What's new

When a Jew became hero of a Muslim nation Bangladesh

Status
Not open for further replies.

Riyad

FULL MEMBER
Joined
Jul 30, 2015
Messages
1,525
Reaction score
-5
Country
Bangladesh
Location
Bangladesh
Hero of Bangladesh war Jack Jacob dies at 92

Lt Gen Jack Farj Rafael Jacob, a celebrated Indian Army officer who negotiated Pakistan’s surrender in the 1971 war, died in Delhi’s Army Hospital Wednesday morning. He was 92. The general, who played a key role in the war leading to the liberation of Bangladesh, he had no family in India.

1452745663_2.jpg



Hero of Bangladesh war Jack Jacob dies at 92 | The Indian Express


How Jack Jacob negotiated Pak’s surrender

When General A A K Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan, invited Jacob to discuss a ceasefire, Jacob flew to Dhaka with an instrument of surrender.

Written by Sushant Singh | New Delhi | Updated: January 14, 2016 1:45 am


jackjacob759.jpg


Pak’s Gen Niazi surrenders to Lt Gen Aurora. Jacob is on the far right. Express archive.

Lt Gen Jack Farj Rafael Jacob, who died Wednesday, was most celebrated for his role in the 1971 war when he was Chief of Staff of Eastern Command in Calcutta, his birthplace. The endgame of Pakistan’s surrender on December 16, 1971, has his imprint.

When General A A K Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan, invited Jacob to discuss a ceasefire, Jacob flew to Dhaka with an instrument of surrender. In his book Surrender at Dacca – Birth of a Nation, Jacob writes he did not fully inform Army headquarters, including Field Marshal S H F J Manekshaw, of the instrument of surrender.

In Dhaka he told General Niazi, he writes, that by accepting his offer of a public surrender, he and his defeated soldiers would receive the protection of the Indian Army. Else, the consequences were for Niazi’s to face. There were only 3,000 Indian troops in Dhaka against Pakistan’s 26,000 but Niazi accepted Jacob’s offer, leading to surrender of 93,000 Pakistanis. Niazi later told the Pakistani enquiry commission on the 1971 war that “Jacob blackmailed me”.

Jacob’s recounting of his role in the 1971 war created a controversy. He claimed in his book he took the decision to race to capture Dhaka, against Manekshaw’s orders to capture other areas. Many felt Jacob was trying to appropriate a bigger role during the war at the cost of other top leaders such as Lt General J S Aurora and Manekshaw.

Born in 1923 to a Jewish family with Iraqi roots, Jacob went to a boarding school in Darjeeling and joined the Indian Army in 1941, at age 18, against the wishes of his father. The war in North Africa was over by the time his artillery brigade was dispatched there to reinforce the British Army. From there, Jacob’s unit was sent to Burma where he fought the Japanese till the end of the World War II.

Jacob retired in 1978. After an unsuccessful stint in business, he joined public life as an adviser to the BJP on military affairs. He served as the governor of Goa in 1998, a period of political instability in the state. From there, he moved to Punjab as a governor.

Jacob was a skilled painter, a lover of antique art, a fan of Western classical music, an enthusiastic angler and a lover of poetry. While fighting in World War II, he carried a slim, rice-paper edition of the Oxford Book of Modern Verse in the back pocket of his uniform, which he read during lulls in battle.

Jacob was also celebrated in Israel, where his uniform hangs in the Israeli military museum. He is featured in John Colvin’s book on Jewish military heroes, Lions of Judah. Jacob was an advocate of strong India-Israel relations.
But he rejected all offers to move to Israel. “I am proud to be a Jew, but am Indian through and through. I was born in India and served her my whole life. This is where I want to die,” he once said.

A wish that came true Wednesday.

How Jack Jacob negotiated Pak’s surrender | The Indian Express


 
.
Hero of Bangladesh war Jack Jacob dies at 92

Lt Gen Jack Farj Rafael Jacob, a celebrated Indian Army officer who negotiated Pakistan’s surrender in the 1971 war, died in Delhi’s Army Hospital Wednesday morning. He was 92. The general, who played a key role in the war leading to the liberation of Bangladesh, he had no family in India.

1452745663_2.jpg



Hero of Bangladesh war Jack Jacob dies at 92 | The Indian Express


How Jack Jacob negotiated Pak’s surrender

When General A A K Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan, invited Jacob to discuss a ceasefire, Jacob flew to Dhaka with an instrument of surrender.

Written by Sushant Singh | New Delhi | Updated: January 14, 2016 1:45 am


jackjacob759.jpg


Pak’s Gen Niazi surrenders to Lt Gen Aurora. Jacob is on the far right. Express archive.

Lt Gen Jack Farj Rafael Jacob, who died Wednesday, was most celebrated for his role in the 1971 war when he was Chief of Staff of Eastern Command in Calcutta, his birthplace. The endgame of Pakistan’s surrender on December 16, 1971, has his imprint.

