Why does India have high academic plagiarism?
- Thread starter TaiShang
- Start date
TaiShang
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Apr 30, 2014
- Messages
- 27,848
- Reaction score
- 70
- Country
- Location
Academic Plagiarism Scores Hatrick in India!
November 26, 2014
Chandra Krishnamurthy
Chandra Krishnamurthy, the erstwhile Vice-Chancellor of National Law University Orissa & currently the Vice-Chancellor of Pondicherry University is the latest in the series of academics who have been accused of plagiarism. Earlier this month, Deepak Pental (Ex- Vice Chancellor of Delhi University) & Abhijit Chakrabarti (Vice- Chancellor of Jadavpur University) were accused of plagiarism. This makes Krishnamurthy the third academic in India to be accused of plagiarism in a single month.
It is alleged that Krishnamurthy in her book, ‘Legal Education in India’, lifted 5 out of 8 chapters from research papers written by legal luminary, N R Madhava Menon. Following this revelation, the Pondicherry University Teachers’ Association (Puta), the Students Federation of India (SFI) and former Puducherry MP and former director of university M Ramadass approached the Ministry of Human Resource and Development (MHRD) seeking Krishnamurthy’s ouster at the earliest.
The charges against Krishnamurthy include allegations that the two books which Ms. Krishnamurthy claims to have written are apparently non-existent and 24 of the 25 papers which she claims to have submitted could not be traced in the UGC database or the online repository for law schools.
The Puta Secretary, N. Dastagiri Reddy cited the example of Kumaun University vice-chancellor B S Rajput who had resigned following plagiarism charges against him and said that Krishnamurthy must resign. He said, “We all view plagiarism as an extreme form of dishonesty and academic theft. We call for immediate removal of the vice-chancellor and a thorough probe by the Union ministry of human resource development into her academic credentials and claims of publications.”
Reddy added that Pondicherry University has taken stringent measures in the past against plagiarism and had dismissed a faculty member guilty of plagiarism in the past.
Expressing strong condemnation, SFI Puducherry Secretary, A Anand, said, “This is an instance of theft and lack of credibility on the part of the head of a prestigious academic institution. These evidences vindicate the accusation that Chandra earned the VC post through fraudulent means. This is also a serious violation of the academic ethics from one who is supposed to safeguard the academic credentials of a higher educational institution. Chandra must be immediately removed from the post and an inquiry should be initiated into all her misdemeanors.”
The incident is an extremely unfortunate one; it exposes the deplorable state of academic research in the country and raises ethical concerns. It also calls for a serious debate on how to effectively check plagiarism in the academia.
While plagiarism almost always invites charges of copyright infringement, it is worth differentiating between plagiarism and copyright infringement. Plagiarism is the use of another’s work without giving him attribution, whereas, copyright infringement is the use of an author’s work without his permission (where the work is protected by copyright). Plagiarism is not only legally wrong, it also violates the moral right of the author to be recognized as the author of the work.
Nobody who has studied in a law school in India is alien to the culture of ‘cut-copy-paste’ or “CCP” prevalent in the student community. However, when the same is resorted to by academics holding extremely prestigious and important posts in educational institutions, it is indeed scary. The reputation of an academic is determined largely on the basis of how “published” he/she is and this leads to their appointment on expert panels and as heads of educational institutions. Vice-Chancellors and teachers of educational institutes must realize the academic responsibility that they shoulder and they must set the right example for their students by not indulging in dishonest academic practices themselves.
***
I guess academic plagiarism is a worldwide phenomenon and despite of all the legal procedures due to growing economic pressure, competition, and perhaps ever increasing number of people in graduate school, the number is increasing.
November 26, 2014
Chandra Krishnamurthy
Chandra Krishnamurthy, the erstwhile Vice-Chancellor of National Law University Orissa & currently the Vice-Chancellor of Pondicherry University is the latest in the series of academics who have been accused of plagiarism. Earlier this month, Deepak Pental (Ex- Vice Chancellor of Delhi University) & Abhijit Chakrabarti (Vice- Chancellor of Jadavpur University) were accused of plagiarism. This makes Krishnamurthy the third academic in India to be accused of plagiarism in a single month.
It is alleged that Krishnamurthy in her book, ‘Legal Education in India’, lifted 5 out of 8 chapters from research papers written by legal luminary, N R Madhava Menon. Following this revelation, the Pondicherry University Teachers’ Association (Puta), the Students Federation of India (SFI) and former Puducherry MP and former director of university M Ramadass approached the Ministry of Human Resource and Development (MHRD) seeking Krishnamurthy’s ouster at the earliest.
The charges against Krishnamurthy include allegations that the two books which Ms. Krishnamurthy claims to have written are apparently non-existent and 24 of the 25 papers which she claims to have submitted could not be traced in the UGC database or the online repository for law schools.
The Puta Secretary, N. Dastagiri Reddy cited the example of Kumaun University vice-chancellor B S Rajput who had resigned following plagiarism charges against him and said that Krishnamurthy must resign. He said, “We all view plagiarism as an extreme form of dishonesty and academic theft. We call for immediate removal of the vice-chancellor and a thorough probe by the Union ministry of human resource development into her academic credentials and claims of publications.”
Reddy added that Pondicherry University has taken stringent measures in the past against plagiarism and had dismissed a faculty member guilty of plagiarism in the past.
Expressing strong condemnation, SFI Puducherry Secretary, A Anand, said, “This is an instance of theft and lack of credibility on the part of the head of a prestigious academic institution. These evidences vindicate the accusation that Chandra earned the VC post through fraudulent means. This is also a serious violation of the academic ethics from one who is supposed to safeguard the academic credentials of a higher educational institution. Chandra must be immediately removed from the post and an inquiry should be initiated into all her misdemeanors.”
The incident is an extremely unfortunate one; it exposes the deplorable state of academic research in the country and raises ethical concerns. It also calls for a serious debate on how to effectively check plagiarism in the academia.
While plagiarism almost always invites charges of copyright infringement, it is worth differentiating between plagiarism and copyright infringement. Plagiarism is the use of another’s work without giving him attribution, whereas, copyright infringement is the use of an author’s work without his permission (where the work is protected by copyright). Plagiarism is not only legally wrong, it also violates the moral right of the author to be recognized as the author of the work.
Nobody who has studied in a law school in India is alien to the culture of ‘cut-copy-paste’ or “CCP” prevalent in the student community. However, when the same is resorted to by academics holding extremely prestigious and important posts in educational institutions, it is indeed scary. The reputation of an academic is determined largely on the basis of how “published” he/she is and this leads to their appointment on expert panels and as heads of educational institutions. Vice-Chancellors and teachers of educational institutes must realize the academic responsibility that they shoulder and they must set the right example for their students by not indulging in dishonest academic practices themselves.
***
I guess academic plagiarism is a worldwide phenomenon and despite of all the legal procedures due to growing economic pressure, competition, and perhaps ever increasing number of people in graduate school, the number is increasing.
MilSpec
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Feb 19, 2011
- Messages
- 12,931
- Reaction score
- 38
- Country
- Location
This is actually a real problem. Especially for smaller colleges and Technical Papers being presented at symposiums.... We seriously need the some serious reforms in the education sector regarding plagiarism and create awareness among students on how to write in graduate and undergrad courses.
According the the map, China has the same problems if not worse, despite claiming to have a lot great "world class universities of original R&D" going on. This was posted yesterday Fake Peer Review Scandal Shines Spotlight on China
dray
BANNED
- Joined
- Apr 8, 2013
- Messages
- 10,853
- Reaction score
- -1
- Country
- Location
kadamba-warrior
FULL MEMBER
- Joined
- Apr 2, 2012
- Messages
- 1,542
- Reaction score
- -3
- Country
- Location
Academic plagiarism in select countries:
Although even one instance of plagiarism is one too many, how exactly is China better than India?
Even by your own map, China had 688 of 6372 authors flagged while India had 471 of 4283! How is China any better?
Maths problem or just a slow day?
SamantK
SENIOR MEMBER
- Joined
- Jan 27, 2012
- Messages
- 5,559
- Reaction score
- -13
- Country
- Location
Oh please, we don't roll Pakistani way 'Xactly'
nForce
ELITE MEMBER
- Joined
- Apr 26, 2010
- Messages
- 8,910
- Reaction score
- -1
- Country
- Location
Probably the OP did not see that, but I will not be worried about that. It's a serious problem for us nonetheless. There is little that can be done presently to stop it.
Similar threads
