What's new

Why Pakistan is still undecided about sending troops to fight in Yemen

More pakistan delays.... better for your country... why fight and die for others...
I think if there is one thing our parliamentarians are good at then it is at having never ending discussions without coming to a conclusion. Delaying by discussion is a task made in heaven for them hence :D
 
. .
wow! KSA is attacking on yemen, yemen is not attacking KSA..
this era is digital.
Genius first get your facts right KSA is attacking rebels who are trying to topple government on Gun Point Yemeni Government supports Saudi action against rebels
 
. .
If we send troops india will invade Pakistan.Due to low presence..
You are really a kid , if we send some numbers of troops in ksa , so that doesnot mean the rest of army in Pakistan is sleeping , Or they are not aware of any threat from india ,
 
.
Pakistan has to decide and decide soon and in favor of Saudi Arabia. When 1979 Kaba siege happened and rumors were spread that Jews have attacked Kaba on very same day people attacked and burned down USA embassy, and if today war enters Saudi Borders Pakistan and entire Muslim world will be on fire can't let that happen we have to go in

Pakistan doesn't have to side with anyone. What it has to do is stay neutral. The war won't enter Saudi borders and the Houties don't want this either.
 
Last edited:
.
ISLAMABAD, Pakistan — War-weary Pakistani lawmakers are balking at committing troops to the Saudi-led campaign against Iranian-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen, complicating efforts by Saudi Arabia to build a broad coalition for a possible ground offensive.

On Wednesday, for the third consecutive day, Pakistan’s Parliament debated whether to send troops, and perhaps aircraft and ships, to the Arabian Peninsula in support of one of the country’s closest allies.

Over the past four decades, the 550,000-member (642.892) :tsk: Pakistani army has repeatedly dispatched forces to Saudi Arabia to back a strategic alliance between the two Sunni-dominated nations. But the latest request from Saudi Arabia is prompting strong opposition from several major Pakistani political parties, reflecting the country’s fatigue with armed conflict as well as unease over whether events in Yemen could further inflame sectarian tensions in the Muslim world.

“Saudi Arabia has always supported Pakistan, but is Saudi Arabia’s territorial integrity under threat?” Muzaffar Hussain Shah, a senator from the Pakistan Muslim League-F, asked on the floor of Parliament. “The answer is no. There is unanimity in this house that Pakistan can’t become part of this war. It’s not our war.”

When the Saudi air campaign in Yemen began two weeks ago, it appeared that Pakistani Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif would commit forces to support the Saudi government.




Saudi airstrikes in Yemen

As in Saudi Arabia, Sunni Muslims are the overwhelming majority in Pakistan. Oil-rich Saudi Arabia has provided extensive financial help to Pakistan over the years, including a $1.5 billion loan last year to shore up the faltering rupee. Sharif also has deep personal ties to Saudi Arabia, where he took refuge when he was ousted in a military coup during a previous term as prime minister in the late 1990s.

Yet, in recent days, even Sharif has appeared to be recalculating the risks of entangling Pakistani troops in the crisis in Yemen.

Although Pakistan’s constitution gives the prime minister complete control over the armed forces, Sharif said this week that he first wants the blessing of Parliament, where debates have been known to drag on for months.

And while that deliberation continues, Sharif has been signaling that he plans to work with allies such as Turkey, which also has been reluctant to commit troops, to try to defuse tensions in Yemen.

Sharif’s government appeared Wednesday to step back even further from a troop commitment when Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif arrived in Islamabad for two days of meetings with Pakistani leaders. Zarif, who is leading a 22-member Iranian delegation, urged Pakistani leaders to remain neutral in the conflict and instead work toward a cease-fire.


“It’s important for all of us to reach understanding that war is not a solution to the problem, so stop the bombardment, stop ground operation, allow humanitarian assistance, start talking and reach a peaceful settlement,” Zarif said after he met with Sartaj Aziz, Pakistan’s national security adviser.


Although there has been past tension in Pakistan’s relationship with neighboring Iran, Pakistani leaders fear a war in Yemen could be a distraction from efforts to finalize a nuclear agreement between Iran and a bloc of nations led by the United States. That deal could bolster Pakistan’s security by sparing it another nuclear-armed neighbor. The lifting of international sanctions on Iran also could expedite a planned gas pipeline between Iran and Pakistan.


Hasan Askari Rizvi, a security analyst based in Islamabad, said there is a broad desire in Pakistan that the military not be distracted from its battle against Islamist militants in the northwestern part of the country.

Pakistan’s military also remains uneasy about possible conflict with arch rival India along the country’s eastern border. And there are concerns that an extended military operation in Yemen against the Shiite Houthis could exacerbate tensions between Sunnis and Pakistan’s Shiite minority.

In a speech to Parliament on Wednesday, Shireen Mazari of the Movement for Justice party sought to draw parallels to Pakistan’s support for U.S.-led military operations in Afghanistan.

“In the past, we fought for the United States in Afghanistan against the Soviets, and post-9/11, we fought another war for the U.S. by opening our country for the American army, CIA and Blackwater,” said Mazari, apparently referring to Pakistan’s decision to allow U.S. military hardware to be transported through Pakistan in the military campaign against the Taliban in the aftermath of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. “We are suffering because of all of that.”

Still, with Sharif’s Pakistan Muslim League-N holding a solid majority in the assembly and the Senate, Rizvi said Parliament still may eventually endorse sending some troops to help Saudi Arabia. But Rizvi said he suspects lawmakers will seek to limit the scope of the operation.

“It might be very vague, such as saying Pakistan will protect Saudi Arabia’s holy places,” Rizvi said.


