Why Don't Indian Muslims Emigrate to Pakistan?

[Alpha Fighter]

It can be as ridiculous as lynching people for eating beef or simple as discriminating against them in all walks of life . Have a look at this . In Mumbai you discriminate for not giving houses to muslim's to rent or sale . How ridiculous is this?

http://www.thehindu.com/news/nation...i-a-no-rent-no-sale-policy/article3613986.ece

Many Muslims builders also only give flat to Muslims, so what......get respect , take respect. Well Didn't lynching didn't happened in PAK? , BTW lynching didn't happened over Beef, Lynching happened because stolen calf was found dead in his house.

Muslims live with dignity here . They don't have to worry about mad machette holding hindu mobs outside just because they are having mutton karahi .

Well dignified people just don't blow themselves.

it was the muslims fault in 47 to not migrate to pakistan,atleast they would not see this kind of discrimination against them in pakistan

MQM ? sound any bell , why is their so called Muhajirs then ?

 

[Khan_21]

Many Muslims builders also only give flat to Muslims, so what......get respect , take respect. Well Didn't lynching didn't happened in PAK? , BTW lynching didn't happened over Beef, Lynching happened because stolen calf was found dead in his house.



Well dignified people just don't blow themselves.

your BJP MNA is calling for punishment for a guy named akhlaq and his family who was lynched because he had consumed beef and had it in his refrigerator . Tell that to your MNA . Muslims are discriminated in jobs , housing , living conditions and everything from A-Z . Just look at the articles I posted .

Don't send them from Indian consulates in Afghanistan and they wont blow themselves up .

 

[nair]

Muslim discrimination is not just limited to beef incidents . Just look at the article I have posted above .

Well India is a country of 1.2 billion people, probably the only country in the world which has so much of diverse population, and that too in numbers......Now I agree that there are certain places where this discrimination happens, and I have come across issues where Hindu's are discriminated by Muslims, so what would Hindu's do?? Go to Nepal???? There is a mechanism which is there to take care of such issues...... Now let us take the Beef issue, You look at this as an issue, But did you notice the kind of attention it got and the kind of public out cry on this issue???? You did not, Because you saw what you wanted to see......

Well when you have such diverse population and that too in numbers living together in a country, it is bound to have such problems, It is not only mulsims which get discriminated, but other section of society too..... Slowly and steadily these issues are getting addressed and several of such issues will be resolved....... But If some one want quick fix solution then they can go to the heaven for Muslims ie : "Pakistan".....I dont think anyone will stop them.......

It is easy to create opinion based on few incidents in a country like India, I do know what i am talking because I lived in several part of the country.......

 

[Alpha Fighter]

your BJP MNA is calling for punishment for a guy named akhlaq and his family who was lynched because he had consumed beef and had it in his refrigerator . Tell that to your MNA . Muslims are discriminated in jobs , housing , living conditions and everything from A-Z . Just look at the articles I posted .

Don't send them from Indian consulates in Afghanistan and they wont blow themselves up .

you read too much false , secular news , get the real news and stay afresh.....

Muslims also do, but still has good life then PAK

 

[Mysticbuddy]

"One of the more intriguing nuggets about the Africa emigration story is that far from fleeing poverty, migrants out of the continent are likely to be relatively well off, and are rarely from the most destitute families
The above quote comes to mind when answering an oft-repeated question: "Why don't Indian Muslimswho seek to make their country 100% "Hindu Rashtra".

Indian Muslims Most Deprived:

Muslims in India are the most deprived among various groups. In majority in education, employment, housing and in the criminal justice system. They have significantly lower levels of development than their Hindu counterparts. So why don't they all migrate out of India?

Why Don't Indian Muslims Leave India?

This question of why don't all of the Muslims migrate out of India to Pakistan and other Muslim nations is most often asked by the Hindu Nationalists who seek to make their country 100% "Hindu Rashtra".

The question, however, does deserve an answer. And the answer is: Poorest and least developed people tend to stay put where they are; they do not migrate. It's only people who have a certain level of income and skills who are more likely to migrate to other countries for better opportunities. This fact has been well-established by multiple studies condu

"Results show that despite increase in the absolute number of migrants, Africa, particularly SubSaharan Africa has one of the lowest rate of emigration in the world .... Poorer countries generally have lower rate of emigration ......Bad socio-economic conditions generally seem to lead to higher rate of emigration by highly skilled individuals. Generally, migration is driven by motives to improve livelihoods with notable evidence on changes in labor market status. Often, self-employed or unemployed émigré ended up in wage employment. The paper outlines policy issues emerging from the migration trend in

Data shows that increased human and economic development is initially associated with increasing emigration. Any form of development in the poorest countries of the world is therefore likely to lead to accelerating emigration. Such findings contradict conventional thinking and force us to

It will be comparing Pakistanis moving to Afghanistan. Before you say anything, I am clarifying it's for immigration and not for terrorism.

 

[illusion8]

Why? Why?

The reasons are obvious. Who would leave India for Pakistan?

That said, there are restrictions on migration of this kind and they should be removed. Those who wishes to leave for any country should be allowed to.

