What's new

When Islamic atheism thrived

Status
Not open for further replies.
to do that one must have authority over his faith atleast!!!! people can be convinced easily as they dont put effort in knowing their own religion... as i said earlier in my post, no one would bother to take these questions to an islamic scholar to get them answered... would anyone??

Buddy, People try to but the problem is of perspective. Even scholar twists people's faith with their perspective. Many a times it is even difficult to understand whether a learned person is scholar or not for e.g Zaid Hamid is treated as scholars by someone with his perspective but for most of us he is a nut nothing else.

TTP, OBL, AQ etc have their theory of Islam. In India, RSS, VHP, Bajrang Dal etc have their perspective of Hinduism. Many of them are learned scholar but wrong with their faith. Would you mind if people question them with their confused faith? They will move only on wrong way as they are.
 
Buddy, People try to but the problem is of perspective. Even scholar twists people's faith with their perspective. Many a times it is even difficult to understand whether a learned person is scholar or not for e.g Zaid Hamid is treated as scholars by someone with his perspective but for most of us he is a nut nothing else.

TTP, OBL, AQ etc have their theory of Islam. In India, RSS, VHP, Bajrang Dal etc have their perspective of Hinduism. Many of them are learned scholar but wrong with their faith. Would you mind if people question them with their confused faith? They will move only on wrong way as they are.
the writer of this topic is doing the same aint it??? you have every right to find out answers regarding any religion, but you have to ask it from someone who has some authority over it, in Islam a scholar is a person whom we call 'mufti' that guy puts up around 16 years of studies and has way more knowledge then an average muslim, so go up to him and if he aint able to satisfy you then you have a reason to point fingers...

but tell me honestly she has put up those questions on a forum, where the majority doesnt have sound knowledge of Islam, dont you think she would go through a proper channel if searching for the answer??

its same like, you claim you can prove theory of relativity wrong, but rather then going to a professor you are putting up your points in front of some high school guys n looking for answer!!!
 
The thread started wanted a discourse among the members about what she thought was interesting which doesn’t necessarily implies she adheres to what was posted, and if she does, nobody has the right to gut her thought. It’s her understanding and everyone needs to respect that. Islam stresses about religious freedom the people having the freedom to choose their religion or have non. Anyways this interesting thread has now being derailed by overzealous numbwits.

@ Emo

Al-Rawandi and Al-Razi had the pleasure of living under the times when enlightenment was all too high and noble. Unfortunately we live in post enlightenment era.
 
and you seem very intelligent to quote from sahih muslim its self and then say that ooh, prophet just said not to quote him.

i am argueing that the holy bible was itself written after a long time of the death of prophet isa, but quran was written in the days of prophet muhammad, dont you get the simple point, can status of hadiths be compared to the bible in the first place??

You sir, are a dumbass.:hitwall:

I was comparing the double standards of traditionalist muslims not comparing the bible and hadith.
 
I was comparing the double standards of traditionalist muslims not comparing the bible and hadith.

by mis-interperating Hadees? :angry: :flame: :tdown: :confused: :sick: :cry: :cry: :cry:
 
Wrong - Prophet Muhammad (PBUH) himself used to instruct peoples to write his words and Sahabas used to write his teachings. Whatever important speech he used to give - he used to repeat three times so that everybody should understand clearly - and Sahabas used to write it down.


Wrong again - Its a famous Hadeeth and you are misinterperating this Hadeeth

Please read this link Stages of Recording Hadith - Reading Islam.com

Hadeeth are the teachings of the Prophet - I don't want to start about the importance of ahadeeth - and i agree there can be some fake ahadees - indirectly claimed to be Prophet's words - but it does not mean you discredit other millions of sayings of the Prophet. If you reject Hadeeth you cannot perform any Islamic ritual whatsoever. You cannot find out how to pray, you cannot find out how to perform hajj, you cannot find out how much to pay in Zakat. You will be contradicting with all the basic foundations of Islam (The pillars of Islam) and then start about daily lives.

Qur'an gives you the guidance and most of the times it gives you hints - that you require ahadeeth for more details. It talks about a certain issue but the whole detail you get from the ahadees. It is true there cannot be any book in the world that cannot be changed except the The Holy Qur'an which is intact since the first day. But at the same point Hadeeth are very helpful source to understand the Islam. You cannot - oh forget it - stupid thread :angry:
The Jews, hundreds of years after Moses's death created Mishnah (hadith, sayings) and Gemarrah (sunna, Actions) and uphold them and the invented laws in them rather than the TORAH (revealed word of God).

In the city of Nicene 300 years after the death of Jesus, the concept of Trinity was CREATED, and is now the primary source of a Christian's belief in defiance of the Bible which advocates the absolute worship of God Alone.

