Why Kerala has no beef with beef.

[Screambowl]

Please do not even compare Advaita Vedanta with Islam. The concepts are entirely different. Way different.

hahahahahaha

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

well that was true, Quran was revealed to him through meditation, but Arabs well you know, they are still following Jahaliya culture.

I do not believe that Quran was "revealed" so its pointless to tell me that. If you believe it, its your problem.

 

[Screambowl]

I do not believe that Quran was "revealed" so its pointless to tell me that. If you believe it, its your problem.

I don't believe that, but that is what my argument is with the muslims. That he became Paigambar after meditating not reading Quran. But What they have as an interpretation is just '' chosen one''

 

[Bitter Melon]

1. We will criticize Pakistan or Bangladesh to death if tomorrow they ban idol worship, no?

2. I don't want my country to be categorized with Saudi Arabia in the matter of religious freedom.

3. Beef should just be treated as food, not a religious matter, at least as long as we are killings rats and snakes, and eating duck meat.



What next? We will also kill the Muslims by stoning?

1. Yes, we ought to criticize if they ban Idol Worship, because it is violative of our religion. Beef ban is not violative of their religion. It is not compulsory to eat beef nor is it a pillar of Islam.
2. India is far from being Saudi Arabia in matters of religious freedom. Eating beef is not religious freedom and you are barking up the wrong tree if you claim beef is what Islam or Christianity is all about.
3. Beef is not just food. It is intrinsic part of Hindu religion and culture. There is prohibition on its killing and that will be followed.

4. Well you put an argument that we should ban idol worship which I believe is very distasteful for a Bengali like you, aspiring monotheist that you guys tend to be, and I was only countering that. If idols could be banned in India, then I do not see the harm in banning Islam either. Rather it becomes compulsory. See I do not want our country to turn into Saudi Arabia either.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

I don't believe that, but that is what my argument is with the muslims. That he became Paigambar after meditating not reading Quran. But What they have as an interpretation is just '' chosen one''

That argument can be made only if you want to find some common ground and want to prevent muslims from attacking the Hindu faith.

Otherwise there really is no need to cook up a story as to how muhammed knew what he knew.

I happen to think that the common ground is India and our culture, not any fantastic claim about muhammed knowing yoga. (which he very well MAY have know, but it is unlikely)

 

[Screambowl]

That argument can be made only if you want to find some common ground and want to prevent muslims from attacking the Hindu faith.

Otherwise there really is no need to cook up a story as to how muhammed knew what he knew.

I happen to think that the common ground is India and our culture, not any fantastic claim about muhammed knowing yoga. (which he very well MAY have know, but it is unlikely)

No, I am more into interpretation of Islam. They should rather meditate in cave than following what is written in Book. That's how Mohammad became the paigamber (enlightened), he did not read any book.

 

[Bitter Melon]

Really??
So what would a poor farmer do when his cow gets old?? any suggestions??
But hey who cares about a poor farmer, all we care about is religion.
Had they banned beef for purely economic reasons, I would've supported it.

Ohh, bleeding heart liberal with so much concern for old cows and poor farmers. Well all the farmer has to do is let go of the cow, it forages and gets enough food for itself from the left over stalks of harvested grains, roadside weeds and grass and bushes. If you had read the research paper I provided you, you would have known that the farmer hardly spends any money on feeding his cattle in India. They feed on their natural surroundings. Also the economics of having a cow around were discussed here many times at length in many many threads. Me suspects your husband being a cow eater has much to do with your support for cow slaughter than economics.

hahahahahaha

Yes, they are way different. Having an unseen god is not a concept.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

No, I am more into interpretation of Islam. They should rather meditate in cave than following what is written in Book. That's how Mohammad became the paigamber (enlightened), he did not read any book.

You are viewing it like a hindu and are making a mistake of thinking Islam is like Hinduism.

Muhammed has asked them to follow his words written down in the quran. They are not required or even allowed to meditate and find god themselves and god forbid become a prophet themselves. Muhammed was pretty explicit about that.

HE IS THE LAST Prophet. Anyone else claiming to be one is to be put to death.

For a true muslim enlightenment is when he die and goes to "heaven". No other form of enlightenment is possible. If he believes it is possible, he is not a muslim and can be put to death for believing that. Do you get it ?

 

[Levina]

68 years of Communist rule is what mental conditioning you malayalis went through.
Same with West Bengal.That reinforced your idea that Hindus eat beef and it was normal in vedas.NO IT IS NOT!
Your land produced Adi Shankaracharya and how far you have fallen?

Adi Shankaracharya would 've never forced something on other ppl who belong to other religions, he did not do that in his life time. Au contraire he removed the ignorance of the people regarding what is right, what is wrong, what is real, what is unreal,the meaning and importance of prayers, how to lead a harmonious life etc.
Do you think he forced something on Buddhists or Jains?

Ohh, bleeding heart liberal with so much concern for old cows and poor farmers. Well all the farmer has to do is let go of the cow, it forages and gets enough food for itself from the left over stalks of harvested grains, roadside weeds and grass and bushes. If you had read the research paper I provided you, you would have known that the farmer hardly spends any money on feeding his cattle in India. They feed on their natural surroundings. Also the economics of having a cow around were discussed here many times at length in many many threads.

So you too don't have a solution to it other than blabbering about it.

Me suspects your husband being a cow eater has much to do with your support for cow slaughter than economics.

Spot on!!!

 

[SpArK]

Adi Shankaracharya would 've never forced something on other religions, he did not do that in his life time. Au contraire he removed the ignorance of the people regarding what is right, what is wrong, what is real, what is unreal,the meaning and importance of prayers, how to lead a harmonious life etc.
Do you think he forced something on Buddhists or Jains?


So you too don't have a solution to it other than blabbering about it.

Spot on!!!

Oiii.. 68 years of communist rule?

I never knew congress, were communists....my Bad.

 

[Bitter Melon]

well that was true, Quran was revealed to him through meditation, but Arabs well you know, they are still following Jahaliya culture.

Nah. Jahaliya culture was far more advanced than the culture they have today. Ancient Arabia was far more liberal, so was Persia.

So you too don't have a solution to it other than blabbering about it.

I gave the solution. Cannot help it if a cow living its life naturally is painful for you and you would rather see it dead.

 

[MokshaVimukthi]

Nah. Jahaliya culture was far more advanced than the culture they have today. Ancient Arabia was far more liberal, so was Persia.

As a matter of fact that is true. Islamic culture and Arab culture was FAR more civilized than the barbaric western "culture".

Probably because of trade links between Persia and India.

 

[Levina]

I gave the solution. Cannot help it if a cow living its life naturally is painful for you and you would rather see it dead.

Thats called resource utilization!!!

 

[Bitter Melon]

Thats called resource utilization!!!

It is called as psychopathy.

 

[Screambowl]

Nah. Jahaliya culture was far more advanced than the culture they have today. Ancient Arabia was far more liberal, so was Persia.

culture still remain.. with pinch of Islam and now they are confused.