They probably harbored hopes of migrating to pakistan in the early 60's or 70's to live in a pure Islamic state, but then, the state pakistan is and has become would have crushed a few of their hopes. Who would in their right minds would want to migrate to Pakistan from India?

Even the muslim mapallas of kerala who went to Pakistan post independence rushed back to kerala - many of them still haven't been returned their Indian citizenship.

Heck, even the so called tormented Kashmiris or the "beef eaters" do not think of going to Pakistan.

The OP reasoning is flawed. Minorities - Christians, Hindus, Sikhs, Ahmedis flee from pakistan the first chance they get till today. There are thousands of Sikhs and Hindus who are vying for Indian citizenship for years.

Pakistani Christians and Ahmedis are in their thousands in Sri Lanka, Thailand etc as refugees, while millions of Bangladeshi Muslim make their way to India.

 

[Khan_21]

you read too much false , secular news , get the real news and stay afresh.....

Muslims also do, but still has good life then PAK

In Pak no muslim will get killed over eating anything , will not get discriminated in jobs just because he is from a different sect , will have no housing issues , will live in posh areas unlike India where they are forced to live in ghettos .

It will be comparing Pakistanis moving to Afghanistan. Before you say anything, I am clarifying it's for immigration and not for terrorism.

The Income difference between India And Pak is minute and nowhere near Pak-Afghanistan where our income is thrice bigger then them . I will see it as an improvement because they will be coming from the poorest country in the world to a relatively less poverty stricken country .

Unlike India where money is in the hands of few elites , money is distributed much better here and that is why by percentage we have a bigger middle class. That's Economics for you .

They will be living in Posh areas here unlike the slums and ghettos of mumbai where they live now . That' housing for you.

As for Jobs they will be free to become CEO 's , business owners and have a much better lifestyle here then India . So I will see this as an upgrade for muslim's there if they come over to Pakistan .

 

[Alpha Fighter]

In Pak no muslim will get killed over eating anything , will not get discriminated in jobs just because he is from a different sect , will have no housing issues , will live in posh areas unlike India where they are forced to live in ghettos .

other get killed on other rumors aka blasphemy pretext.

The Income difference between India And Pak is minute and nowhere near Pak-Afghanistan where our income is thrice bigger then them . I will see it as an improvement because they will be coming from the poorest country in the world to a relatively less poverty stricken country .

Unlike India where money is in the hands of few elites , money is distributed much better here and that is why by percentage we have a bigger middle class. That's Economics for you .

They will be living in Posh areas here unlike the slums and ghettos of mumbai where they live now . That' housing for you.

As for Jobs they will be free to become CEO 's , business owners and have a much better lifestyle here then India . So I will see this as an upgrade for muslim's there if they come over to Pakistan .

lol, your becoming CEO u have to study and not madrasa edu work

how many Muslims from PAK become the CEO of MNC? be it google, Pepsi, etc?
how many Muslims from PAK work in Intel, Apple.

In India if u study , you can do anything, if u goto madrasa for free food, u end up in slumps, choice is yours, we cant force anyone.

many Muslims become president and on good post, but they educated, Abdul kalam

 

[Khan_21]

other get killed on other rumors aka blasphemy pretext.




lol, your becoming CEO u have to study and not madrasa edu work

how many Muslims from PAK become the CEO of MNC? be it google, Pepsi, etc?
how many Muslims from PAK work in Intel, Apple.

In India if u study , you can do anything, if u goto madrasa for free food, u end up in slumps, choice is yours, we cant force anyone.

many Muslims become president and on good post, but they educated, Abdul kalam

First comes roti , kapra , makaan and the CEO . Neither of those are available to them in India . They live in dirty ghettos in India and are discriminated everywhere . And seeing the slums in India even Somali's , Ethopian's will thank God they don't live there .

 

[Bombaywalla]

First comes roti , kapra , makaan and the CEO . Neither of those are available to them in India . They live in dirty ghettos in India and are discriminated everywhere . And seeing the slums in India even Somali's , Ethopian's will thank God they don't live there .

You really need to see the world for what it is, not for what you think it is.

 

[Indrajith]

if it was the economic situation --- just come and see the Muslims in Kerala , they are the most wealthiest & Influential there , however they are not treated second class like the Muhajirs of pakistan

 

[Stephen Cohen]

Lack of job and economic opportunities in Pakistan and the news that they read
about Mohajirs and MQM

 

[ravi gupta]

They coined that termed for themselves many still prefer to be called Urdu Speaking,Gujraris or Rajisthanis

Then why differentiate same way many Hindus migrated to INDIA but there is no any differentiation among those.
Or they have a seperate party or institution to represent them.

 

[liall]

it was the muslims fault in 47 to not migrate to pakistan,atleast they would not see this kind of discrimination against them in pakistan

But there is some discrimination against Indian muslims in Pakistan. There is even a word for them, Mujhahair is it?

 

[Sparkle229]

But there is some discrimination against Indian muslims in Pakistan. There is even a word for them, Mujhahair is it?

i was talking about those who stayed dumbass