The Muslims 150- 200 years after the death of Muhammed CREATED another source of their religion with the Quran, "Hadith and Sunnah", falsely attributed to the prophet Muhammed, and in defiance of the Quran. Today most Muslims have discarded the Quran in favor of Hadith and Sunnah.

"If only the people of the scripture believe and lead a righteous life, we will then remit their sins, and admit them into gardens of bliss. If only they would uphold the TORAH, and the GOSPEL, and what is sent down to them herein (QURAN) from their Lord, they would be showered with blessings from above them and from beneath their feet. Some of them are righteous, but MANY of them are evil-doers." 5:65-66

(No Mishnah, Gemarrah, Hadith, Sunna or trinity here.)

(1) Ibn Saeed Al-Khudry reported that the messenger of God had said,

"Do not write anything from me EXCEPT QURAN. Anyone who wrote anything other than the Quran shall erase it."

The following historical incident happened about 30 years after the death of the Prophet Muhammed and shows that the Prophet never canceled his order not to write but the Quran. The hadiths books however contained some fabricated hadiths that are considered by the same Hadiths scholars as very weak, trying to indicate that Muhammed changed his view about writing the hadiths. The readers of the hadith to follow, that happened about 30 years after the death of the Prophet, will conclude by themselves that the Prophet Muhammed never authorized the writing of the hadiths since the time he told his followers not to write but the Quran.

(2) From Ibn Hanbal;

Zayd Ibn Thabit (The Prophet's closest revelation writer) visited the Khalifa Mu'aawiyah (more than 30 years after the Prophet's death), and told him a story about the Prophet. Mu'aawiyah liked the story and ordered someone to write it down. But Zayd said. " the messenger of God ordered us NEVER to write anything of his hadith,"


(3) The famous book, "Ulum Al-Hadith" by Ibn Al-Salah, reports a hadith by Abu Hurayra in which Abu Hurayra said the messenger of God came out to us while we were writing his hadiths and said; "What are you writing?" We said, "Hadiths that we hear from you, messenger of God." He said, "A book other than the book of God ?!" We said, "Should we talk about you?" He said, Talk about me, that would be fine, but those who will lie will go to Hell. Abu Hurayra said, we collected what we wrote of Hadiths and burned them in fire.

(4) In the famous book, "Taq-yeed Al-Ilm", Abu Hurayra said, the messenger of God was informed that some people are writing his hadiths. He took to the pulpit of the mosque and said, "What are these books that I heard you wrote? I am just a human being. Anyone who has any of these writings should bring it here. Abu Hurayra said we collected all these and burned them in fire.


(5) Again, in the book "Taq-yeed Al-Ilm", Abu Saeed Al-Khudry said, " I asked the messenger of God a permission to write his hadiths, but he refused to give me a permission."

(6) The farewell Pilgrimage of the Prophet Muhammed is a corner stone in the Muslim history. The Final Sermon given by the Prophet during this pilgrimage was witnessed by thousands of Muslims. There are however THREE versions of this sermon in the Hadiths books. This by itself reflects the degree of corruption of the Hadiths books as this is the most witnessed speech of the prophet Muhammed.

1- First version, " I left for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the book of God and my Family. Muslim 44/4, Nu2408; Ibn Hanbal

4/366; darimi 23/1, nu 3319.

This is the version made up by the Shiite Muslims.

2-Second version, "I left for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the book of God and my Sunnah" . Muwatta, 46/3

This is the version made up by the Sunni Muslims.

3- Third version, "I left for you what if you hold up to, you will never be misguided, the BOOK OF GOD." Muslim 15/19, nu 1218; Ibn Majah 25/84, Abu dawud 11/56.

And ONLY the book of God.This is the version hated by the Sunni and Shiite Muslims alike. This is the ONLY version that agrees with the repeated assertion in the Quran that Muhammed's message is ONLY the QURAN. Many Sunni Muslims and Shiite Muslims do not even know that this version of the sermon exists. In reality, they do not want to know, the truth hurts, but Hell fire hurts much more.

As for the notion that Hadiths were written as early as the Prophet's time, this is historically correct but the prophet himself and those who ruled after him condemned these writings and looked at those who wrote these Hadiths with disgrace. The hadiths books mentioned that the Prophet Muhammed burned the collected hadiths, and was very angry at people making "another book with the book of Allah." Abu Baker and Omar Ibn Al-Khattab, were also reported to burn the Hadiths collections.

This prohibition of hadiths was continued until Omar Ibn Abdel-Aziz permitted the writing of Hadiths and Sunna, then many books and (Kararees) appeared containing Hadiths, e.g. Ibn Greeg, Malik Ibn Anas, Mohammed Ibn Is'haq. The most famous from among these were the book of Malik Ibn Anas, (Al-Muwattaa). that had about 500 Hadiths. At the end of the second century the books known as (Masaned) appeared, e.g. the Masnad of Ahmed Ibn Hanbal that has about 40,000 Hadiths. In the first half of the third century the famous six books of hadiths appeared and these are the books used by many of the scholars these days. 1- Sahih Bukhary. 2- Sahih Moslem. 3- Sunan Abu Daoud. 4-Sunan Al-Termethy. 5-Sunan Al-Nesaay. 6- Sunan Ibn Mageh.
 
