we see today. Otherwise, we'd be t just another failed state.

 

[angeldust]

Okay I understand you guys want development but at what cost?? Selling your souls to the devil? This man is a bigoted criminal. End of story. India is a secular country, it was built from the ground up with this ideal, it is in the constitution. Just because he has managed successful development in his stare doesn't mean he should be the PM of a country that is proud of its diversity.

No right thinking Indian supports what happened in Gujarat under Modi's watch. Or in Delhi when Sikhs were killed under Rajiv Gandhi's. But the nation moved on with Rajiv Gandhi as PM. Why not Modi? Or do we get into technicalities of whether India post Indira's assassination was actually under Rajiv's watch? But then if we are into technicalities, the jury is still out on Modi too. Its not about what a few Indians on the forum here do with their souls. Its what the voters in the millions do at the ballot. And that is what really matters to every Indian for the next 5 years. I repeat. The future of India cannot be held hostage to its past. We learn and we move on. Democracy is about choice and self-determination. If India votes for Modi, then Modi leads India. It is the choice of the rest of the world to respect that decision or not, in how they choose individually to engage with India were that to happen. For Indians, the choice was made by themselves for themselves. And we would live with that moving forward.

 

[JanjaWeed]

Modi is great.......for gujarat. I do not want to see that retard within a 1000 mile radius of prime ministers office. Why is a medieval party like BJP still in existance today is beyond me. There are no justification for modis atrocities and those of BJP as a whole. India was, is and must always remain secular. Last time BJP came into power, they brought the threat whole friggin war right on our door steps.

I know all you hindu folks in the forum want to see BJP in power...but im thankful it will remain that way only in this forum.

Congress has done a whole load of good for our country and the people, except for occasional speed bumps. Now dont go ranting off about 2G scam. The minister was prosecuted.

you seems to be well versed with all the flaws that exists in modi & BJP. what you don't seems to realise is the fact that the so called 'secular' parties practicing a dangerous trend called reverse communalism, to which people fall prey without even knowing. So called secular parties practice a opportunistic 'reverse communalism' that has historically done innumerable harm to the nation & continues to undermine india's progress, security & stability.
when a 'secular' party starts communal mass mobilisation on emotional sectarian issues, they participate in a dangerous trend, contributing directly to the greater radicalisation of minority community. now.. this trend of 'reverse communalism' is more dangerous than the actual one, which people normally talk about!

 

[angeldust]

The fact is that Politics and Religion are joined at the hip. Politics is about ruling people. And that means you first need to get a grip on what really rules the masses - Religion. Both parties do it, so neither side has the right to act all sanctimonious about it - be it the Congress Muslim vote-bank politics or the BJP and its Hindutva/ Ram Rajya. Not that its ever going to stop either side from attempting to climb to the top of the ivory tower and denouncing the other. We need call a spade a spade and say it out aloud. India is truly secular not only because Muslims (and other minorities) want it , but because the Hindus do. It is not difficult to imagine modern India with close to three-quarters of a billion Hindus were that not the case. It is a fact of life and acknowledging it does not make anyone less of an Indian. It so happened that in 1947 till today, there was and continues to be mass buy-in amongst the Indian masses for the concept of secularism, and for that we are all responsible and can take equal credit for.

 

[Bizarre]

Time to wake upppppp Time to support BJP..