When General A A K Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan, invited Jacob to discuss a ceasefire, Jacob flew to Dhaka with an instrument of surrender. In his book Surrender at Dacca – Birth of a Nation, Jacob writes he did not fully inform Army headquarters, including Field Marshal S H F J Manekshaw, of the instrument of surrender.

In Dhaka he told General Niazi, he writes, that by accepting his offer of a public surrender, he and his defeated soldiers would receive the protection of the Indian Army. Else, the consequences were for Niazi’s to face. There were only 3,000 Indian troops in Dhaka against Pakistan’s 26,000 but Niazi accepted Jacob’s offer, leading to surrender of 93,000 Pakistanis. Niazi later told the Pakistani enquiry commission on the 1971 war that “Jacob blackmailed me”.

Jacob’s recounting of his role in the 1971 war created a controversy. He claimed in his book he took the decision to race to capture Dhaka, against Manekshaw’s orders to capture other areas. Many felt Jacob was trying to appropriate a bigger role during the war at the cost of other top leaders such as Lt General J S Aurora and Manekshaw.

Born in 1923 to a Jewish family with Iraqi roots, Jacob went to a boarding school in Darjeeling and joined the Indian Army in 1941, at age 18, against the wishes of his father. The war in North Africa was over by the time his artillery brigade was dispatched there to reinforce the British Army. From there, Jacob’s unit was sent to Burma where he fought the Japanese till the end of the World War II.

Jacob retired in 1978. After an unsuccessful stint in business, he joined public life as an adviser to the BJP on military affairs. He served as the governor of Goa in 1998, a period of political instability in the state. From there, he moved to Punjab as a governor.

Jacob was a skilled painter, a lover of antique art, a fan of Western classical music, an enthusiastic angler and a lover of poetry. While fighting in World War II, he carried a slim, rice-paper edition of the Oxford Book of Modern Verse in the back pocket of his uniform, which he read during lulls in battle.

Jacob was also celebrated in Israel, where his uniform hangs in the Israeli military museum. He is featured in John Colvin’s book on Jewish military heroes, Lions of Judah. Jacob was an advocate of strong India-Israel relations.
But he rejected all offers to move to Israel. “I am proud to be a Jew, but am Indian through and through. I was born in India and served her my whole life. This is where I want to die,” he once said.

A wish that came true Wednesday.

How Jack Jacob negotiated Pak’s surrender | The Indian Express

There have been many Jewish heroes within the Islamic World; especially during the Crusades when they fought side to side with Muslims soldiers to defend Jerusalem and other cities or when they single handedly held back the Crusaders for a month at Haifa. Jews were regarded as honest and trustworthy within the Islamic world. Zionism, Israel and the occupation destroyed their reputation.
 
.
He was a hero......Salute
 
. .
Indian military worked with the terrorists to pave the way for the so called "Liberation" and this man didn't do anything exceptional.
 
.
Indian military worked with the terrorists to pave the way for the so called "Liberation" and this man didn't do anything exceptional.
You need to read the part where he negotiated surrender with Niazi despite being in a weaker position.

Had Niazi and troops put upon fierce resistance of fight to death, it would have taken India atleast a month to capture call in necessary reinforcements and capture Dhaka.

In the mean time Poland had proposed a resolution at UN asking for Indian troops to vacate East Pakistan and exercise restraint. Soviets had clearly warned they would not veto any more resolution.
This resolution being accepted in the UN could have led to loss of Indian gains and prevention of formation of Bangladesh.
 
.
You need to read the part where he negotiated surrender with Niazi despite being in a weaker position.

Had Niazi and troops put upon fierce resistance of fight to death, it would have taken India atleast a month to capture call in necessary reinforcements and capture Dhaka.

In the mean time Poland had proposed a resolution at UN asking for Indian troops to vacate East Pakistan and exercise restraint. Soviets had clearly warned they would not veto any more resolution.
This resolution being accepted in the UN could have led to loss of Indian gains and prevention of formation of Bangladesh.
Like i said, Indian military was in cahoots with the Bengali terrorists, collectively they outnumbered Pakistan military in East Pakistan by a long margin. Pakistan military over there didn't have much of a choice, especially the well-being was at stake. It's an other issue that they didn't fight to the end and the leadership was absolutely flawed, but to say this man turned the 71 war into a victory is a total BLUFF. The one who planned to rope in the Bengali terrorists deserves more credit.
 
.
There have been many Jewish heroes within the Islamic World; especially during the Crusades when they fought side to side with Muslims soldiers to defend Jerusalem and other cities or when they single handedly held back the Crusaders for a month at Haifa. Jews were regarded as honest and trustworthy within the Islamic world. Zionism, Israel and the occupation destroyed their reputation.

Well, Even in recent time before 1947, Hindus and Muslims fuaght for a common cause "Freedom". Rest is History.

OTOH,

Time and Again , Sikhs , Jews and Muslims have Played EXCEPTIONAL Roles for the Defence of the Motherland in India.
Chandpuri , Jacob and Abdul Kalam to name a few.

