What's new

Why are Mongolians so hostile toward China

VALKRYIE

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Mar 6, 2015
Messages
669
Reaction score
-1
Country
Canada
Location
Canada
1081409_4822572c62457d22756ec7c6205488ff-692x360.jpg

A Mongolian honor guard performs during the opening ceremony of Khaan Quest, an annual multilateral military exercise near the capital Ulan Bator. Photo: Reuters

HomeReal InsightCommentators

What’s behind the Mongolians’ hostility toward mainlanders

A recent attack on Chinese tourists in Mongolia has caused a diplomatic ruckus.

The Chinese consulate in Mongolia complained to the government in Ulan Bator which later apologized, but the Chinese media accused Mongolia of being insincere.

To understand how Mongolians regard China, it’s important to consider the subject in the context of international relations.

Professor Wang Hao of the Mongolia Research Center of Peking University says Mongolia has a “small country complex” that comes from being sandwiched between two big neighbors — China and Russia.

Increasingly, Mongolia has been engaged in multilateral diplomacy in recent years to improve relations with Japan, the United States and the European Union.

Since 2003, it has been holding a series of military exercises, dubbed Khaan Quest, with the US.

In 2010, it contributed peace-keeping troops to the US-led coalition effort in Afghanistan and signed a partnership framework agreement with the European Union that same year.

These actions have shown that Mongolia is keen to balance the influence of different powers, particularly China.

With the rise of the mainland, many Chinese businessmen are investing in Mongolia’s mining and energy sectors.

However, while Chinese companies bring foreign capital to Mongolia, they also stand accused of taking jobs from local workers, causing disaffection in the population.

Many rightist organizations have emerged in Mongolia, usually targeting China.

These include the neo-Nazi group Khukh Mongol and other entities such as Tsagaan Khass and Dayar Mongol.

In Russia, neo-Nazism has given rise to so-called “skinheads” who are known to attack Asians in the streets.

Mongolia’s neo-Nazism can be traced to Russia.

In fact, their followers are very similar in that both emphasize the purity of blood and promote xenophobia.

In addition, Mongolia’s neo-Nazis appreciate German orthodoxy.

Members of the Tsagaan Khass have publicly said they respect Hitler for his efforts to preserve racial purity, although they don’t agree with his decision to start World War II.

Also, Tsagaan Khass strongly opposes the idea of Mongolian women marrying Chinese workers. Offspring from such unions are discriminated against.

A rightist group, Dayar Mongol, recently attacked Chinese workers of a mainland company.

Nyam Puruv, a scholar in Mongolian history and sociology, believes the rise and influence of neo-Nazis have been exaggerated.

After all, there are only several hundred neo-Nazi supporters in Mongolia.

They are mainly young unemployed people or individuals who have not received higher education.

They are the ones most affected by the influx of Chinese investment into Mongolia and are thus showing the strongest opposition.

But rightists in China are equally hostile.

After the latest incident, many Chinese netizens left messages in online forums, suggesting China should do to Mongolia what Russia did to Crimea when Moscow annexed it from Ukraine, in order to “reunify Mongolia”.

Such comments show how susceptible Chinese rightists can be to extremist manipulation.

– Contact us at english@hkej.com

RA

What’s behind the Mongolians’ hostility toward mainlanders

It so sad that the great Mongolian empire which rule China dynasty has fallen to its hegemony.
 
.
What’s behind the Mongolians’ hostility toward mainlanders

It so sad that the great Mongolian empire which rule China dynasty has fallen to its hegemony.

Well, Mongolians are lucky they did not extinct as many other minority groups in China. They still have 2 million population...

BTW, most of Mongolians in Outer-Mongolia are not "pure Mongolians" but slaves of "real" Mongolians.
Mongolians in Inner-Mongolia are purer.

After Zunghar Genocide, Mongolians are extinct from Xinjiang.
80% killed and 20% fleet to Russia and Mongolia.
Dzungar genocide - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
 
Last edited:
. .
They have be told what to do or how to write and think by the Russian for more than 70 Years, it will not change quickly.
And it's interesting that they can't even write the tradition Mongolian.
 
.
Well, Mongolians are lucky they did not extinct as many other minority groups in China. They still have 2 million population...

BTW, most of Mongolians in Outer-Mongolia are not "pure Mongolians" but slaves of "real" Mongolians.
Mongolians in Inner-Mongolia are purer.

After Zunghar Genocide, Mongolians are extinct from Xinjiang.
80% killed and 20% fleet to Russia and Mongolia.
Dzungar genocide - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

That's 2 million more than what the Han Chinese should have allowed.

2 million problem if you ask me.
 
.
1. Qing ruled Mongolia for over 200 years and some ultra nationalist in China still claims it.

2. China "stole" inner Mongolia, the much richer and more populated Mongolia.

3. Mongolia was a satellite state of Russia for over 70 years so they naturally mistrust great powers.

4. Mongolia is landlocked so their only access to port is with China and their main economic life line is China. This gives China a lot of power over them.

5. 3 million vs 1.3 billion. Mongolia knows China can overpower them militarily.

It's human nature really. We hate our bosses because they have so much power over us. We find every little fault about them and criticize them to no end even if the boss is average in personality. Mongolia hates China because it fears China's power. Low population, sandwich by 2 historical superpowers and no access to port.
 
.
After Zunghar Genocide, Mongolians are extinct from Xinjiang.
80% killed and 20% fleet to Russia and Mongolia.
Dzungar genocide - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Dzungars were militant people that attacked and committed massacres of their neighbors in Muslim Central Asia. Many Dzungars migrated to Volga region and created Kalmyk region that assisted Russians against their wars and conquest of Muslim Caucasian region.
 
.

That's why. Anyway, the Mongolians are a good people, I respect them, and so do the Chinese. They'll turn around. Can't fault China for having 1.3 billion people or for being your neighbour. When they realise China isn't hostile, and is responsible for almost all of their economic well being, they'll turn around.
 
.

Pakistan Defence Latest Posts

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom