Why Pakistan MUST consider Afghan civilians as its own

[RescueRanger]

@TMA it is crucial to distinguish between those Afghans who hate us, and the ones who don't.

People living near our borders would gladly join us if we provide them a better future. Using that as a template, we can keep extending our influence throughout Afghanistan.

Afghans realize they NEED Pakistan. I know this by talking to a few here in Sydney. In order to get their papers for Australia, they need to travel across the border. It usually involves paying bribes to border guards, or sneaking into Iran then crossing over into Pakistan. But they realize they wouldn't get anywhere without us and they only have good memories of Pakistan regarding how they were treated here.

The fact of the matter is that 20 years ago, there was no PA on the border and no one in Afghanistan hated us. Along came an anti-Pakidtsn government in Kabul and

Been to Afghanistan, worked with Afghans and let me tell you, their impression of Pakistan is purely a negative one. Despite us hosting generation after generation of them since the 1980s.

 

[CriticalThought]

Been to Afghanistan, worked with Afghans and let me tell you, their impression of Pakistan is purely a negative one. Despite us hosting generation after generation of them since the 1980s.

And what are we doing to change this negative perception?

 

[Maarkhoor]

And what are we doing to change this negative perception?

It is in their genes to bite the who feeds them, read the history whenever and whoever wants to help them they bites back. We should maintain safe distance between us and cursed land and it's citizens.

 

[H!TchHiker]

https://twitter.com/x/status/926534039648993280

..

There is another one who demand the same studied in Peshawar and working in Khyber TV, born and educated in Pakistan does not wish to leave but break away part of Pakistan..I think you agree with both of them

https://twitter.com/x/status/929607668398002176

[/QUOTE]
Whats your thoughts about them ? @CriticalThought both born and raised in Pakistan and wish sanctions on Pakistan to the extent of breaking it

 

[CriticalThought]

It is in their genes to bite the who feeds them, read the history whenever and whoever wants to help them they bites back. We should maintain safe distance between us and cursed land and it's citizens.

Why didn't we need to do the same 20 years ago?

 

[RescueRanger]

And what are we doing to change this negative perception?

I am an old man, I worked in the Muhajir camps when I was in college trying to do just that! In the 90's. giving free medicine and food and clothes and even helping some get in school or jobs by pestering my family. We never got any good will out of it in return.

Please don't ask what we have done to change this perception, we kept them on our soil for 30+ years, no more!

 

[Babur The Uzbek Tiger]

Pakistan should have invaded Afghanistan during the Soviet war there and taken all of these nomadic Pashtun lands in the south. Pakistan also should have taken back Kashmir by painting India as a heavily deluded Soviet ally and the west would not have been able to say anything. Pakistan suffers from an inability to project its interests. The PR capabilities are nonexistent. This points to heavy nepotism and corruption at the very top.

 

[RescueRanger]

Why didn't we need to do the same 20 years ago?

See my above post to answer that question! Cheers!

 

[Maarkhoor]

Why didn't we need to do the same 20 years ago?

That was mistake and it is not necessary to repeat the mistake or live with that, learn from past and made correct decision for future.
Afghanistan is a hell hole will not became peaceful till youm e qayama and it's citizens / politician / armed forces are now stooges of R&AW, we should send them back and we can send them aid their but we don't need them in Pakistan since they are security risk, if they are not deported then prepare more coffins for our soldiers and officers along with civilians.

 

[CriticalThought]

https://twitter.com/x/status/926534039648993280

..

There is another one who demand the same studied in Peshawar and working in Khyber TV, born and educated in Pakistan does not wish to leave but break away part of Pakistan..I think you agree with both of them

https://twitter.com/x/status/929607668398002176

Whats your thoughts about them ? @CriticalThought both born and raised in Pakistan and wish sanctions on Pakistan to the extent of breaking it[/QUOTE]

Yes Alhamdulillah born and bred in Pakistan. And you are simply cherry picking some of the worst examples that Afghanistan can present.

That was mistake and it is not necessary to repeat the mistake or live with that, learn from past and made correct decision for future.
Afghanistan is a hell hole will not became peaceful till youm e qayama and it's citizens / politician / armed forces are now stooges of R&AW, we should send them back and we can send them aid their but we don't need them in Pakistan since they are security risk, if they are not deported then prepare more coffins for our soldiers and officers along with civilians.

You are misunderstanding my intentions. I want us to treat them like our civilians during operations in Afghanistan to lay down the groundwork for the eventuality where Afghanistan will simply be a province of Pakistan.

 

[Maarkhoor]

Whats your thoughts about them ? @CriticalThought both born and raised in Pakistan and wish sanctions on Pakistan to the extent of breaking it

[QUOTE="Yes Alhamdulillah born and bred in Pakistan. And you are simply cherry picking some of the worst examples that Afghanistan can present.[/QUOTE]

Pakistan should learn from this little boy and treat Afghanis same way.

 

[CriticalThought]

I am an old man, I worked in the Muhajir camps when I was in college trying to do just that! In the 90's. giving free medicine and food and clothes and even helping some get in school or jobs by pestering my family. We never got any good will out of it in return.

Please don't ask what we have done to change this perception, we kept them on our soil for 30+ years, no more!

Until 2001 we has no problems from Afghanistan. What have we done since to counter the poisonous propaganda of the Kabul government?

 

[El Sidd]

You are misunderstanding my intentions. I want us to treat them like our civilians during operations in Afghanistan to lay down the groundwork for the eventuality where Afghanistan will simply be a province of Pakistan.

why can you not understand that Afghan way of life is completely different to Pakistani way of living?

You look at the world with Koala eyes that everything will be cuddly loving orgy if we do that

 

[fitpOsitive]

Afghan problem is not ending soon so let's start by giving nationality to those Afghan Muhajireen who are interested in getting it

Every afghani, including Abdullah Abdullah, will be interested in such a move.

 

[H!TchHiker]

Until 2001 we has no problems from Afghanistan. What have we done since to counter the poisonous propaganda of the Kabul government?

Did they accept Pakistan with its boundaries officially until 2001 ?or Not ?

Whats your thoughts about them ? @CriticalThought both born and raised in Pakistan and wish sanctions on Pakistan to the extent of breaking it

Yes Alhamdulillah born and bred in Pakistan. And you are simply cherry picking some of the worst examples that Afghanistan can present.

[/QUOTE]
I am giving the example of most educated one at the expense of Pakistani students...Rest will be far more then them if this is what educated ones have to say..I am sure you have never been to Afghanistan ...