Who Would Win A Conflict In The South China Sea: The Infographic

[Echo_419]

The question should be directed to the USA worldwide and to India for your problems that arise internally and in S Asia

Unrealistic propositions
That scenario amounts to a WW3 and a nuclear one
Dont think India will be left unscathed either

We only have problems with one neighbour & that's a personal one
On topic
Both China & US should balance each other out

 

[Bussard Ramjet]

And India does? Or the Japanese, so friendly with fellow US ally South Korea? Or those Aussies, picking fights with Japan over dolphins?

Well, all countries that you have described do have more.

Yes, Japan doesn't have good relations with Korea, yet many other countries in ASEAN, India and US are all cheering for its militarization.

That dolphin issue is so small man! There is always a scale and severity of conflict. Most nations, even friendly ones, always have some or the other issues.

 

[Keel]

We only have problems with one neighbour & that's a personal one
On topic
Both China & US should balance each other out

You have a problem with literally all your surrounding neighbours
for the balancing thing that is echoing my propositions to the usa:

Does the usa want war or a joint development with China for prosperity?
The ball is in the US court!

 

[Bussard Ramjet]

You have a problem with literally all your surrounding neighbours
for the balancing thing that is echoing my propositions to the usa:

Does the usa want war or a joint development with China for prosperity?
The ball is in the US court!

What problems do we have with all our neighbors?

 

[Echo_419]

You have a problem with literally all your surrounding neighbours
for the balancing thing that is echoing my propositions to the usa:

Does the usa want war or a joint development with China for prosperity?
The ball is in the US court!

BS tell me about abyotger dispute except Pakistan

 

[Keel]

BS tell me about abyotger dispute except Pakistan

Utterly bs against someone's claim on your side that we have a problem with all our neighbours which in fact confine to the Viet, the Pinoys and Japanese

You people have to learn to recognise the USA - the universal troublemaker which has created more wars and tensions than peace, iso shoeshining their boots all the time

Indian has a huge problem inside wrt the insurgence and also border and other issues with S Lanka, Bangladesh, China

 

[Echo_419]

Equally bs against someone's claim on your side that we have a problem with all our neighbours which confine to the Viet and the Pinoys and Japanese You people have to learn to recognise the USA - the universal troublemaker which has created more wars and tensions than peace iso shoeshining their boots all the time

Indian has a huge problem inside wrt the insurgence and also border and other issues with S Lanka, Bangladesh, China

Insugrency is a domestic threat not a foreign one
Land disputes with Bangladesh is a thing of past & we never had any disputes with Sri Lanka
Also we are aware of the US agenda & wish you all the best to counter it

 

[Keel]

Insugrency is a domestic threat not a foreign one
Land disputes with Bangladesh is a thing of past & we never had any disputes with Sri Lanka
Also we are aware of the US agenda & wish you all the best to counter it

The SCS would be a conflict of the past IF the Japanese and the Yankies do not get involved
This also applies to Diaoyu Islands

If the same things like your support of the Tamil Tigers and the border issues with your neighbours have the warmongers' involvement, you wont get off the hooks easily

The insurgency in India is more devastating than our issues in Xinjiang and Xizang
It is your foremost danger with regard to the stability of India as a nation according to your former PM

In addition we have a much longer coast line and border which means we have a lot more neighbours than India. If you people keep on harping the diatribes about our conflicting relationship with all our neighbours - that is ridiculous

We only have problems about 3 most contentious neighbours only

 

[Echo_419]

Equally the SCS would be a conflict of the past IF the Japanese and the Yankies do not get involved

If the same thing like the your support of the Tamil Tigers and the border issues with your neighbours have the element of the warmongers involvement, you wont get off the hooks easily

The insurgency in India is more devastating than our issues in Xinjiang and Xizang
It is your foremost danger with regard to the stability of India as a nation

In addition we have a much longer coast line and border which mean we have a lot more neighbours than India. If you people keep on harping the diatribes about our conflicting relationship with all our neighbours - that is ridiculous

We only have problems about 3 most contentious neighbours only

& we have issues with only 2 you & Pakistan
So I guess we win

 

[Bussard Ramjet]

Equally bs against someone's claim on your side that we have a problem with all our neighbours which confine to the Viet and the Pinoys and Japanese You people have to learn to recognise the USA - the universal troublemaker which has created more wars and tensions than peace iso shoeshining their boots all the time

Indian has a huge problem inside wrt the insurgence and also border and other issues with S Lanka, Bangladesh, China

I accept that you have more neighbors than India, totally.
But you are really mistaken if you think that India is in any way or form internally unstable. India is very very stable internally. And most of the issues internally, are really too small, be it Maoist insurgency, or anything else.

 

[21stCentury]

First....Completely wrong assumption...

USA is not going to place 1 CBG,but possibly more than 2 along with other vessels,if things heat up a little bit..and if they decide to go to war,then God Save China(Even Commies going to say that)..

why???

I'm going to give a simple account..

Aspect-Gulf War..

