What's new

Why Peshawar attack drew more outrage over Assam

this is becoming a casteist, terrorist loving hindutva forum. from the censored thread

Why India’s media cares more about the massacre of Pakistani children than our own
assam.jpg

Indian tribal children react to camera at a relief camp at Tinsuti village in Sonitpur district(AP Photo/Anupam Nath)


This is the time of the year when millions across the globe pray for peace on earth. And no, this is not being said ironically. Surely, as the year winds down to a close, humanity can get together to celebrate the idea of peace, of hope, of compassion, no matter what one’s religious affiliations might be?

But this seems to be a futile wish.

Even as people prepare to celebrate, in various ways, the end of the year, a bloodbath once more engulfs this land. In Sonitpur and Kokrajhar districts of Assam, suspected National Democratic Front of Boroland(S) killed innocent villagers, mostly Adivasis, when they opened fire on Tuesday.

Among the dead were women and young children.

And then the terror, and inevitably, the retaliation. The newspapers have pictures of people fleeing their homes, their possessions in little bundles on their heads. There is grief in their eyes, and horror. Frail men, young and old, arm themselves with nothing more lethal than fragile, primitive bows and arrows, against the modern guns used against them.

The death toll is 72 and rising, and retaliatory attacks are taking place, as expected. In these, and in police firing, seven more have been killed, bringing the total so far to 79.

And so it goes, endlessly. Horror piled on horror.


Terror fatigue

Around the year, across the globe, there have been numerous deaths at the hands of terrorists. These come to us via the media. Some get worldwide coverage, as well they should. Earlier this month, sending chills up the spines of all were the pictures of the attack on schoolchildren in Peshawar, Pakistan. That was perhaps a new nadir in human depravity, though who knows, even that point might soon be breached.

But some others terror attacks, such as the ones in Kokrajhar and Sonitpur, have hardly been noticed by mainstream media. Even though these assaults are equally horrifying, and deserving of condemnation in the strongest terms. It is not that media coverage will alleviate the sufferings of the survivors. But there is the hope that perhaps, if the rest of the world comes to know of it, there will be awareness of what is going on. And through awareness, perhaps, there will come condemnation, and ultimately, a refusal to tolerate this kind of terrorist attack by the larger communities of the world, in future.

And yes, it is a sorry thing when we weigh “gravity” and “importance” of the horrors around us, to allocate space in our papers and our electronic media. A violent death by a terrorist attack brings trauma and untold grief and misery in its wake, crippling the survivors and scarring them for life. But there is, today, a kind of “terror fatigue” which ensures that only the most gut-wrenching acts of terrorisms make it to the consciousness of the world. The other, numerous deaths by terrorist acts remain in the local media. There seems to be a hierarchy in this matter. This is a very sad, but very true fact of life.

This is a wretched commentary indeed on the state of the world today. Has civilisation reached such a low point that horrific acts must now jostle with each other for media space, each one more terrifying than the last?

We see that body counts matter, even in the space allocated to the news of deaths by terror attacks.

We see that location matters. A large number of deaths in a remote area, considered peripheral by the “mainstream”, merits less space than fewer numbers in a place deemed to be more “central”, therefore more “important”.

We see also that economic status matters. The rich, and the middle class get more media space if they become the victims of these attacks. As for the poor – well, even as pictures of lines of them fleeing their burning homes stream into our drawing rooms, one face merges into the next, one scream of terror begins to sound very much like another.

And that, too, is another aspect of the horrors of the times that we live in.
 
.
-No Kailash Sathyarthi saying take me hostage and spare the kids.
-No Malala condemning the killing of children -No hashtags like the ones we had seen during the Peshawar attack -Headlines which state outrage in Assam and not outrage in India.
-No candle light marches outside the India Gate
-No SMS campaigns on television seeking support for the victims Irony: Peshawar attack vs Assam attack

All this despite the death count in Assam shooting up to 82 of which 23 were women and 18 very innocent children whose lives were cut off even before they could even understand what this world is about. Were the victims not high profile:

The Peshawar attack was no doubt a horrific one and while we must completely condemn the killings in all possible ways, one must also not forget that what happened in Assam was nothing short of barbaric. The problem is that the victims were Advasis who do not fit the definition of the up market people. Does this incident not hurt the conscience of the so-called conscience keepers of the nation who are outraged?
Irony: Peshawar attack vs Assam attack When the Peshwar attack is took place, there were scores of hashtags supporting the victims and families. While there is no harm in raising ones' voice against meaningless violence a though ought to be spared for the children who lost their lives in Assam as well. they were as innocent as those kids in Peshawar.


More outrage during the exodus:
When there was a massive exodus two years back when students left various cities to return home there was such a major outrage across the nation. People came out in the open expressing solidarity and there were several debates condemning those who were rumour mongering in a bid to scare away these people. While every incident attempting to terrorise people needs to be condemned in a big way the idea is not to be selective while doing so. Cause is fine, but why kill? There are various explanations that have been given and the reasons explained for this attack. However under no circumstance can violence be justified whether it is killing a man, woman or child. The allegation against the tribals by the militants is that they had been supporting the security forces and hence this was one of the reasons for the attack-the other one being it was revenge. However this attack was more to demonstrate the strength of the organization which was dwindling in numbers.

An outfit which started off with 3500 people has just around 400 today. Moreover there was a new set of cadres who had come back from Myanmar after training. The intelligence says that they had to show their capability and ensure that terror is spread. Only by spreading terror can are such forces relevant. State has failed, centre needs to act: The Union Government has decided to take up this issue very seriously. It is clear that the state government has failed and even when concentrating its own security, it did so in expected areas.

Since yesterday the Assam police have been saying that they had focused on the Muslim dominated areas instead and there was hardly any presence of security personnel in the tribal belts that were hit. For the union government it is big a challenge ahead and it needs to bring all the groups under one roof and get them to talk before finding a lasting solution to the problem. The home minister will visit Assam which is under red alert and take stock of the situation before returning and discussing the issue with the Prime Minister and the National Security Advisor.
@oye_natta

Why Peshawar attack drew more outrage over Assam - Oneindia

First time I am hearing about this incident, even nothing in the news about this....my deepest condolences and may the dead rest in peace.
But its all about media coverage.
 
.
We are talking about Indians. Indians felt more bad than Pakistanis it seems. There were condolences messages on every electronic and social media stating how those terrorists could kill those cute and fair children.


Yes who were killed by Christian Bodo terrorists.

Btw I am going to post a thread on real religious demographics of India. Do post in there.

Thanks to all Pakistan obsessive Indians who showed support for Pak and ignored similar massacre in their own country.

We are talking about Indians. Indians felt more bad than Pakistanis it seems. There were condolences messages on every electronic and social media stating how those terrorists could kill those cute and fair children.


Yes who were killed by Christian Bodo terrorists.

Btw I am going to post a thread on real religious demographics of India. Do post in there.

Thanks to all Pakistan obsessive Indians who showed support for Pak and ignored similar massacre in their own country.
 
.
i
Because Peshwar attack was done by Muslims, the Western mainstream media don't post about other terrorist acts but those committed by the Muslims. If those people were killed by any Islamist groups, there would be plenty of condemning from Western media, there would be hash tags on Twitter, Obama would make a speech of how it was inhumane and must be dealt with an iron fist.
f they are Muslims then, I'm not and if I'm Muslim then they are not. Case closed, :pakistan::pakistan: btw, I'm Pakistani by religion..
 
.
We are talking about Indians. Indians felt more bad than Pakistanis it seems. There were condolences messages on every electronic and social media stating how those terrorists could kill those cute and fair children.


Yes who were killed by Christian Bodo terrorists.

Btw I am going to post a thread on real religious demographics of India. Do post in there.

Agreed Mujahid....I am also wondering there are times then both of us can be on the same page...This is the beauty of India....Honestly...It is dispointing for me we are so hyped up for Pakistan masacre...but even i do not find this news as a headline news on that same day in any indian news paper too...This is to so tragedy of us...
 
.
also, It depends on what media gives the full attention to.. like in Pakistan Thar desert, over 230 children has been submitted to death by Sindh govt's negligence ... and no one has been punished or even inquired for those poor children... who should I blame ? :(
 
.
I have a regret to say that most of us not even paid our condolences in first post before jumping into hot debate including me... I would like to express my sincerest sympathy for those ill fated Indians n their families... May all RIP .....Indian Media ROT IN HELL, you ppl ran thousands hr of chit chat show over Peshawar attack however now it seems mourning tears dried up for your own Indians .... I equally blame the ppl of this country for being insensitive/oblivion to the pain of our own ppl, no one is running twitter trend for Assamese who lost their families .... Certainly double standards of my own country men.....
 
.
Agreed Mujahid....I am also wondering there are times then both of us can be on the same page...This is the beauty of India....Honestly...It is dispointing for me we are so hyped up for Pakistan masacre...but even i do not find this news as a headline news on that same day in any indian news paper too...This is to so tragedy of us...
Media ignored them for a reason. Bodo terrorists were Christians! Terrorism by Christians in North-east is always ignored by the media.

India media isn't a sovereign entity.

Baptist Church Funds CNN IBN.Gospel of Charity Funds NDTV.Christian Council Funds TIMES.Joshua Society Funds The Hindu.
 
.
I think Bodos were influenced by the Taliban attack.
 
.
Media ignored them for a reason. Bodo terrorists were Christians! Terrorism by Christians in North-east is always ignored by the media.

India media isn't a sovereign entity.

Baptist Church Funds CNN IBN.Gospel of Charity Funds NDTV.Christian Council Funds TIMES.Joshua Society Funds The Hindu.

Or may be we did not value the life of the poor advasis as of now...It is our own low..
 
.
Well i think we should not compare both incident with each other. Both were barbaric and horrific events and highly condemnable regardless of its scale and numbers.
 
.
Media ignored them for a reason. Bodo terrorists were Christians! Terrorism by Christians in North-east is always ignored by the media.

India media isn't a sovereign entity.

Baptist Church Funds CNN IBN.Gospel of Charity Funds NDTV.Christian Council Funds TIMES.Joshua Society Funds The Hindu.

I always doubt your credentials of being muslim. Christians are our brothers and people of the book, yet you support them over pagans?
 
.
It is pretty simple. Indian obsession with Pakistan. Anything bad inside Pakistan would always draw a lot of attention from India. Who cares what happened in Assam. a lone dead soldier in occupied Kashmir would mean more thanks to Pakistan connection with the conflict.
 
Last edited:
.
This is a perfect example of what is wrong with India. Imagine if twitter and facebook and online news sources were there in 1990s when IA was killing Muslims in Kashmir enmass.........India is so hell bent on it's fetish with Pakistan, that it doesn't realize the fire burning on its own soil.

And then they dream about becoming a superpower.

Take a clue from this that a very important news outlet in India had this as their headline after the Peshawar attack:

'Has Pakistan's own demons come back to haunt them?'

Yet they are more informed about warrants related to Hafiz Saeed and Dawood Ibrahim.......i wonder who they are going to blame the Assam violence on? Bangladesh i suppose or ISI through Dhaka.

What a messed up nation, that is why i would like to visit India once in my lifetime along with North Korea.
 
.
Sad but that's what sells In India

No one wants to hear about Bodo militants attacking Indians! Indians are pure and selfless, it's not like they are occupying Bodoland and helping tribal militant groups to kill illegal Bangladeshis!


A more juicy headline for Indians is the Taliban in Pakistan. all the Indians can blame it on double game and say karma for 26/11

So then what was the massacre in Assam karma Too?
 
.
Back
Top Bottom