In the meantime, Pakistan is continuing efforts to rescue thousands of its citizens who are trapped in Yemen. In a rare instance of cooperation between Pakistan and India, the two countries have even been rescuing each other’s citizens.

Eleven Indian nationals arrived home Wednesday night after Pakistan’s navy rescued them along with 171 Pakistani nationals from the southern city of Mokallah in Yemen.

“They’ve taken great trouble to do something, and we need to appreciate that,” India’s foreign secretary, S. Jaishankar, told reporters. “We approach this whole issue as an opportunity to really cooperate with each other.”

Over the past week, India’s air force and navy also have rescued 4,000 Indian nationals and more than 500 foreigners from 32 countries, including three Pakistanis and a dozen U.S. citizens, officials said.



Annie Gowen in New Delhi contributed to this report.

Why Pakistan is still undecided about sending troops to fight in Yemen - The Washington Post

At least good news, we are NOT siding with either Saudi Arabia and Iran.

Pakistan is growing to mature and right thinking in right time, not longer baby with bottle.
 
.
Genius first get your facts right KSA is attacking rebels who are trying to topple government on Gun Point Yemeni Government supports Saudi action against rebels

but Pakistan forces are not in position to involve in sectarian or rebel war, we are already in state of chaos. KSA got its army, weapons and most important their friends "Israel and USA". Participating in this war is ridiculous.
 
. .
No troops.

Dispatch Marines, Frigates, Subs & Jets. Contributing is important but we need our Army at home front.

Yaar what are you thinking?? We don't need to contribute anything to Middle East Crisis..... [ except we can buy Tu-95 Bear from Russia to monitor them and return back home. :D ]

Please read important bold parts below.

"In a speech to Parliament on Wednesday, Shireen Mazari of the Movement for Justice party sought to draw parallels to Pakistan’s support for U.S.-led military operations in Afghanistan.

“In the past, we fought for the United States in Afghanistan against the Soviets, and post-9/11, we fought another war for the U.S. by opening our country for the American army, CIA and Blackwater,” said Mazari, apparently referring to Pakistan’s decision to allow U.S. military hardware to be transported through Pakistan in the military campaign against the Taliban in the aftermath of the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001. “We are suffering because of all of that.”
"
 
.
First of all if you see Iranians here like me @Serpentine , @Daneshmand or everybody else trying to prove that its a bad decision for Pakistan to go to war on another muslim country , it's not because we really care .

10 Arab countries are already engaged in bombing Ansarallah for their revolution , adding Pakistan to it doesn't actually change anything .....

This decisive storm was not even a DECISIVE BREEZE till now . so spare us your fantacy .

Its cause Pakistan is our neighbor and what affects pakistan DIRECTLY - and not even indirectly - affects Iran .

Secondly , fortunately the parliament of pakistan has more people like @waz and @haviZsultan and less people like @OTTOMAN and @Zarvan .
 
.
Its due to the fact that we have terrorists and traitors in media and parliament. Same people who said do talks with talibans and military action is not solution. Secondly Pakistan don't need to announce publicaly about military support to Kingdom. A lot is happening behind the scenes since Zia's era.
 
.
I still believe a force of some kind will be sent to Saudi Arabia but their will be clear red lines of them staying within Saudi territory
I don't think they need our Air Force with the kind of toys they have nor we should involve ourselves in bombing missions in a foreign Muslim country
An outright NO to Saudi demands is unlikely but we have to balance it with in no way putting our soldiers in any kind of danger
 
.
They have to choose between SA and Iran

How about just supplying both with nukes and telling them to wipe each other from the map? Imagine that.

Our decision to enter to war (or not) will ultimate depend on the pros and cons. If we do support the Saudis, it is most definitely because we're getting something out of it.
 
.
Why the need for that?
Dont you think the Arabs can handle it on their own?

Really? If the House of Saud could have handled the situation they would have deployed their ground troops into Yemen already. This isn't a Shock and Awe by the airstrikes. The Houthis knew the Saudis were going to come after them, because they want a different Shia as the leader of Yemen.

Genius first get your facts right KSA is attacking rebels who are trying to topple government on Gun Point Yemeni Government supports Saudi action against rebels

The Houthis are a faction of Shia who are 1/3 of Yemen's population. They were in continuous rebellion against the government since 64. The rebel leader was killed in 2004. And a truce was agreed to in 2011 with Yemeni President for 32 years Ali Abdullah Saleh.

The Arab Spring came around and the Houthis allied with the entire population of Yemen for a new regime. One that would protect minority rights, provided economic growth, and government with elected officials. Ali Abdullah Saleh's appointed successor, General Abd Rabbuh Mansur Hadi, wanted a federation of 6 states. Which would have divided the political groups against each other and only have helped the General.

The Houthis rebelled and gained support from units in the Yemeni Military. Confirmed reports are that units that were loyal to Ali Abdullah Saleh are fighting with the Houthis, and uncornfirmed report that US trained Yemeni Special Forces sided with the Houthis also. As do the majority of Yemeni citizens, who are sick of Gen. Hadi.

In January Gen. Abd Rabbuh Mansur Hadi resigned as President of Yemen, the Houthis then captured him in Sanaa and named a new transitional 5 member presidential council. Gen. Hadi was able to escape to Aden and to give the middle finger to the Houthis spread wide claims and reinstated himself as the President of Yemen. Now he's in Saudi Arabia.

There is no confirmed reports that Iran is supporting the Houthis, other than Gen. Hadi saying that Iran is supporting the Houthi once he landed in Saudi Arabia.

You Mr. @Zarvan are not informed of the Yemeni Crisis. :enjoy:
 
.

Latest posts

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom