Why do Pakistanis love Kashmir?

[AbhimanyuShrivastav]

Came out few years later too.. But lit up Indra..

Sure.. So the rant from the "Administrator" was indeed stupid. And it seems you agree...

 

[I.R.A]

“Precisely. Kashmir is a natural part of Pakistan and Kashmiri Pandits must pay jizya.”

The amount of Jizya is much less than Zakat by the way, and in today's world she is talking nonsense, if I was that Kid I would have given her a face palm for being ignorant to the current affairs and situation and acting smart in her rants.

As if Pakitan Government is collecting jizya all over the country already.

I mean… I like my men tall, dark and handsome (and somewhat modern!).

I did not know I am a commodity for women, who will choose me based on their desires and fantasies.

And what is this somewhat modern or somewhat backward, an added feature for the toy she seeks?

I realize this article is supposed to be more on the comedy side of things - because if it's not, I'm seriously disturbed by the level of irresponsibility and misinformation in our newspapers. First of all,

This pseudo-liberal (the author) has no idea what she's talking about. Parroting the Western and Indian narrative while completely disregarding the reality of what 'Jihad fi sabillillah' means and what it signifies in this political conflict is a really irresponsible thing to do. All it does is reinforce the misunderstandings that make the 'Islamic' terrorist narrative so powerful, and that is not something anyone should do nowadays.

No such school exists in Pakistan. I have been to the top-level 'Elite' 'Westernized' schools in Pakistan and none of them prohibit Urdu. That is an exaggeration to say the least. Some prohibit provincial language (i.e Punjabi, Saraiki etc) slang and what they consider to be bad language but absolutely none prohibit speaking normal, decent Urdu. They even have Urdu lessons. A lot of Urdu lessons, actually.

Even more irresponsible idiocy. Instead of clarifying the reality about Islamic concepts like Jizya, she is spreading more of the same narrative that lets terrorists turn their politics into an ''Islam vs Everyone else'' scenario. And she's talking to a kid when she does this.
Refuting lies about Islam: Allegation that Islam expanded by forcing people to pay Jizyah
It's even worse because no one in Pakistan is legally required to pay any Jizya.


She is also apparently a PPP supporter - not surprising at all.


Hilariously referencing Christine Fair's book in her facile defamation of the PA.

What a laughable conclusion.

And now the mandatory reference to the inappropriate activities of some people (in that specific place) to add more to the insult of Pakistanis.



The reality is very different. This article ignores so many viewpoints, so many social and political realities, along with making so many factual errors that it is, laughable, as I believe and hope it was intended to be.

I'll just quote a comment from the original article (long but worth a read):

Very well written arguments and analysis.

 

[I.R.A]

We do not like some things, But trust me Some people we hate most than other and You guys top that list.

Just to let you know this feeling is mutual. Don't be mistaken.

I don't know why Pakistanis have soft corner for Indian Sikhs, but trust me I have no sympathy for you or your sikhs, and I have not forgotten what atrocities your elders did at the time of partition, you deserved what happened at Golden temple. And if someday things go crazy I would love to see Indian sikhs being at the top of the list of targets.

 

[Zibago]

Just to let you know this feeling is mutual. Don't be mistaken.

I don't know why Pakistanis have soft corner for Indian Sikhs, but trust me I have no sympathy for you or your sikhs, and I have not forgotten what atrocities your elders did at the time of partition, you deserved what happened at Golden temple. And if someday things go crazy I would love to see Indian sikhs being at the top of the list of targets.

Sikhs massacred Muslims in Jammnu and East Punjab zero sympathies from me aswell

 

[SrNair]

The figures are wrong.

Who cares whether ypu believe it or not ?

They did that to prevent BJP fom coming to power with the article 370 d BS etc.. To secure their interests.. Even now the kashmiri party PDPA? Is demanding things like :

Negotiations with Pakistan.
Royality for Jhelum and Chenab
No article 370

Etc.

GO FIGURE ... Otherwise there are pics of KAshmiris pissing on BJP flags outside poll booths.

Anyway they used Indian Democracy for that.We have seen 100 more demands two decades ago from parties like this .Now they reduced in to two .Within next two decade they will become totally irrelevant.We have already begin demographic changes.

