When Jinnah refused Rohingyas to be part of Bangladesh

[Homo Sapiens]

Why they became uncultured is not that they born uncultured but due to lack of proper education job opportunity they are now involve in many criminal activities . in fact criminals are taking advantage of their vulnerabilities .
If they had join us with some patch of land from Burma current Rohingya crisis would not born we would have little bit of more land . only problem could now as we enjoying a homogeneous country of around 98% bengali , the percentage would be reduced to 90-95%.

How it will reduce 90-95 percent? 10 lakh Rohingyas are not even 1 percent of Bangladesh's population.

And a very small percentage of Rohingyas are engaged in criminal activities. Criminal tendency among them is no more or no less then other nation in the world. Rohingyas are victim of being a burden population. Everywhere in the world, immigrant, burden population's crime is zoomed out of proportion to make them bad, evil to justify washing hands from responsibility of host population. Fortunately, still majority Bangladeshi people maintain enough sympathetic views about Rohingyas.

 

[Goku]

As usual, i see your countrymen doubt your credentials owing to your hard hitting, fact-laden statements but don't let that deter you. Burmese are considered as savages by the Bangladeshis when it's the other way around. Rohingyas are the most backward and regressive thinking community in our neck of the woods.

I would even welcome a Bangladeshi to my state, but these Rohingyas-never ever.. Though Bangladeshis are maintaining distance from the Rohingyas they want other countries to house them! Sheer duplicity, imo.

They dont care about Rohingyas , they just want geo political and economical advantage that come from it like aid , relevance on global stage

 

[Avicenna]

As usual, i see your countrymen doubt your credentials owing to your hard hitting, fact-laden statements but don't let that deter you. Burmese are considered as savages by the Bangladeshis when it's the other way around. Rohingyas are the most backward and regressive thinking community in our neck of the woods.

I would even welcome a Bangladeshi to my state, but these Rohingyas-never ever.. Though Bangladeshis are maintaining distance from the Rohingyas they want other countries to house them! Sheer duplicity, imo.

That guy @Riyad is a piece of work.

Some of what he says is valid.

But I have NEVER heard a Bangladeshi say that BD was better off a part of India.

 

[namefield_empty]

They dont care about Rohingyas , they just want geo political and economical advantage that come from it like aid , relevance on global stage

Also that the Bangladeshis know that there is little to differentiate these Rohingyas from their citizens, and the rampant corruption in Bangladesh would help these refugees get identification documents and would merge into their society seamlessly. Hence the Rohingyas are being caged in a secluded place under inhuman conditions by BD government.

 

[Avicenna]

Also that the Bangladeshis know that there is little to differentiate these Rohingyas from their citizens, and the rampant corruption in Bangladesh would help these refugees get identification documents and would merge into their society seamlessly. Hence the Rohingyas are being caged in a secluded place under inhuman conditions by BD government.

The Rohingya situation was foisted upon Bangladesh by Myanmar.

Of course Bd doesn’t want 700000 refugees inside its border.

But it’s doing the best it can under the circumstances.

 

[namefield_empty]

But I have NEVER heard a Bangladeshi say that BD was better off a part of India.

Very few Indians too would say that BD should have remained a part of India, we are better off as friendly neighbouring countries. I think what @Riyad means to say is that BD culture (aside from minor religious differences) is almost similar and heavily influenced by India, if he harbour dreams of BD becoming a part of India or something along those lines then he's wrong.

Compared to the other BD members whose posts reverberate in the same frequency, Riyad comes along as a breath of fresh air. I, for one, appreciate his contrarian point of view and insightful posts.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Also that the Bangladeshis know that there is little to differentiate these Rohingyas from their citizens, and the rampant corruption in Bangladesh would help these refugees get identification documents and would merge into their society seamlessly. Hence the Rohingyas are being caged in a secluded place under inhuman conditions by BD government.

Condition is not inhuman there. More than 150 international NGOs are working there to provide their basic needs. We have cleared more than 6000 acres of land to house them. This amount of land is adequate to house 1 million refugees. Moreover, most of the cost of sustaining them coming from Bangladesh's own resources, not from international donors.

I know you Indian Hindus are mad at Bangladesh for not helping Myanmar to ethnically cleanse the Rohingya Muslims from their land at the expanse of it's own well being. It put into question mark about your own desire to cleanse eastern part of India from Muslim by branding them as Bangladeshi illegals. But Bangladesh is not helping your desired goal of Muslim free country is what making you to rage against Bangladesh. And in one hand declaring Rohingyas to be the ''evilest'' people in the world yet at the same time lashing out at Bangladesh for supposed ''inhuman treatment'' of Rohingyas for not letting them diffuse with Bangladeshi population. But to frustrate your expectation, Bangladesh will keep this Rohingya issue alive as long as it needed until their eventual repatriation happen. Your dream of Muslim free India and Myanmar will not come true.

