W.11
BANNED
- Joined
- Jan 20, 2011
- Messages
- 15,032
- Reaction score
- -32
- Country
- Location
The video saying that Pakistan was a british creation and pakistan's geography is artificial doesnt know much about modern states and how they came into being and their history.
The entire region was called ''Sindh'', The borders of the kingdom of Sindh included regions like bolan pass/Queutta, makran, kandahar in the westm, kashmir in the north and its eastern borders met Kannauj.
this is well attested in records made by Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang and the arabic records of the kingdom of chach. Even before that, Hou Hanshu mentions the country of Indus in the first centuries AD. So modern state of Pakistan definitely existed in some form way before the British made it one, the kingdom of ranjeet singh was also the principle entity which invaded and conquered the KPK and FATA (hence modern day border between pakistan and afghanistan, even before that swat and kabul served as the terminus point of the indian subcontinent, faxian even calls swat as terminus of northern india) and the northern baltistan areas and up up towards ladakh even before the british came into the picture, the mughals had already ruled and governed balochistan so the eastern balochistan boundary was already well defined before british and the iranians only held the western part of balochistan, king akber defeated the persians and ruled till modern day kandahar as the frontier post of the mughal empire. The khyber pass and valley of kabul was considered as the transitional point or border passage between india and west/central asia.
Even during the british empire, it were ''muslims of indin subcontinent'' who had proposed a north western muslim majority autonomous region'' and was certainly not proposed by the british.
the only credit which goes to the british was demarcating the line which separated india from pakistan, entire sindh province was included and only the division of punjab was made by them, rest of the states fell directly under historical boundaries which were well established even befoore the british arrived at the scene.
regards
The entire region was called ''Sindh'', The borders of the kingdom of Sindh included regions like bolan pass/Queutta, makran, kandahar in the westm, kashmir in the north and its eastern borders met Kannauj.
this is well attested in records made by Chinese pilgrim Xuanzang and the arabic records of the kingdom of chach. Even before that, Hou Hanshu mentions the country of Indus in the first centuries AD. So modern state of Pakistan definitely existed in some form way before the British made it one, the kingdom of ranjeet singh was also the principle entity which invaded and conquered the KPK and FATA (hence modern day border between pakistan and afghanistan, even before that swat and kabul served as the terminus point of the indian subcontinent, faxian even calls swat as terminus of northern india) and the northern baltistan areas and up up towards ladakh even before the british came into the picture, the mughals had already ruled and governed balochistan so the eastern balochistan boundary was already well defined before british and the iranians only held the western part of balochistan, king akber defeated the persians and ruled till modern day kandahar as the frontier post of the mughal empire. The khyber pass and valley of kabul was considered as the transitional point or border passage between india and west/central asia.
Even during the british empire, it were ''muslims of indin subcontinent'' who had proposed a north western muslim majority autonomous region'' and was certainly not proposed by the british.
the only credit which goes to the british was demarcating the line which separated india from pakistan, entire sindh province was included and only the division of punjab was made by them, rest of the states fell directly under historical boundaries which were well established even befoore the british arrived at the scene.
regards
Last edited:
