Why an India-Indonesia comparison seems fairer than an India-China pairing

[beijingwalker]

Why an India-Indonesia comparison seems fairer than an India-China pairing
The economies of India and Indonesia are run on similar lines; while we may aspire to be a democratic if smaller version of China, we may only manage to be a larger and more accomplished Indonesia
T N Ninan Last Updated at May 11, 2018 15:04 IST

It has become obvious that comparisons between India and China make less and less sense. Though both are geographically large and populous, and firmly positioned as the two fastest-growing large economies, they have been on different economic growth trajectories for four decades, such that the Chinese economy is now five times India’s.

China is in another league in the power game, while India is losing traction in its own neighbourhood. China is increasingly more accomplished when it comes to technology acquisition and absorption, quality of education and the elimination of poverty, and .

http://www.business-standard.com/ar...an-an-india-china-pairing-118051100589_1.html

 

[rambro]

Dont agree coz indonesia is actually doing much better + internally more stable.

Comparison should be with different country.

 

[Indian wonk]

Dont agree coz indonesia is actually doing much better + internally more stable.

Do mention the Macro-economic data points of Indonesia which you used to compare with India and found your aforementioned results .

Why an India-Indonesia comparison seems fairer than an India-China pairing
The economies of India and Indonesia are run on similar lines; while we may aspire to be a democratic if smaller version of China, we may only manage to be a larger and more accomplished Indonesia
T N Ninan Last Updated at May 11, 2018 15:04 IST

It has become obvious that comparisons between India and China make less and less sense. Though both are geographically large and populous, and firmly positioned as the two fastest-growing large economies, they have been on different economic growth trajectories for four decades, such that the Chinese economy is now five times India’s.

China is in another league in the power game, while India is losing traction in its own neighbourhood. China is increasingly more accomplished when it comes to technology acquisition and absorption, quality of education and the elimination of poverty, and .

http://www.business-standard.com/ar...an-an-india-china-pairing-118051100589_1.html

Actually India should be compared with Timbuktu.

 

[Quibbler]

Dont agree coz indonesia is actually doing much better + internally more stable.

Comparison should be with different country.

Whoa. A Dictatorship commenting on the stability of a Democracy. Democracies might be messy but the can take punches and blows much bigger than them. On the other hand, one crazy leader in a Dictatorship and Kaboom.

 

[Indian wonk]

Whoa. A Dictatorship commenting on the stability of a Democracy. Democracies might be messy but the can take punches and blows much bigger than them. On the other hand, one crazy leader in a Dictatorship and Kaboom.

Bro let them live in their ethereal phantasm world , its funny .

 

[war&peace]

while we may aspire to be a democratic if smaller version of China, we may only manage to be a larger and more accomplished Indonesia

Since when India is more developed than Indonesia...

 

[Offshore]

india should Paired with Wakanda

 

[beijingwalker]

Whoa. A Dictatorship commenting on the stability of a Democracy. Democracies might be messy but the can take punches and blows much bigger than them. On the other hand, one crazy leader in a Dictatorship and Kaboom.

Democratic Iraq or Afghanistan are so stable, and India? One of the most violent countries in the world.

 

[rambro]

Whoa. A Dictatorship commenting on the stability of a Democracy. Democracies might be messy but the can take punches and blows much bigger than them. On the other hand, one crazy leader in a Dictatorship and Kaboom.

Hello, Malaysia is a democratic country too.
It is not exclusive to India only, wait India is a flawed democracy aka pretender

Can i say modi is a dictator? it is known how unstable india is with all the internal turmoil.
Kaboom? Banana republic get it?

pffftt.

 

[AyanRay]

Why an India-Indonesia comparison seems fairer than an India-China pairing
The economies of India and Indonesia are run on similar lines; while we may aspire to be a democratic if smaller version of China, we may only manage to be a larger and more accomplished Indonesia
T N Ninan Last Updated at May 11, 2018 15:04 IST

It has become obvious that comparisons between India and China make less and less sense. Though both are geographically large and populous, and firmly positioned as the two fastest-growing large economies, they have been on different economic growth trajectories for four decades, such that the Chinese economy is now five times India’s.

China is in another league in the power game, while India is losing traction in its own neighbourhood. China is increasingly more accomplished when it comes to technology acquisition and absorption, quality of education and the elimination of poverty, and .

http://www.business-standard.com/ar...an-an-india-china-pairing-118051100589_1.html

If you really wanted to have a mental orgasm, would have at least paid for the subscription and read the whole article.

 

[Quibbler]

Democratic Iraq or Afghanistan are so stable, and India? One of the most violent countries in the world.

Democracy never set there. They never had time to strengthen their institutions.

In India, violence is not against political structure(except kashmir where democracy is not applied as per emergency clause). Social violence exists but is rarely a cause for political unstability.

Hello, Malaysia is a democratic country too.
It is not exclusive to India only, wait India is a flawed democracy aka pretender

Can i say modi is a dictator? it is known how unstable india is with all the internal turmoil.
Kaboom? Banana republic get it?

pffftt.

Ya. Sure you are from "Myanmar".

 

[SrNair]

Hello, Malaysia is a democratic country too.
It is not exclusive to India only, wait India is a flawed democracy aka pretender

Can i say modi is a dictator? it is known how unstable india is with all the internal turmoil.
Kaboom? Banana republic get it?

pffftt.

Actually who cares Malaysia is this or that ?

On topic : Some neighbours need a lots of burnol .
Even recently proved that if we stand on our own Chinese chose to avoid any conflict.

 

[Nike]

This will be a legit comparison, as both countries got their independence almost at the same time and both embracing democracy although Indonesia been in dictatorship for almost four decades (late Soekarno and Soeharto era)

https://countryeconomy.com/countries/compare/indonesia/india

 

[beijingwalker]

Even recently proved that if we stand on our own Chinese chose to avoid any conflict.

We stand on our own and Indians chose to avoid conflict, that's why they send Modi and defence minister to fly to Beijing.

 

[noksss]

Hello, Malaysia is a democratic country too.
It is not exclusive to India only, wait India is a flawed democracy aka pretender

Can i say modi is a dictator? it is known how unstable india is with all the internal turmoil.
Kaboom? Banana republic get it?

pffftt.

Hope your non-banana republic pardons anwar ibrahim