 

[Pakistansdefender]

Bangladeshis should have remained in India as East Bengal but religious violence in Bengal let us secede from India and join Pakistan and Jinnah could not refuse East Bengal as part of Pakistan. Culturally we are very close to India's Bengal but due to historical reasons we are separate from Indian Bengalis.

You can join back ....

Bangladeshis should have remained in India as East Bengal but religious violence in Bengal let us secede from India and join Pakistan and Jinnah could not refuse East Bengal as part of Pakistan. Culturally we are very close to India's Bengal but due to historical reasons we are separate from Indian Bengalis.

Elect nusrat jehan the true embelem of Muslim pious women as your pm of united bengal .

 

[Black_cats]

@Black_cats

Do you really consider that fifth columnists comment as divine truth? It is true due to lack of opportunities some Rohingyas are engaged with crime and taking over work due to lower pay so local population has some issue with it. But Bangladesh as a whole is with the Rohingya cause and want their safe return. You can compare it with the Afghan refugees in Pakistan. Do Pakistanis really hate Afghans? I highly doubt that though Afghans are involved with crime in Pakistan but not all of them.

 

[namefield_empty]

I know you Indians Hindus are mad about Bangladesh to not helping Myanmar to ethnically cleanse the Rohingya Muslims from their land at the expanse of it's own well being.

This doesn't make any sense. For one, other than the humanitarian angle and security threat the Rohingya issue doesn't concern us directly. Secondly, it's time you stopped putting blame on others for your own incapability.

It put into question mark about your own desire to cleanse eastern part of India from Muslim by branding them as Bangladeshi illegals.

Equal numbers of Hindus and Muslims have entered north-east from your country, so stop viewing everything from the perspective of religion. Since you have already branded me as anti-muslim Hindu let me tell you that your Hindus entered NE as you Muslims in BD burnt their homes down and made them flee from your country. Even today you won't find the Hindus raise much objection about the NRC , though their names are excluded too. It's only your BD muslims that are misleading people by claiming it as a communal exercise.

Rohingyas to be the ''evilest'' people in the world yet at the same time lashing out at Bangladesh for supposed ''inhuman treatment'' of Rohingyas.

Don't know about the bold part, but they are backward thinking and very prone to radicalization and are mainly used in Bangladesh for smuggling and robbery.

But to frustrate your expectation, Bangladesh will keep this Rohingya issue alive as long as it needed until their eventual repatriation happen

What else can you do? 1 million refugees shoved into Bangladesh in broad daylight and all we see you do is grovel before the world powers.

 

[third eye]

We must thank Jinnah for his wisdom that he rejected such proposal of annexing Burmese territory to East Pakistan / Bangladesh. Rohingyas and Bangladeshis are rivals. We Bangladeshis make fun of anyone who is uncultured and behave weirdly as Rohingyas. They are hated by majority of Bangladeshis because they are involved in theft, smuggling, bred like rabbits, primitive mentality, militant mentality, using fake Bangladeshi ID card and going abroad with Bangladeshi passport.

.. and posters here grudge India for not accepting Rohingiyas !

 

[Black_cats]

.. and posters here grudge India for not accepting Rohingiyas !

Posters here say India is helping Myanmar despite the genocide carried by them. Rohingyas are most persecuted people on earth. Due to that reason many criminal and terrorist groups are taking advantage of them. How many years you would like to confined yourself in a congested refugee camp with no work and life. Please note they have no nationality as well so that they can go anywhere.

 

[third eye]

Posters here say India is helping Myanmar despite the genocide carried by them. Rohingyas are most persecuted people on earth. Due to that reason many criminal and terrorist groups are taking advantage of them. How many years you would like to confined yourself in a congested refugee camp with no work and life. Please note they have no nationality as well so that they can go anywhere.

Heartbreaking..

What are the options to mitigate the ' sufferings"

 

[Beast]

Do you really consider that fifth columnists comment as divine truth? It is true due to lack of opportunities some Rohingyas are engaged with crime and taking over work due to lower pay so local population has some issue with it. But Bangladesh as a whole is with the Rohingya cause and want their safe return. You can compare it with the Afghan refugees in Pakistan. Do Pakistanis really hate Afghans? I highly doubt that though Afghans are involved with crime in Pakistan but not all of them.

I doubt that. Your compatriot just reveal his true intention and it's only you who insist your own view.

 

[Homo Sapiens]

Even today you won't find the Hindus raise much objection about the NRC , though their names are excluded too. It's only your BD muslims that are misleading people by claiming it as a communal exercise.

Because Hindus are confident that they can settle in India no matter how much Assamese ultra-nationalist raise hue and cry. BJP govt. is with them. All the Hindus outside Assam are with them. So they can look at NRC with carefree attitude. But for Muslims, no such privilege exist. So, reasonably they are worried and rightfully pointing it's communal agenda.