USN Fleet---

Super Carrier--

1.USS America
2.USS John F. Kennedy
3.USS Midway(Not Super Carrier though)
4.USS Ranger
5.USS Saratoga
6.USS Theodore Roosevelt

Guided Missile Cruiser,Destroyer,Frigates,Battleships etc--

1.USS Bunker Hill
2.USS Caron
3.USS Curts
4.USS Fife
5.USS Ford
6.USS Hawes
7.USS Horne
8.USS Kidd
9.USS Jarrett
10.USS Leftwich
11.USS MacDonough
12.USS McInerney
13.USS Missouri
14.USS Mobile Bay
15.USS Nicholas
16.USS Normandy
17.USS Oldendorf
18.USS Paul F. Foster
19.USS Princeton
20.USS Vreeland
21.USS Worden
22.USS Wisconsin

Amphibious Task Force-

18 ships(Comprising few AAS,which can carry multiple aircrafts,helos etc)

along with multiple support ships......


This force is against a country which doesn't have a proper navy.Now imagine what they're going to use if something like US-Sino war will happen..

also,USA's main power is not its Armed Forces,but they way they acquire allies..in any war breaks out,China will experience half of Asia will support USA with Ships,Supplies and manpower,while China will stay alone..thats good for Hollywood Movies perhaps(Hero fighting against villain all alone),but actually pretty scary during war.

Oh no were shaking, time to cede our territories to the global dictator USA--wait nvm were not India or Philippines. You might be scared of the U.S. but we don't care.

 

[GR!FF!N]

Unrealistic propositions
That scenario amounts to a WW3 and a nuclear one
Dont think India will be left unscathed either

of course its unrealistic..whole thread is..

Oh no were shaking, time to cede our territories to the global dictator USA--wait nvm were not India or Philippines. You might be scared of the U.S. but we don't care.

pretty tough words coming from a country which got cowered not once,but twice....

First Taiwan Strait Crisis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Third Taiwan Strait Crisis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

in fact,it was USA which saved China's @r$3...But of course,you guys studied alternative history..

He is a m0r0n who ignores power of USA..and possibly China soon going to realize it..

One Example...

A war is brewing in SCS..count number of countries of each camp..USA already turned it China vs Everyone else involved..In fact,USA is gaining footholds around SCS..what is China's status??making artificial islands??but isn't that a very feeble attempt as it is not going to be a military threat as hyped??the very first hours of battle,these are going to vanish just like WW2 beach defense of Japanese..

and about "Our Territory"...

your territory??on what account??have enough proof on that??why don't show that to the world in forums like ICJ??everybody else are solving it like that way,even bitter enemies like Bangladesh and Myanmar or India and Pakistan...

 

[Keel]

& we have issues with only 2 you & Pakistan
So I guess we win

Keep the change pls

of course its unrealistic..whole thread is..

The thead is interesting until your unrealistic comments

 

[21stCentury]

of course its unrealistic..whole thread is..



pretty tough words coming from a country which got cowered not once,but twice....

First Taiwan Strait Crisis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Third Taiwan Strait Crisis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

in fact,it was USA which saved China's @r$3...But of course,you guys studied alternative history..

He is a m0r0n who ignores power of USA..and possibly China soon going to realize it..

One Example...

A war is brewing in SCS..count number of countries of each camp..USA already turned it China vs Everyone else involved..In fact,USA is gaining footholds around SCS..what is China's status??making artificial islands??but isn't that a very feeble attempt as it is not going to be a military threat as hyped??the very first hours of battle,these are going to vanish just like WW2 beach defense of Japanese..

and about "Our Territory"...

your territory??on what account??have enough proof on that??why don't show that to the world in forums like ICJ??everybody else are solving it like that way,even bitter enemies like Bangladesh and Myanmar or India and Pakistan...

Buddy that is the PAST, why don't you also bring up the 8-nation alliance that invaded China? What is happening now is a China who is strong enough to stand up to protect its own sovereignty -- not acting tough. Who is acting tough here is the U.S. trying to look like some bravo superman for the world protecting 'helpless innocent victims' lol.

SCS is none of your business so why bother?

 

[Bussard Ramjet]

of course its unrealistic..whole thread is..



pretty tough words coming from a country which got cowered not once,but twice....

First Taiwan Strait Crisis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Third Taiwan Strait Crisis - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

in fact,it was USA which saved China's @r$3...But of course,you guys studied alternative history..

He is a m0r0n who ignores power of USA..and possibly China soon going to realize it..

One Example...

A war is brewing in SCS..count number of countries of each camp..USA already turned it China vs Everyone else involved..In fact,USA is gaining footholds around SCS..what is China's status??making artificial islands??but isn't that a very feeble attempt as it is not going to be a military threat as hyped??the very first hours of battle,these are going to vanish just like WW2 beach defense of Japanese..

and about "Our Territory"...

your territory??on what account??have enough proof on that??why don't show that to the world in forums like ICJ??everybody else are solving it like that way,even bitter enemies like Bangladesh and Myanmar or India and Pakistan...

This is intellectually dishonest. Indians have always held the position that Kashmir issue is between India and Pakistan, and no outside parties, whether it be the UN or US, are welcome.