Moreover, As far as jews are concerned, India ( People to people , Politically , Culturally , Economically and Defence ) has strongest ties with Israel. Infact Modi i his first meeting with Netanyahu mentiond Sir Jacob's name as well.
 
. . .
The Indians should be thanking Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto. Of course Bhutto is a hero to Indians but not Bengalis.
 
. .
Hero of Bangladesh war Jack Jacob dies at 92

Lt Gen Jack Farj Rafael Jacob, a celebrated Indian Army officer who negotiated Pakistan’s surrender in the 1971 war, died in Delhi’s Army Hospital Wednesday morning. He was 92. The general, who played a key role in the war leading to the liberation of Bangladesh, he had no family in India.

1452745663_2.jpg



Hero of Bangladesh war Jack Jacob dies at 92 | The Indian Express


How Jack Jacob negotiated Pak’s surrender

When General A A K Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan, invited Jacob to discuss a ceasefire, Jacob flew to Dhaka with an instrument of surrender.

Written by Sushant Singh | New Delhi | Updated: January 14, 2016 1:45 am


jackjacob759.jpg


Pak’s Gen Niazi surrenders to Lt Gen Aurora. Jacob is on the far right. Express archive.

Lt Gen Jack Farj Rafael Jacob, who died Wednesday, was most celebrated for his role in the 1971 war when he was Chief of Staff of Eastern Command in Calcutta, his birthplace. The endgame of Pakistan’s surrender on December 16, 1971, has his imprint.

When General A A K Niazi, commander of Pakistani forces in East Pakistan, invited Jacob to discuss a ceasefire, Jacob flew to Dhaka with an instrument of surrender. In his book Surrender at Dacca – Birth of a Nation, Jacob writes he did not fully inform Army headquarters, including Field Marshal S H F J Manekshaw, of the instrument of surrender.

In Dhaka he told General Niazi, he writes, that by accepting his offer of a public surrender, he and his defeated soldiers would receive the protection of the Indian Army. Else, the consequences were for Niazi’s to face. There were only 3,000 Indian troops in Dhaka against Pakistan’s 26,000 but Niazi accepted Jacob’s offer, leading to surrender of 93,000 Pakistanis. Niazi later told the Pakistani enquiry commission on the 1971 war that “Jacob blackmailed me”.

Jacob’s recounting of his role in the 1971 war created a controversy. He claimed in his book he took the decision to race to capture Dhaka, against Manekshaw’s orders to capture other areas. Many felt Jacob was trying to appropriate a bigger role during the war at the cost of other top leaders such as Lt General J S Aurora and Manekshaw.

Born in 1923 to a Jewish family with Iraqi roots, Jacob went to a boarding school in Darjeeling and joined the Indian Army in 1941, at age 18, against the wishes of his father. The war in North Africa was over by the time his artillery brigade was dispatched there to reinforce the British Army. From there, Jacob’s unit was sent to Burma where he fought the Japanese till the end of the World War II.

Jacob retired in 1978. After an unsuccessful stint in business, he joined public life as an adviser to the BJP on military affairs. He served as the governor of Goa in 1998, a period of political instability in the state. From there, he moved to Punjab as a governor.

Jacob was a skilled painter, a lover of antique art, a fan of Western classical music, an enthusiastic angler and a lover of poetry. While fighting in World War II, he carried a slim, rice-paper edition of the Oxford Book of Modern Verse in the back pocket of his uniform, which he read during lulls in battle.

Jacob was also celebrated in Israel, where his uniform hangs in the Israeli military museum. He is featured in John Colvin’s book on Jewish military heroes, Lions of Judah. Jacob was an advocate of strong India-Israel relations.
But he rejected all offers to move to Israel. “I am proud to be a Jew, but am Indian through and through. I was born in India and served her my whole life. This is where I want to die,” he once said.

A wish that came true Wednesday.

How Jack Jacob negotiated Pak’s surrender | The Indian Express

salute sir, RIP
Bangladesh is not majority Muslim nation. It's more like fasiq munafiq Majority nation and munafiqs are worst than kafir.
and you should change nationality to a arab country lol
 
.
There have been many Jewish heroes within the Islamic World; especially during the Crusades when they fought side to side with Muslims soldiers to defend Jerusalem and other cities or when they single handedly held back the Crusaders for a month at Haifa.
I'm very surprised you know this bit of history, which is usually forgotten.

Jews were regarded as honest and trustworthy within the Islamic world. Zionism, Israel and the occupation destroyed their reputation.
No,sir. Relentless propaganda endorsed by a "shallow and fascistic mindset" does that. Today, Pakistan's education establishment forbids the correction of any slanders against the Jewish State as "challenges to the ideology of Pakistan": link. So if Arabs teach their children from birth that Israeli Jews are evil and should be stabbed in the back, or that Israel is to blame for all the world's ills, or that Israel is to blame for gravity, anything else that in passing is classed as anti-Israel, there is nothing Pakistani teachers and professors are supposed to do to correct it.
 
. .
Status
Not open for further replies.

Pakistan Affairs Latest Posts

Back
Top Bottom