The Jews, hundreds of years after Moses's death created Mishnah (hadith, sayings) and Gemarrah (sunna, Actions) and uphold them and the invented laws in them rather than the TORAH (revealed word of God)
The Talmud is the compilation of Oral Law, which comments on and expands the Torah.

Jews who didn't follow Oral Law in addition to the Torah are called Karaites. They are a minority of Jews today. Apparently these were the Jews who inhabited the Arabian Peninsula in the time of Muhammed and are referred to in the Koran.
 
The Muslims 150- 200 years after the death of Muhammed CREATED another source of their religion with the Quran, "Hadith and Sunnah", falsely attributed to the prophet Muhammed, and in defiance of the Quran. Today most Muslims have discarded the Quran in favor of Hadith and Sunnah.

Your this statement is more than enough for me to call you an Idiot :angry: :flame: and i don't want to waste my time reading rest of your post and the posts you make after that in this thread.

No Muslim can discard the Holy Qur'an in favour of Hadeeth. Qur'an is a word of God. Simple, Nothing can stand against it. All Muslims are in concensus that if any Hadees you see that contradicts/collides with the teachings of the Qur'an it will be discarded automatically.

Hadees is a source of Information and is not a Holy Book of God

Idiot :angry:
 
Your this statement is more than enough for me to call you an Idiot :angry: :flame: and i don't want to waste my time reading rest of your post and the posts you make after that in this thread.

No Muslim can discard the Holy Qur'an in favour of Hadeeth. Qur'an is a word of God. Simple, Nothing can stand against it. All Muslims are in concensus that if any Hadees you see that contradicts/collides with the teachings of the Qur'an it will be discarded automatically.

Hadees is a source of Information and is not a Holy Book of God

Idiot :angry:

It seems you misunderstood me... What i meant was that traditionalist muslims have turned the hadith into a religious source, in essence disregarding the Quran as the SOLE religious source as determined by Allah:

"Shall I seek other than God as a source of law, when He has revealed to you this book fully detailed?" 6:114

"Obey God and obey the messenger. If you shall turn away then the sole of the messenger is to deliver the message (the Quran)"

"It (the Quran) is a revelation from the Lord of the universe. Had he (Muhammad) uttered any other teachings, We would have grabbed him by the right, and We would have severed his Wateen (Major artery of the heart), none of you could have helped him." 69:43-47

"These are God's revelations that We recite to you truthfully. In which Hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?" 45:6

You don't have an answer for the rest of my post either
:D
 
Last edited:
The Talmud is the compilation of Oral Law, which comments on and expands the Torah.

Jews who didn't follow Oral Law in addition to the Torah are called Karaites. They are a minority of Jews today. Apparently these were the Jews who inhabited the Arabian Peninsula in the time of Muhammed and are referred to in the Koran.

Yeah..basically the talmud for orthodox jews is what hadith is for traditionalist muslims.
 
You just can't face the facts can you... You've turned the hadith into a religious source, in essence disregarding the Quran as the SOLE religious source as determined by Allah.

You don't have an answer for the rest of my post either
:D

didn't bother to read your post - as prove your worth in your last post.

I don't know why peoples try to defend something - that they know nothing about it?

You could be the only person/Muslim on earth who will take Hadees before Qur'an. Qur'an is Qur'an - Its a word of God - Period

Hadees is the teachings of our Prophet - Not the word of God

Don't reply again or i am gonnai complain
 
didn't bother to read your post - as prove your worth in your last post.

I don't know why peoples try to defend something - that they know nothing about it?

You could be the only person/Muslim on earth who will take Hadees before Qur'an. Qur'an is Qur'an - Its a word of God - Period

Hadees is the teachings of our Prophet - Not the word of God

Don't reply again or i am gonnai complain

I misunderstood you and so did you...i've edited my last post. i Hope you read it since i never said i take the hadith before the Quran.

For your clarification, i don't take Hadith as religious sources.
 
I misunderstood you and so did you...i've edited my last post. i Hope you read it since i never said i take the hadith before the Quran.

For your clarification, i don't take Hadith as religious sources.

Fair enough :)

Now lets close this chapter - This is not a religious forum - Religious discussions are not allowed here in this forum - I have an answer to each and every single word u posted in the above post - but that will lead to another debate

You may PM me later - and i will reply you in detail when i have some time - Its easy - Its something that i have talked over n over again - i keep meeting peoples of your belief - but trust me - everytime they are satisifed with my answer but fail to answer my questions
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Country Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom