Why are Bangladesh and Myanmar enemies?

[VikingRaider]

I don't understand. Just tell the truth or perhaps there is some reason you cannot. Maybe you guys are facing many more problems there than I can imagine. Don't even know what this South Asian style is. I am 4th generation in Canada, ancestors from England, Scotland and one from Germany (Bavaria). Sorry dude, I also don't know what a Bharati is. I can look the word up, though.

As far as the "West" not being evil goes....why is my ground water poisoned? People here not evil? killing people and taking their land is just business? Not for me it isn't. Guess I am not a Roman or a German.

Okay if you are western origin then I already answered your question.

South Asian style is simply emotional style and I think western are stoic compared to south Asians.

 

[KurtisBrian]

Okay if you are western origin then I already answered your question.

South Asian style is simply emotional style and I think western are stoic compared to south Asians.

you didn't answer my questions. You went around in a circle. But that is okay. They were more rhetorical questions anyway. Written for you to ponder. have a good evening.

 

[Destranator]

The aggression has mainly been from the Myanmar side, if you read the news-reports.

And it is no longer called Burma.

We don't have time to deal with these people, too many things going on locally.

No need to be so polite to hypocritical idiots. This type is also found among Indians. They ruin it for their respective countries.

 

[Bilal9]

No need to be so polite to hypocritical idiots. This type is also found among Indians. They ruin it for their respective countries.

Did not want to elicit any reactions and waste my time, that's all.

Someone who can say this sort of thing is a major hypocrite, like you said. Or, a false flagger.

 

[Bilal9]

West isn't evil, but neither angels too. China also funded us , all are part of business.



I will answer your question , but first you have to answer me , are you a Canadian origin or Bharati origin living in Canada?

My answers will be different according to your identity.

But I doubt that any pure western will ask question in this manner , as it's actually south Asian style ( or origin )of asking a question.

ভাই আপনে কার্তিক এর লগে কথা বইলা সময় নষ্ট কইরেন না। এই পাবলিক ভারতীয়।

 

[Homo Sapiens]

i just read that the population of St Martin's island is 4,000. who lives there? whats there ethnicity?

First of all, Myanmar never claimed St. Martin's island officially or even spelled out openly by any of their minister, military junta leadership or any other important figure. This entire episode is about two recent incidence when some Myanmar govt. website map shown St. Martin's Island as a part of Myanmar. When Bangladesh protested, they apologized their 'mistake' and removed that map. They claimed it was unintentional mistake, but many are unconvinced and suspect, it was a ploy to divert attention from Rohingya issue.

Burmese knows very well that they have no credible claim over this Island. From The beginning, this Island was a part of British Bengal province rather than British Burma. When in 1937, Burma was separated from British Indian empire, this island remained with Bengal. Since then it became part of formal East Pakistan and then independent Bangladesh. In 1974 maritime boundary agreement between Bangladesh and Myanmar, they accepted St. martin's as a part of Bangladesh. The 2012 international arbitration over maritime boundary between Bangladesh and Myanmar also firmly established St. Martin's as a part of Bangladesh and gave it 6 nautical miles territorial water between the Island and Myanmar. So, Myanmar knows very well that they have no legal basis or historical claim over St. Martin's island, that's why they resorted to that kind of dirty trick. And they also knows very well that, if Bangladesh complains about Burmese mischievous attempt at UNCLOS, they will be in trouble.

This island is 8 sq. km in size and populated by 7000 resident population. Almost all of them are Bengali ethnicity. Until late 19th century this island was uninhabited and then was settled by Bengalis from Cox's Bazar and Rohingyas from Arakan.

 

[VikingRaider]

ভাই আপনে কার্তিক এর লগে কথা বইলা সময় নষ্ট কইরেন না। এই পাবলিক ভারতীয়।

ওহ আচ্ছা ভাই বুঝছি! আমার অবশ্য প্রথমেই সন্দেহ হইছিল তার প্রশ্নের ধরন দেখে! বাহরাম খিলজিও মনে হইতেছে একই গোয়ালের গরু!
@Bilal9

 

[Paul2]

Not really enemies.... burma is a barely functioning conglomerate of tiny states...

Rohingya is a major issue.... once they go back st martins will remain a tiny storm in the tea cup that will flare from time to time.

Short sharp conflict probably in the horizon if burmese military loses control....but tiny possibility.

Bottom line not enemies not friends and fairly detached from one another.

Before saying this, you are better to look on its army.

I'd say even if fully mobilised Bangladesh military may not be able to give Burmese a whacking.

3 fold advantage in trained manpower (Burmese army is known for long brutal training)

4 fold advantage in artillery

2 fold advantage in modern aircraft

I only see BD making Burmese itch if it were to commit to surprise strike, mobilisation, and attritious land warfare using its overwhelming population advantage, and the fact that the lion share of Burmese military is stuck in jungles fighting ethnic armies.

 

[bluesky]

Before saying this, you are better to look on its army.

I'd say even if fully mobilised Bangladesh military may not be able to give Burmese a whacking.

3 fold advantage in trained manpower (Burmese army is known for long brutal training)

4 fold advantage in artillery

2 fold advantage in modern aircraft

I only see BD making Burmese itch if it were to commit to surprise strike, mobilisation, and attritious land warfare using its overwhelming population advantage, and the fact that the lion share of Burmese military is stuck in jungles fighting ethnic armies.

Do not worry. Our Hasina Bibi will shortly build jet fighters she declared only recently. But, I do not know how she will.

Probably, her BAL party possesses the Aladin's Lamp. The lamp will provide technologies to do it.

 

[Paul2]

Not really enemies.... burma is a barely functioning conglomerate of tiny states...

Rohingya is a major issue.... once they go back st martins will remain a tiny storm in the tea cup that will flare from time to time.

Short sharp conflict probably in the horizon if burmese military loses control....but tiny possibility.

Bottom line not enemies not friends and fairly detached from one another.

Before saying this, you are better to look on its army.

I'd say even if fully mobilised Bangladesh military may not be able to give Burmese a whacking.

3 fold advantage in trained manpower (Burmese army is known for long brutal training)

4 fold advantage in artillery

2 fold advantage in modern aircraft

I only see BD making Burmese itch if it were to commit to mobilisation, and land warfare.

Do not worry. Our Hasina Bibi will shortly build jet fighters she declared only recently. But, I do not know how she will.

Probably, her BAL party possesses the Aladin's Lamp. The lamp will provide technologies to do it.

I tend to believe that this Aladin's lamp is a building on the 3 Park Rd

 

[X-ray Papa]

Before saying this, you are better to look on its army.

I'd say even if fully mobilised Bangladesh military may not be able to give Burmese a whacking.

3 fold advantage in trained manpower (Burmese army is known for long brutal training)

4 fold advantage in artillery

2 fold advantage in modern aircraft

I only see BD making Burmese itch if it were to commit to surprise strike, mobilisation, and attritious land warfare using its overwhelming population advantage, and the fact that the lion share of Burmese military is stuck in jungles fighting ethnic armies.

Yet they could not beat their rag-tag rebels.

 

[SpaceMan18]

Before saying this, you are better to look on its army.

I'd say even if fully mobilised Bangladesh military may not be able to give Burmese a whacking.

3 fold advantage in trained manpower (Burmese army is known for long brutal training)

4 fold advantage in artillery

2 fold advantage in modern aircraft

I only see BD making Burmese itch if it were to commit to mobilisation, and land warfare.

I tend to believe that this Aladin's lamp is a building on the 3 Park Rd

Interesting since Bangladesh kicked Myanmar's @ss in border fights , just because Myanmar has a larger army doesn't mean it will do well.

They may have air superiority now , but again they won't use all their aircrafts against us , and plus our border with Myanmar has hills and the fighting arena isn't that large.

Myanmar couldn't win against rebels how tf will they win against Bangladesh ?

Our navy has a bit of advantage over there Frigates with MANPADS lol

So no , Myanmar will not win a war since Myanmar is divided unlike Bangladesh

 

[bdslph]

NO WE ARE NOT ENEMIES we have full diplomatic relationship and we do business full scale

 

[magra]

First when they crossed NAF river while trafficking drugs and shot at us back in 2000s... they sent us an aggressive letter for shooting back... we killed 600 of em until they calmed down and sent us a letter to ceasefire... (this is also the time when we sent truckloads of Indian BSF to india, the BDR chief (BGB) was forced retired shortly)
THEN in 2008 they claimed st Martin and sent a warship with South Korean oil drill to look for oil in our territory, we sent a corvette and a frigate and they ran off...
Then some other border skirmishes, they kidnapped or shot and killed our soldier... we mortared and killed 2 officers of theirs...
Then BDR mutiny happened, Their balls were sacked, BGB was created...
Since we we have done nothing except very recently when we shot a BSF shorts wearing soldier in the head... and at another seperate occasion took firing position at BSF for trying to push in Indian disabled people into bd...
They have been laying claim to st Martin multiple times, live off of smuggling drugs to bd... so yeah we’re enemies for these reasons

The question was about Myanmar & BD. Why did you talk about BSF so many times? Are you that obsessed about India?

 

[Saiful Islam]

Before saying this, you are better to look on its army.

I'd say even if fully mobilised Bangladesh military may not be able to give Burmese a whacking.

3 fold advantage in trained manpower (Burmese army is known for long brutal training)

4 fold advantage in artillery

2 fold advantage in modern aircraft

I only see BD making Burmese itch if it were to commit to mobilisation, and land warfare.

I tend to believe that this Aladin's lamp is a building on the 3 Park Rd

First tell to stop scattering like fleas when hearing the sounds of gunshot.