In Kashmir

 

[black-hawk_101]

Kashmir, Siachin, Indian Punjab, UP, Rajistan and Gujrat are all parts of Pakistan being occupied by India.

 

[Zibago]

Who cares whether ypu believe it or not ?



Anyway they used Indian Democracy for that.We have seen 100 more demands two decades ago from parties like this .Now they reduced in to two .Within next two decade they will become totally irrelevant.We have already begin demographic changes.

In Kashmir

After
Genocide of Muslims, Jammu 1947 | Kashmir Media Service
demographic change coming in IOK

 

[suresh1773]

Kashmir, Siachin, Indian Punjab, UP, Rajistan and Gujrat are all parts of Pakistan being occupied by India.

What is the source,

some Pakistani History text books

 

[SrNair]

After
Genocide of Muslims, Jammu 1947 | Kashmir Media Service
demographic change coming in IOK

Hindus from other parts of India will settle there.

 

[I.R.A]

View attachment 195864

Recently, I spoke to a kid who was once a student at an elite and Westernised school in Pakistan (speaking Urdu even during breaks is punishable by a detention at such schools). I was surprised that he couldn’t even take a casual joke on the Kashmir issue. He remarked, “Kashmir does not want to be a part of India.” Amused, I retorted in my usual tongue-in-cheek tone: “Precisely. Kashmir is a natural part of Pakistan and Kashmiri Pandits must pay jizya.”

The above sentences clearly shows how much she is disconnected with Pakistan and Pakistanis as well as oblivious of the history and religion. There is nothing wrong in encouraging new writers and publish their work but should the newspapers publish such delusions and fallacies, I guess the editor of 'Nation' did not do his/her job well.

By the way, who is she? I have heard this name for the first time. Is she among the tier 1 columnists? No; tier 2 columnists? No; tier 3 columnists? No; tier 4 columnists? any tier columnists? No, not even there!

OK, then move on.

Oey huy TT? Ballay ballay shawa shawa ......................................

 

[singh sahab]

Just to let you know this feeling is mutual. Don't be mistaken.

I don't know why Pakistanis have soft corner for Indian Sikhs, but trust me I have no sympathy for you or your sikhs, and I have not forgotten what atrocities your elders did at the time of partition, you deserved what happened at Golden temple. And if someday things go crazy I would love to see Indian sikhs being at the top of the list of targets.

That would be the last day for those target list holders.

 

[I.R.A]

That would be the last day for those target list holders.

I can understand, it's not your fault.

 

[utraash]

* Muslims WILL ounumber you in South Asia within 50 years.

* Central Asia is already Muslim

* You'll be ounumbered and sandwiched between Muslim Central & South Asia, Indonesia and your big fat enemy China.

* History has proved time and again that Muslims have ALWAYS seeked revenge for oppression. We are on the backfoot now....but a few decades onwards baby boy, you guys are going to pay for ''every one'' of our dead...today we are counting our dead bodies....tomorrow the maths is going to be yours.

* Soviets oppressed our Muslim kin for two centuries, but didn't succeed....despite their might, nuclear bombs and ICMBs, we destroyed them in the end.

* Guess you forgot that Muslims have attained over 18 new states in just 30 years.. You can laugh as much as you can sonnyboy because your kids won't have that 'luxury'.

Typical ummah gloat ....These suicidal tendencies have made what Pakistan is today...... Keep growing these imbecilic traits....
Ontopic
Reason for obsession with Kashmir
1) The romanticism of ummah concept
2) Strategically at pivot location
3) Securing water resources
4) Lastly white skin brotherhood

@levina
Its not love otherwise same would not have led the bloodshed in the name of liberation..... Need to replace the "love" in the thread title ....

 

[singh sahab]

I can understand, it's not your fault.

Laugh all you want, just remember the poster boy of your countries division. Lieutenant General Jagjit Singh Aurora

Kashmir, Siachin, Indian Punjab, UP, Rajistan and Gujrat are all parts of Pakistan being occupied by India.

You sir, just made my day.

 

[kaku1]

That does not seem to the case.I used to read posts from IDF where indian members while talking to each other posted about Akhand Bharat and also about Modi`s plans to destroy Pakistan after comming into power.


Its seems like India is an angel.#Balochistan insurgency/terrorism,TTP,etc

Thats called Realpolitik.